Political Gabfest · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
Three Slate hosts connect the coming Democratic oversight fight to the NVIDIA resignation and China chip policy, with a failed Hegseth impeachment as the case study.
Tap a chapter to play it from that moment in the show's own player; the transcript opens there too.
“I have a very loud internal clock.” David Plotz · at 59:05 — ▶ hear it from here
The hosts open with Washington's next two years, after Trump named Stephen Miller chief of staff following a midterm rout. Emily Bazelon expects the White House to block subpoenas and silence witnesses, as it did in the first term, while Democrats make corruption their central theme. John Dickerson warns that scattershot probes can look like revenge, and that the strongest oversight targets one concrete failure, such as whether Pentagon leaders were warned about missile shortages.
NVIDIA's chief executive resigned amid an alleged affair with an employee and a business partner tied to Chinese intelligence. Matt Sheehan of the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace says the bigger stake is chip policy, since the CEO pressed to loosen export controls and chips sold to Malaysia may have reached China. He adds that Beijing is torn, because buying American chips undercuts its domestic producers, while its worry about AI safety is rising but still well below Washington's.
The panel then turned to the failed impeachment of Pete Hegseth, which stalled after 11 Democrats missed the vote while a single Republican supported it. Bazelon and Dickerson argue hearings should come first, so officials must answer questions before impeachment is considered. The episode closes with listener chatter, including David Plotz's exit as CityCast CEO and an obituary for Judge Richard Posner.
Matt Sheehan is a senior fellow at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace who focuses on global technology and China.
Matt Sheehan said NVIDIA's chief executive had been pushing President Trump to loosen export controls and sell more chips to China and Southeast Asia. He called that personal influence a key reason the chip policy had held in the last few years, and said it might now shift.
“And very specifically, what he's been doing is he's been pushing to sell more chips to China.”Matt Sheehan · 30:02
Matt Sheehan said Anthropic and OpenAI describe AI risk as imminent, catastrophic and possibly existential. He said Chinese official discourse on the same risks is much lower, though it has been rising quickly since 2024.
“Anthropic, OpenAI, they say this is imminent, this is catastrophic, this is maybe existential, and we need to deal with it now.”Matt Sheehan · 37:48
Emily Bazelon said the failed impeachment of Pete Hegseth failed mostly because 11 Democrats did not show up for the vote. She said if they had all voted to continue impeachment, it would have kept going.
“it failed mostly because a bunch of Democrats, 11 of them, didn't show up.”Emily Bazelon · 48:35
John Dickerson said Stephen Miller has absolute loyalty to President Trump and knows how to work the inside of the system. He compared Miller's loyalty to Haldeman's loyalty to Nixon, saying it is a true belief rather than a performance.
“In other words, I don't think he has to fake it.”John Dickerson · 14:13
Emily Bazelon said the January 6th Select Committee hired a TV producer to make its hearings ready for television, with lots of clips for late night and social media. She cited it as a model Democrats could return to when investigating the Trump administration.
“they hired a TV producer to make those hearings like very TV ready”Emily Bazelon · 5:26
The hosts said the impeachment effort failed after 11 Democrats missed the vote, and that only one Republican supported it. They argued Democrats should hold hearings first and make officials answer questions about the Iran war before pursuing impeachment.
Matt Sheehan, a senior fellow at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, said NVIDIA's chief executive pushed President Trump to loosen export controls and sell more chips to China and Southeast Asia. He said the policy could now shift because that personal influence is gone. He also said chips sold into Malaysia were allegedly routed to Chinese companies and military buyers.
Matt Sheehan said Chinese officials see AI threats as further off than leading American labs such as Anthropic and OpenAI do. Beijing's first concern has been information control, followed by labor disruption and loss of control over models. Sheehan expects a real shift only after a scary incident inside China, perhaps next spring, though concern has risen sharply since 2023.
Emily Bazelon said the failed impeachment of Pete Hegseth looked shambolic, because 11 Democrats missed the vote and only one Republican backed it. She argued Democrats should instead hold hearings first and make officials answer questions about how the Iran war began, the way Congress once pressured officials to resign.
John Dickerson said Stephen Miller's appointment as chief of staff is a fair reading of a more aggressive White House. He said Miller knows how to work the inside levers of government and has absolute loyalty to Trump, which Dickerson compared to H.R. Haldeman's loyalty to Nixon. He warned that Miller could push immigration enforcement harder, raising political costs for the president.
Emily Bazelon said the next Democratic oversight push could copy the January 6 select committee, which hired a TV producer, used clips and brought surprise witnesses beyond the administration's control. She warned the main risk is too many targets, which could make the probes look like score-settling rather than work that leads to legislation.
David Plotz said he is stepping down as CEO of CityCast, the local news podcast company he founded six years ago, and handing the job to his co-founder, Andy McDaniel. He said CityCast reaches about 1.5 million listeners and readers and that he has a loud internal clock that makes him reset every six years. He asked listeners for job or project ideas for what he does next.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.
0:00Hello and welcome to the Slate Political Gab Fest. November 12th, 2026, the Welcome to Miller Time edition. I'm David Flotz of CityCast in Washington, D.C. From his Garrett in New York is John Dickerson. Hello, John. Hello. My name is David. You can say hello, David. Did you forget? No, I just thought I would just say a general hello. I mean, we've been doing this for 21 years. I couldn't give one slightly different entrance. I think you forgot my name. That was the hello. Somebody forgot my name. Uh, also in New York today, she's, I don't know. She's probably at the times doing some timesy thing is Emily Bazelon of the New York times magazine and Yale university law school. Hello, Emily. Hey guys.
1:03Uh, Emily has forgotten both of our names either this this week on the gap fest how will the next two years unfold in washington how what will president stephen miller do how will the democrats reign in an incorrigible administration then the stranger by the day jensenensen Wong scandal, NVIDIA scandal, and what it portends for America and America's relationship with China. And then the failed first impeachment of Pete Hegseth was this debacle for the Democrats. Why did it go so awry? Plus, we'll have cocktail chatter. We have a super exciting announcement for you. We're doing our annual conundrums show back in New York City city we're gonna be somewhere on tuesday december 15th for live taping where we're going to take on your thorniest dilemmas uh like which historical
1:54figure would make the worst roommate uh whether it's ever okay to recline your seat on a plane this show as many of you know it's a joy to at. We had an incredible time last year. It sold out mega fast. So here's how you can make sure you're going to get tickets. The tickets are not on sale just yet, but you can sign up now at slate.com slash gabfest live and why slate.com slash gabfest live and why there's a form where you can leave your email and we'll let you know when tickets are available. We're also going to limited number of VIP packages. If you want to hang out with us before the show, feed us conundrums and have a drink. And if you're a Slate Plus member, you'll get a discount on tickets. If you are not
2:33a member yet, you can go to slate.com slash gabfest plus to become a member. Again, Tuesday, December 15th in New York City, sign up at slate.com slash gabfest live NY to be first in line. We will be collecting your conundrums real soon. Hi, this is Brooke DeVard of Naked Beauty. Make your home feel like the holidays with Pura. From fresh pine to sweet nostalgic scents inspired by your favorite childhood memories, Pura's holiday collection brings the sense of the season to every room. Whether you're hosting a small gathering or a big holiday celebration or enjoying a quiet, cozy night at home, Pura makes holiday hosting simple and memorable. Set the perfect seasonal mood, Pura makes holiday hosting simple and memorable. Set the perfect seasonal
3:25mood with Pura. Explore the holiday collection and learn more at Pura.com. why takes patience intelligence determination why takes over 700 of the best journalists in the world united by a fearless drive to unearth the truth why is difficult and more important than ever before for the why financial times the next two years are shaping up to be roisterous and angry here in Washington, D.C. if the early signs post midterm elections are any guide. President Trump has responded to being routed in the election by naming his most belligerent and cruel and untamable aide, Stephen Miller, as his chief of staff. Miller was already, I think, by most accounts, the most powerful figure in the administration besides the president. Democrats with a 70 plus House majority and at least 55 Senate seats now that Mississippi has fallen to them are sharpening their knives. They lawyer up as the House Oversight incoming chair, Robert Garcia said. So, Emily, evidently, one narrative the next two years is going to be the
4:46conflict between an aggressive and investigatory Congress that's trying to restrain a president by using oversight and the power of the purse, and then an administration that has shown scorn for that. How does it look like this battle is going to be fought? Because you're going to have Congress that is going to try to investigate and try to use money to stop the president from doing what he wants to do. And then president who is really good at not allowing that to happen. Yeah, not allowing that to happen, meaning blocking subpoenas, telling government witnesses not to testify. I think we can expect all of that. That will be a reprise of the first Trump administration. However, Democrats were able to have some effective hearings in spite of that. That will be a reprise of the first Trump administration. However,
5:26Democrats were able to have some effective hearings in spite of that the first time around, right? So if you remember the January 6th Select Committee, they hired a TV producer to make those hearings like very TV ready and with lots of clips for late night and early morning and social media. And they had some surprise witnesses who were beyond the Trump administration's control. Well, that was the Biden administration, though. Yes. The January 6th investigation. Still, but there were still a lot of defying of subpoenas. The Trump witnesses did not cooperate. You're right. It was the Biden administration. But it all happened without the people who the Trump administration would not want to testify.
6:12And I think that's a model and they can go back to it. They also can call lots of private citizens as witnesses. You know, the theme is going to be corruption. They've made that clear. And people who don't work for the Trump administration don't get to justify subpoenas. So you can imagine hauling in CEOs, other people who have been fired or resigned from the administration are going to want to come in and testify. I think, to me, the risk for the Democrats is that there are too many targets, they become scattershot. And also just that they seem like they're settling scores and seeking revenge, as opposed to like, really trying to probe questions that then allow them to fix things through legislation, right? The purpose of congressional investigations is not
6:50revenge. It's supposed to be, I'm trying to find out about a problem so I can then go and address it. John, what about the kind of power of the purse question? Because one of the worrisome things for those of us who are of a historical and constitutional mind over which i am not over the past couple of years has been the way in which the president has essentially defied congressional uh legislation about how to spend money and where to spend money and everything from the destruction of usa id to the deprogramming of the Department of Education. Again and again, he has said, like, I'm just going to spend money in the way I want to spend money. All his stuff that he's done in Washington is essentially saying, I'm going to take the
7:34Interior Department budget and use it as my interior decorating budget. So how do you expect that the Democratic Congress is going to grapple with that? How are they going to grapple with it? And then how do they order it in their priority list of grappling? Because one of the tricky things about that, and it's a good one to focus on is it's maximally important with respect to the balance of powers and the shared power system. And yet, an unpopular Congress, because all Congresses are unpopular these days, advocating for its prerogatives and talking about things like the Impoundment Act and Nixon gets far away from the curb, right, from people's daily lives. Now, you can explain how, and of
8:26course, this is true, the whole reason it's important for Congress to have the power of the purse is that Congress represents a diverse nation. It represents a balance against the whims of the president. All of that is, of course, true. But as you're doing the theatrical rollout of what you're supposed to be doing, and this goes back to Emily's point about the January 6th hearing, is that the most important thing? I think what happens, basically, they go through the process, and where they have a conflict with the administration, they engage in what will be a long legal fight. And that is important institutionally, but probably theatrically is not primary. One of the weaknesses, I think, of the January 6th analogy is that they had video
9:05footage, and which is why the hearings were produced by a former TV producer. They had one of the most extraordinary moments in American history to center their discussions around, and that isn't true with things like crypto. It's tricky. And as you said, Emily, there is also a target-rich environment. There are so many things that the Democrats could focus on. My final notion is that there is an interesting part of oversight, which is just kind of like, wait, hey, wait a minute here. So, for example, we're going to talk about Hegseth later. But one of the ways that administration officials are spinning the Hegseth thing is to say it's not Hegseth's fault. It's the chairman of the Joint Chiefs who didn't tell the president that they were running out of missiles and Patriot interceptors.
9:49So wait, you're saying that the chairman of the Joint Chiefs didn't tell the president that they were going to burn through a bunch of missiles? I think we should talk about that with the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. That is a totally legitimate, straight up congressional role to ask the people fighting wars how they've carried them out. So then what you have is the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff in front of the cameras, who is not going to lie. And he's going to say, no, I told the president like eight times about these missiles. It's a way to get at the problems of the administration in a way that the previous Congress controlled by Republicans never would have said, hey, wait a minute. So that's a single example. I'm not saying it's
10:28the best one, but roll that across everything. And you have an opportunity for just hearings on things that are maybe not grand, but that if you pick at them, uncovers a lot of the vulnerabilities of the existing administration. Um, so Stephen Miller is a genuinely terrifying figure and actually think his baldness and his thinness and his kind of skeletal nature is, is part of that. He, in that signal chat that, uh, was, uh, leaked to which Jeffrey Goldberg of the Atlantic was included in, it was clear that Stephen Miller was the alpha of all alphas in that administration and that discussion. He's with the most senior people in the administration, and he stated, here is where we stand. What, Emily, is the source of
11:16Stephen Miller's strength? It is really fascinating that he is this person who is such a powerful figure. Yeah, it's a great question. Part of it's his loyalty to President Trump. So that makes the president loyal to him in return and give him a lot of power. Also, he's supposed to be a super hard worker who has really gone to understand the inner workings of government, right? I mean, he was there the first time around. This is part of the whole advantage of coming back into office after having had an initial four years. You know, some of these Trump administration officials were pretty frustrated in the first administration because the workings of government stymied them. And now they've like learned a thing or two about how to make the whole apparatus turn in their
12:00direction. So I think you're right that Miller is poised to be very effective. But there's also a tension here, right? The better he is at like, you know, making ICE enforcement even more extreme and brutal, the more there's going to be a political cost to pay for Trump. And, you know, in his interview on 60 Minutes with Ross Dow that last week, Trump was distancing himself from his own immigration policy, which is like ridiculous in a sense because he's the one who's authorizing it. But you could see there a kind of hesitation that may come into play if Miller really tries to, you know, if Miller's really let loose. John, what do you what do you think about the appointment of Miller? What does it signal? Does it signal what I think the initial respondents seem to suggest it signals, which is, oh, yeah, Trump will be untrammeled because now he has his consigliere, his most hatchety of hatchet men unrestrained and in charge of everything? Or actually, is that an overreading of the situation. I think it's a pretty good, pretty fair reading. I think you, there's the inside
13:07game and the outside game. In terms of the inside game, in the wake of this extraordinary drubbing by Republicans, you could imagine entrepreneurial activity by people inside the Trump administration, people thinking, yeesh, he's a lame duck. The worm has turned. I'm going to start leaking. I'm going to start preparing the nest for my life afterwards. I'm going to maybe see what Marco's up to. And if he's going to run, maybe we start to make some distance between the president and Marco Rubio or same with JD Vance or Tom Cotton or anybody else who wants to run. And Stephen Miller will find those people and eject them by trebuchet across Pennsylvania Avenue without any blinking. So he is he knows how to work through the system. There's been lots of reporting about him showing up on lower level departmental conference calls. He knows how to work the inside part of the system. And he has, as Emily mentioned,
14:13absolute loyalty to the president. And also, you know, in kind of the way Haldeman did with Nixon, the loyalty is like in his bones. In other words, I don't think he has to fake it. He's a true believer in the core of Donald Trump. And so that makes it, you know, those, the number of people who fall into that category is really small. He and the president are in sync on all of that stuff. In terms of immigration, you know, what the president said to Ross is, you know, example, 5,000 of him saying something that doesn't retain its truthfulness, even by the end of the sentence in which he's saying it. My first interview with Stephen Miller, however many years ago it was, in 2017, nine years ago,
14:56on Face the Nation, I said, the president said that migrants whose only infraction is being in the country illegally should not worry because he's not coming after them. And so I said to Miller, like, so is that right? Should those people not be worried? And he said, I'm not going to tell also knows how to work in the spaces where President Trump just doesn't care. Like all of the stuff that goes on in government, he doesn't care. And so I think this is a corollary to my let him talk about the ballroom because he enjoys the ballroom. He can talk about the marble while he's doing all of that, I, Stephen Miller, I'm going to continue and even stamp harder on the accelerator with respect to all of the things that have been done on
15:50immigration. And if some whiny Republicans who want to like have this milk toasty future in the party want to complain about it, screw them, because I'm going to keep doing this. I mean, it really is very much it is this deniability where you want somebody who will work in the dark corners for you. And you, you know, you know that they're ruthless, you know that they will do stuff, but you pretend that you don't know. And sometimes you don't actually know, but mostly pretend that you don't know. of the next two years. One of them is going to be that these this grim machinery of the American government in the hands of the Trump administration is going to keep functioning, right? We're going to continue to have probably like cruel and very strict immigration enforcement. They're going to
16:36be other areas where it just like pursuit of enemies, pursuit of enemies, like these things that, you know, are just going to continue in this like really unsettling way and could be quite volatile, even maybe more volatile. And on the other hand, the president is going to be very weak. Right. I mean, he's been revealed as a political loser. Republicans are going to start to distance themselves and he should become the whole thing should become less scary at the same time that it like continues to operate. I don't quite know how that's all going to play out. But both of those dynamics are there. One thing I don't understand to that end, Emily, and this is for both of you is, it is true that the Republican Party is very weak. And the president is weak. But it's also true
17:21that the people who remain, at least in Washington, are extremely conservative. Everyone who wasn't extremely conservative basically lost their seat. So it's not that what happened is that the ultra conservatives lost their seats. I mean, some of them did. But mostly, it's just they washed out everyone who was in a kind of mildly pro-Trump district. I guess the people who put up some resistance to Trump are all gone. And so they got purged. They were purged or they lost. They either lost, you know, like Thomas Massey or Tom Tillis. They were sort of like driven out of the party or they lost. And so on the one hand, the Republican Party is extremely unpopular. Trump is very unpopular. But on the other hand, I don't where is the internal resistance going to come to what Trump is doing?
18:09Yeah, you didn't see it on the impeachment of Hegseth vote. So yeah, after the 2006 losses by Republicans, there was a rush to get rid of Donald Rumsfeld. You know, I mean, Bush did beat him to it, but you didn't have Republicans lining up to support Rumsfeld. So I think, well, it's part of the dilemma that we talked about last week. I mean, the president has extraordinary hold over the party. The challenge for those who are not the president is that they lack his dynamism. And so there are those who will, you know, run for the Christian nationalist wing, and there are others who will run to the business wing and all that. But they lack his ability to play in all of those places and get excuses from those he needs excuses from and dominate others who previously had resisted domination.
18:59That lack of skill, I think, is what will cause the challenge among Republicans, because there will be no one dominant figure. Also, by the way, Donald Trump won't let there be a non-him dominant figure. And so I think that, you know, all those little billiard balls bouncing off each other is what creates chaos, in part because of what you're describing, David. There's no way to break free. And if you believe that breaking free is a precondition for recreating the party in whatever its post-Trump form will be, if you can't have that breaking free moment, then the party stays in this kind of frustrated kind of moment it's in right now, where he has lots of power, but parts of it are super weak. So for example, remember, he gave a
19:43prime time address about Chinese influence. He floated the idea of $5,000 checks. His entire party on both of those big things totally ignored him. He's trying now to talk about corruption in democratic cities. He put out a social media post on Thursday morning saying, J.D. Vance is going to spend all his time looking into this. It's the Democrats who are corrupt. Like that will just go through into the wind. Republicans won't pick that up. This won't be the new message to confront Democratic claims about corruption. It will just be, you know, just a tweet into the wind or whatever it is. And so still powerful. And yet nobody's listening on some of these things. Yeah. And they're caught in such an interesting trap of their own making, right?
20:25I mean, they're all in line with Trump. They are still gonna fear potentially primaries if they in any way thwart him or just his wrath on social media. In their worlds, that's harmful. And yet if you try to look ahead, like their next phase, their future has to be something that breaks free of Donald Trump or the party is going to be cooked in the American national landscape. Can I make two final points? One of which is, if you were smart, and you were the debt running the world for the Democrats, which is impossible, because it's hard to run the world for any party. But as you your mind would basically be about this is about 2028, that Donald Trump is going to thwart what we do and stuff's going to get caught up in legal battles. And there's just too much
21:10that we have to do both in keeping the lights on and dealing with government as it is, and trying to fix some of these things that we think were particularly bad during the Trump years. There's too much to do. Don't set expectations too high, but use Trump immediately and constantly from now until 2028 as a symbol of what's wrong with this party we oppose, which is to say that the Republicans. So you say, you, America, sent us a signal that you really care about us getting to questions of affordability. And what does Donald Trump do? He spends all his time talking about the ballroom again. You wanted the war to end. What does Donald Trump do? He doubles down on his secretary of defense. To spend time doing
21:49that, because again, you have to stay, keep expectations where they are, and you don't have the levers of power. So you're always going to be disappointing people because you just don't have all three branches of government, or not all three branches, but you don't have the House, Senate, and presidency. And that is probably a smart thing to do. The final point is, when we think about accountability, and back to your great point, Emily, about the January 6th committee, another thing they did successfully on the January 6th committee that will be impossible now is that basically, both through collective action and the leadership of the committee, they told those members of the Democratic Party who wanted to make a name for themselves in these hearings,
22:28settle down. Don't go acting a fool in public because it'll distract from our message. And everybody pretty much stayed on that talking point. That ain't going to be the case now. There are a lot of people who see their route to future glory as their exciting moment in one of these hearings. And when you create that entrepreneurial environment, people who see their route to future glory as their exciting moment in one of these hearings. And when you create that entrepreneurial environment, people who aren't ready for their turn at the center of the stage can make an idiot of themselves. And that then becomes the thing that captures the news cycle. And you go from a position of legitimately investigating areas of
23:01accountability to basically a clown show. So the idea that like hearings are going to be a great idea, I think, forgets for a moment that hearings are sometimes total clown shows. Yeah, there was a little taste of that this week when Garcia, who's the head of the incoming head of the House Oversight Committee, talked about how he knows something about pettiness going into the hearings. Like that's not the line. The line is like, this is very sober. I mean, I also think, John, don't the Democrats need to show Americans through like a set of proposed legislation? Here's what we would do for you if we had a trifecta. You know, here's what we would do on health care, on other affordability issues, on, you know, corruption, like let's ethics,
23:48let's like have some proposals out there. And they're starting to talk. Oh, yeah, they'll have that in their problem won't be the shortage of proposals. It'll be too, it'll be too many. But they should pick some and all get behind them. I mean, in theory, you know, also, like, one of the problems of being in leadership is, you know, what we talked about earlier when David brought up, you know, Congress's power of the purse, like super, super, super, super important, just hard to talk about in public. So, you know, that's a challenge of leadership, how to do that. And the other is that like some of these things that are really, really important, permitting reform, also not like fascinating. Scintillating.
24:22Scintillating. But that's not, that doesn't matter. That's what leadership is like. You got to figure that stuff out. It's not a, um, one of the things that irritates me about the coverage of the Democrats, and this is true of Republicans too, is people present the standard garden variety challenges of leadership as like, Oh, crack up in the democratic party. Or, you know, woe is whether the, the Republicans, although whether the Republicans is reasonable now after the largest law since 1974. But, you know, it's like governing is difficult. Leadership is hard. Parties that are big and win at this size are going to have massive internal conflicts. This is the way it happens. When you play football, there is tackling.
25:00It is not a flaw. It's the way the game is played. Today's show is brought to you by Vanguard. To all the financial advisors listening, let's talk bonds for a minute. Capturing value in fixed income is not easy. Bond markets are massive, murky. And let's be real, lots of firms throw a couple of flashy funds your way and call it a day, but not Vanguard. Lots of firms like to highlight their star portfolio managers, like it's all about that one brilliant mind making the magic happen. Vanguard's philosophy is a little different. They believe the best active strategy shouldn't be locked away with one person. They should be shared across the team. That way, every client benefits from the collective brainpower, not just one individual's
25:55take. And the bond market is complex, and it's not something that one person or a small team can realistically keep up with. Vanguard has been in the game a long time and their scale gives them a serious edge. So if you're looking to give your clients consistent results year in and year out, go see the record for yourself at Vanguard.com slash audio. That's Vanguard.com slash audio. All investing is subject to risk. Vanguard Marketing Corporation. In today's world, planning ahead isn't always top of mind, but not having life insurance can leave families facing difficult financial uncertainty during already emotional times. In many cases, loved ones are left managing expenses, debts, or long-term obligations without a clear plan in place. Life insurance is one way to help
26:41provide financial security and support when it's needed most. That's where Ethos comes in. Ethos makes getting life insurance fast and easy, and it's 100% online. You can get a quote in seconds, apply in minutes, and even get same-day coverage. There's no medical exam. You just answer a few simple health questions online, and coverage options are flexible with up to $3 million available and some policies starting at around $30 a month. Ethos has also earned strong customer feedback with a 4.9 out of 5 star rating on Trustpilot based on more than 5,500 reviews as of August 2026. Help protect your family with life insurance through Ethos. Get your instant free quote at ethos.com. That's E-T-H-O-S dot com.
27:24Application times and rates may vary. Every restaurant wants to be busy. Most restaurants aren't ready for it. I'm Chef Mike from Detroit 75, and Toast helps us stay ready when the lunch rush hits. We prepare for lunch like we're preparing for battle. Orders are flying, tickets are stacking, and the guests should never feel the chaos. Toast keeps our team organized so we were taping that Jensen Wong, the CEO of NVIDIA, has resigned. He has resigned, of course, because of the rapidly metastasizing scandal surrounding him um he he has been caught doing what uh middle-aged men appear to be doing all the time now which is uh cheating in all sorts of different ways potentially with somebody who worked for him in a senior executive position and also with somebody who was a uh someone who had a business partnership with nvidia who was also a chinese spy so um it's
28:31an incredible story nvidia is one of the most important companies in the world jensen wong is the most important person at nvidia was until five minutes ago uh and to talk about what the consequences will be we have matt sheehan who's a senior fellow at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. He focuses on global technology and China. And I imagine he's been extremely busy. So, Matt, what are the ripple effects of Jensen Wong leaving NVIDIA? It is a company which he built. He is, you know, run really with an iron fist as perhaps the silicon fist. He has controlled it and turned it into the most important hardware company in the world for this AI boom. Yeah, we're obviously going to be seeing ripples, waves across the stock market.
29:20That's going to feed into the broader economy. There's going to be a bunch of different sectors. But I think probably the most important, especially for those who sort of view AI as maybe the critical technology of this era, I think the biggest impacts might be on the US-China relationship in AI and specifically what chips China has access to to train their AI models. The reason NVIDIA is such an important company is because they are functionally the only show in town when it comes to designing some of the best AI chips, some of the GPUs that go into training these models. This is a huge advantage for the US. It's a huge problem for China. And Jensen has been really at the intersection there.
30:02And very specifically, what he's been doing is he's been pushing to sell more chips to China. He's been very effective at pushing President Trump to loosen export controls on chips to China, and also to sell a lot of chips to Southeast Asia, where a lot of Chinese companies train their models. So he's kind of in many ways been the man with his finger in the dam of export controls. There's a lot of Washington, D.C. and Silicon Valley, to a certain extent, that would love to tighten export controls on semiconductors to China. He's been the one holding that back. And now once you pull him out of the equation, does that dam break? Yeah. And the argument he has made for selling the chips is that if we don't sell China the chips, they're going to figure out how to make these most advanced chips. And so then they will win the AI race. I mean, it's kind of
30:49counterintuitive, right? Because the case for export controls is like, no, you withhold the chips and then that slows them down. I mean, do you imagine American policy is going to shift because of this resignation? Is he that key a figure? He was a very close ally of President Trump's. He really is that key of a figure in He was a very close ally of President Trump's. He really is that key of a figure in this. I mean, not just because he runs the largest company and that company has a lot of lobbying power, but just him as a person and his personal relationship to Trump has seemed to be pivotal. You know, there have been along the way in the last two years, there have been a bunch of decision points of, are we going to sell this chip? You know,
31:24the H200, the B200, all these sort of cutting edge chips that are rolling out every six months or so. And there's just been very clear moments where it looks like US policy is heading towards more restrictions. Jensen has a meeting with President Trump, he promises to, you know, give the US government a 25% kickback on these sales, and then the sales go through. And, you know, that's a level of influence, sort of personalistic influence that I think really has held the day in US politics, including in US-China relations for the last few years. And that might now be shifting, not just because of what's happening in Congress, but because we're moving one of the really key actors. Just before, John, you ask your question.
32:05I mean, one of the stories that I followed with kind of like slack jawed recently was the H200 chips where they were selling, which is a slightly less advanced chip. They got permission to sell a bunch of them to companies in China. And it turns out those companies in China are just shadow companies that are presumably passing them right on to the Chinese government or onto companies that are barred from getting these chips. Gee, who would have thought? And the Commerce Department was just being like, go ahead, do it, presumably under pressure from NVIDIA. I mean, that was just an outrageous example. Yeah. And it happens not just with selling the chips into China and then they're sort of redirected, but also into, you know, nominally, a lot of these chips are being sold
32:40to Southeast Asia, like Malaysia as a country. It has one of the largest sets of data centers anywhere in the world. They have data centers comparable to those in Europe. You know, Malaysia, not really a country you would think of as at the cutting edge of training models. But that's partly because Chinese companies can go and train their models on data centers in Malaysia, but also because that might be a conduit for smuggling into China. This is, you know, it's shadowy stuff. Not everything is proven, but there's a lot of evidence that a lot of the chip sales into Southeast Asia, into companies like Megaspeed. I should say Megaspeed was the company run by the woman who Jensen Huang had the affair with, who was allegedly recruited by
33:19Chinese intelligence. And those sales, a lot of them, either they go to Malaysia and they're used by Chinese companies there, or they get smuggled and routed as he was. In other words, this wasn't just that his girlfriend was from this company, but that he might himself now be in trouble, assuming a different kind of Department of Justice, but that he might be himself in trouble if he knew this was happening. So I can't speak to the legal aspect of, you know, what did he know? When does he know? And what does that make him responsible for? But I think from a slightly higher level, people within the AI policy community have been saying for years that it's abundantly clear that these chips that are being sold to
34:15Malaysia and Southeast Asia, in some cases, are being routed to China. There has been sort of exposés of these chips showing up in China. If you look at procurement notices by the People's Liberation Army, the Chinese military, they're often like, they're asking for products driven by NVIDIA chips that they're not allowed to have. People would say like, it has been clear for a long time that this smuggling is happening and that Jensen and NVIDIA were essentially turning a blind eye to this. I don't know about the sort of the legal knock-on effects of that, but that's how I'd say people in my community have been assessing this for a while. So now I'm going to ask my actual question. How does China view this?
34:53On the one hand, they lose their advocate. On the other hand, chaos in the U.S. AI industry can't be all bad for them. Yeah, it's a double-edged, triple-edged sword in a lot of ways. I mean, President Trump is going to China this coming weekend week for another round of interactions with President Xi for the APEC summit, which is happening in China. And in general, China really doesn't like sort of bad news, messy, bad news coming out in advance of these summits. They want this to be very sort of carefully choreographed and it all to be good vibes and stuff like that. And so just the messiness of having an alleged Chinese intelligence asset at the heart of this company, not great. On that sort of high level, they don't love that. In terms of the selling of chips to China and
35:47China's relationship to its companies buying those chips, China's actually very torn on this because they feel the same dynamic that I think a lot of the advocates of selling chips to China have felt. China feels if our companies just keep buying NVIDIA chips, we're not going to have customers for our domestic chip producers. That's going to undercut our domestic chip producers. And we're going to spend longer time sort of reliant on the U.S. And so one of the kind of funnier moments of this over the past year has been, you know, this meeting between Jensen and President Trump. And the end result is, OK, you can sell these chips to China. And then China's first reaction is like, actually, maybe we don't want those.
36:23And we're going to impose our own sort of import restrictions on those chips. At the end of the day, China is willing to buy a certain number of NVIDIA chips. They see this as kind of the necessary bridge. Like they can't produce enough domestically. And they want the NVIDIA chips to kind of fill in the gap until they're able to produce enough domestically. But it's not like they're just sort of waiting for a flood of NVIDIA chips and that could potentially undercut their domestic industry. To change the subject slightly, Matt, what kind of interest is there in China and Chinese official circles for more cooperation generally around AI and AI safety? You hear in the US, of course, oh, well, we can't slow down. We can't cooperate because if
37:05we – we can't slow down because if we do, China will get ahead and therefore full speed ahead, no restraint on what we're doing. All guests, no breaks. Yeah. Within China, is there an appetite? Like let's get together, let us work together to try to find some constraints. So the international dynamic here between the US and China is really critical. And I think it's going to get critical going forward. But the way that I see it, the most important debates about this are happening domestically within each country. Like unless the US government itself believes that AI poses a severe threat, then we're not going to be doing meaningful stuff with China on that. And same thing with China, unless they domestically believe that their own models might be posing a threat to the Chinese Communist Party,
37:48then they're not going to have a real interest in working with the US. So I spent a lot of time both monitoring the international and the bilateral relationship, but a lot of time monitoring what's happening domestically within China. How do their own AI experts, how does their own AI policy community think about these risks? And the way I describe it is their sort of threat perception is a lot lower than what you might see in a company like Anthropic. Anthropic, OpenAI, they say this is imminent, this is catastrophic, this is maybe existential, and we need to deal with it now. If you compare sort of Chinese official discourse to that, it's way lower than that. They think that this is probably further off, that they can find
38:24ways to deal with it. But despite the fact that it's sort of lower at an absolute level, it really has been trending up pretty dramatically over the last few years. So if you go back to like 2023, the existential risk conversation was almost non-existent in China. And then starting in 24, 25, and really picking up speed this year, it has actually been sort of, it's been ticking up the list of priorities of the CCP. And so a lot of this depends on sort of how soon these things come to pass. I think if we were to face existential risks, you know, next month, the CCP would not be prepared for that. They would not have put in the time to build the systems to be prepared for that. We have a little bit more time. I think, you know,
39:04they're looking at the same information the US is. They're looking at the open AI hugging face incident. It is freaking them out to a certain extent, maybe not as much as AI safety people would hope it is, but it's trending in the right direction. And my sort of theory of the case here is basically once both governments domestically wake up to this and decide this is a top priority, that's when you're going to see an opportunity for real work internationally. There's initial steps that we can take, but we do need more work domestically within each country to set the table for that. Just staying on the CCP there, Matt, is there increasing concern about it, a function of the sped up possibly timeline to superintelligence? Or is it that the general
39:48paranoia of the Communist Party is finally kicking in? And as an adjunct to that, isn't the Communist Party always paranoid about things? And why isn't this making them more paranoid? I mean, something that can root around the authoritarian control would seem to me to be a real threat, just because they're used to like looking for real threats. Absolutely. Yeah. Paranoid is a good sort of baseline assumption when thinking about their, how they view threats. When they deal with like a new information technology, they almost have like a sequence of things that they care about. And the first step in that is the first like threat perception is always about sort of information, political control, you know, what we, what they would call content security and what we would call censorship. So when large language models, chat GPTs kind of first came on the scene,
40:33their very first reaction is like, what is this going to do to our existing controls on information? And they spent a couple of years regulating on that front. And I think at this point, they feel pretty good about the controls they have in place from a information perspective. It's in many ways their top priority, but they feel pretty good about that. Once they have that under control, they start to kind of like broaden the aperture and look at more risks and look at more threats. And the ones right now that are sort of top of mind for them are labor disruption. That's really, really kicked up in the last year or two in China. They're very concerned about that. They're concerned about stuff like AI companions,
41:09sort of psychological harms dependence. And then what you're referring to, the threat of a loss of control over the models really has been raising. That's of all the different sort of forms of catastrophic risk. Is it about enhancing sort of chem bio capabilities of terrorists? Or is it about sort of hacking by, you know, criminal groups or loss of control seems to be the one that is most sort of consistently on their minds. And it does fit that psychology that ultimately, the CCP and Xi Jinping himself are people who really put a very, very high premium on control, on economic control, on social control. It's, you control. In the US, we're used to, we kind of embrace a certain level of chaos within our system more broadly, and there's not that same
41:52embrace in China. So I think as this sort of ticks up their list of priorities, I think that is the thing that is going to be most salient for them, but they're probably going to need a couple more sort of scary incidents. For one, the one, like the Chinese models are behind. So whereas we saw, you know, OpenAI hugging face in July, they're probably not going to see something like that until early next year, maybe spring of next year. And that might be more of the wake-up call that they need. For now, they're like, they're looking at the gap with the US and they see that as very threatening. And, you know, catch up is a top priority. But I think as the incidents become real to them, they're affecting their banking sector, their infrastructure.
42:32That's when we're really going to see this kind of control instinct ramp up. Matt, before we let you go, I have a question actually for all of us, which is just the more prurient question. Do you guys think that Jensen Wong lost his job because he had an an affair with a chinese spy because he had an affair with a subordinate both would one of those have been enough i feel like the spy should be enough i think it should be enough but it might not have been i don't think it would have been enough it didn't look like it was about to be but now now he looks just like out of control, right? Can I also say there is a little parade of men who get tons of respect, are very smooth talking, are from Silicon Valley. I'm thinking of
43:18Mark Zuckerberg, Elon Musk, now Jensen Wang, who are odious. Like, it is obvious from the beginning that they cannot be trusted. They get treated with enormous respect, even reverence. And they're bad. Like, it's evident that they're bad. Okay, stop it now. Wait. Was it evident that Jensen Wang is odious? I mean, it's obviously odious now. I mean, it's obviously evident now. In a weird way, Mark Zuckerberg, who I don't think, as far as we know, doesn't cheat on Mrs. Mark Zuckerberg. I'm not accusing him of cheating. I'm just saying. He's much more odious. They all, like, because they're silver-tongued and they've made so much money. I'm not sure Mark Zuckerberg would ever be accused of being silver-tongued.
43:59They've just made a lot of money. They've made a lot of money. I mean, whatever. Okay. I just am saying they, like, are on these pedestals and they are bad. And it is obvious that they are bad from day one. I don't think it, but I disagree with the day oneness. Emily. Yes. Because you are enthralled to them for some period of time. I mean, Jensen Wong is obviously an amazing technologist who's built an incredible company. That's done something. I mean, like, are you surprised that, that some middle-aged man is, is fucking some you know a subordinate or beautiful woman who throws herself at him i mean like that is my point these people cannot be trusted and it is should be obvious and they just like fulfill all my expectations about mad
44:41is mad is like i did not sign up for this. I'm a consumer. I'm a consumer of this conversation. Matt has moved from the stage to the audience. I just feel like I have to listen to these people. I have to listen to other people in my life who I respect who are also men and be like, oh yeah, Jensen Wong, making a lot of good points. Blah, blah, blah. No! Not making good points. Not to be trusted. That is a lot of mine points. Blah, blah, blah. No, not making good points. Not to be trusted. That is the bottom line. Wait, but people are complicated. We indemnify Matt against all accusations that he is a participant in any way in this conversation. Are you also thereby distancing yourself? I think you might want to do that too.
45:20Go ahead. No, no, no. What I would like to do to rescue this is whether the idea that a certain small number of people in these companies are going to make the decisions that cabin AI or don't seems to me to be, this seems to be pointing out the risk of that. Sam Altman, another one in that category. I'm also going to go back to David. I don't know if you're going to think this is fair, but in previous Elon Musk times, it was like a lot of like very gauzy, dewy eyed, you know, staring at Elon Musk and like, no, he was always bad. OK, poor Matt Sheehan. Literally nothing to do with this. Just here for the policy. But you did, you were like a big, ladies and gentlemen, Matt left us 15 minutes ago.
46:10I think people are complicated and like people's complex people's contributions as business people, technologists, creators of, of, of new products in the world, new opportunities, new science. Like that is one thing. And then their personal life is another, like, it is not clear to me, it is clear to me that Jensen Wong is, you know, it's not somebody I would want to be married to. But is it clear to me that he is incapable of being the CEO of the amazing chip company? I don't know. I just feel like this particular breed of Silicon Valley entrepreneur has not made the world a better place. It was clear from the beginning that they couldn't be trusted. And now we have yet another example. Oh, my goodness.
46:51All right. We got to stop. I'm sorry, Matt. That is not usually what happens with guests. No worries. Matt Chien is at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. He's not responsible for anything that any of us have said here. Matt, thanks for coming. Thank you very much, Matt. Thank you, guys. 500 orders a month was manageable. 5,000 is madness. Embrace intelligent order fulfillment with ShipStation, the only platform combining order management, warehouse workflows, inventory, returns, and analytics in one place. What used to take five separate tools, ShipStation does in one. Automate fulfillment and rate shopping to ship up to 15 times more with up to 90% savings. Go to ShipStation.com and use code AUDIO to try ShipStation free for 60 days.
47:48This time of year gets busy, and it can be easy to put off your colon cancer screening. If you're 45 or older and at average risk, here's how simple it can be. Request the Cologuard Plus test online, answer a few questions, and a health care provider reviews your request. If it's right for you, the kit is shipped straight to your door. No prep, non-invasive, used at home in about 15 minutes. Request the Cologuard Plus test online today or talk to your doctor. Available by prescription only. An initial attempt to impeach Secretary of Defense slash War Pete Hegseth this week, an attempt that was framed up by departing Republican Rep. Thomas Massey, failed kind of abjectly. Why did it fail, Emily?
48:35Well, I don't really get this. I mean, it failed mostly because a bunch of Democrats, 11 of them, didn't show up. If they had all been there and they had all voted in the way that would have continued impeachment, it would have kept going. A few of them said they got caught in traffic jams. I just couldn't tell if it was all like a little shambolic. John, do you have a theory of the case here? No, I think there was actually, I think 11 of them missed the vote. I mean, I don't think. There was a traffic jam on Pennsylvania Avenue that slowed them down but uh uh yeah it was it was a little shambolic i mean there was a bar for the house majority the house whip was having some party at a bar really unclear yes maybe god something i read said you know the impeachment effort failed uh
49:21allowing donald trump to duck the political ram. I'm not sure he ducked it. Like, so imagine the impeachment succeeds. And like, now, now it seems to me if you're a president, you can say, geez, we were, you know, we were about to win this war, or he claims they've already won it. So we were about to tie it up. And we were going to have 52 straights of Hormuzes, and gas was going to go to two bucks, but the Democrats got in the way with their crazy impeachment and blah, blah, blah, blah. It could give you something else to talk about. Where things stand at the moment is the president is engaged in a highly unpopular war and Pete Hegseth is still in the job and Pete Hegseth is getting reprimanded by a sergeant at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier
50:06because he and his entourage were making, were taking a picture and giggling or whatever. I mean, Hegseth is an albatross for Trump that impeachment could have. I'm not saying, I'm not saying it's good. I'm just saying I'm not sure that he's out of the woods yet on on the Hegseth front um because of the failure of this impeachment i mean hegseth is such an unappealing martinet he's i mean he's so obviously narcissistic and dumb and and obsessed with the wrong things and he's spent so much time on what appear to be really quixotic and pointless and cruel efforts to witch hunt trans soldiers and and shame black people, demote black people and women, you know, drive out any general who doesn't toe the line that he has.
50:56And so he I think you're right that he is he's extremely damaging to Trump every day he's in office. So, yes, fail at impeaching him and that's fine. But they really did. It was a real botch jaw. It felt like it was a real botch. It felt like, oh, we've got a plan. We're going to do this. And then, A, all the Republicans voted against it, except Thomas Massey. And B, the Democrats couldn't even get their act together. So it seems like it's a bad precedent, Emily. Yeah, that's what I meant by shambolic. I mean, it seemed kind of like Massey was giving them a freebie, right? Like they could all just, the Democrats, unify around impeachment. They don't have control of the Senate right now. The impeachment vote would run out when this Congress runs out.
51:43So then they don't, they're not faced with actually having to decide what to do in a trial, right? Because the Republicans still control the Senate, obviously, they're going to vote not to convict. And it would be symbolic, but still a kind of like symbolic scalp for Democrats to have. And now they don't have any of that. And I guess that yes, they can start over with the new Congress. But it's presumably will take more time and become a kind of focal point. And I also thought that, yes, like Hegseth is super unpopular and has lots of problems. But also it seemed like both he and Trump were relishing the return to the comfort zone of being aggrieved right now.'re being martyred again um by their critics like that turns into the dynamic and that seems to me like a real problem going
52:31forward that the democrats are going to have to address there's a difference between investigating because you're trying to find out information and deciding that you're ready to punish someone through impeachment you know it used to be that Congress held hearings and there were pressure on administration officials to resign. Yeah, that's what happened. Right. With like Alberto Gonzalez, who was one of the attorneys. They start at the end and going back to the beginning. Yeah, like that was the normal dynamic was that like you created political problems for the president. This official left. That was how Congress got this done. And now we're in this world where like, we immediately go to impeachment, which is like whole next level.
53:12John would seem skeptical with that. Emily, I think that's a really keen insight. And like, so the so really, what you're saying is that if the Democrats want to be canny about this, they will hold hearings of the sort that John, you described in our earlier segment, where you bring in the chairman of the Joint Chiefs to talk about what actually were the orders about the war and what actually were you guys discussing. That's how you undermine. Right. That's why their heart wasn't in impeachment. I mean, so that's what I was saying earlier. In other words, wait till you're in power and then just have like really basic, like, how did we get into this war? Was the intelligence really what you said it was?
53:49Like, we're, this is not some like a vendetta against Pete Hexeth. We're just like meat and potatoes. We just launched a war and blew through all these Patriot missiles and all these other Tomahawk missiles. Like, was that a wise idea? What did we know about like what Iran really had? And like that's, you don't get accused of being sort of insanely vindictive and you just do the work and you get a bunch of military people up there who aren't going to lie and who probably aren't huge Hegseth fans anyway. And so you get a, you have maximum control, which you don't now, and you have the maximum ability to uncover some of this stuff, which is both a good policy thing and a good political thing. So I don't think it's a huge plus, like this is a hugely unpopular war.
54:36And every time Hegseth and the president get sort of stroppy about being asked about the war, it only doubles down on the fact that they made a bad choice to go to the war in the first place. So I don't think there's like a huge downside to Democrats that the impeachment didn't go through or that the war is still continuing. It's still super unpopular, and it's still a problem for the president. I guess I do think you're onto something, Emily, with your use of the word aggrieved. And I think one of the things that is most dismal about the environment we live in, I don't think it's just unique to the United States. I don't think it's unique to Republicans. I think it is a global phenomenon is that the basic stance that most people seem to want to have in the world is that I mean, victimized, like, and being victimized is, is, is a great position to be in. It's like, oh, poor me. And I think you're right that this was an example
55:25where they allowed Hegseth to set himself up as a victim and then couldn't even make him a victim. I mean, part of this is because they didn't do all the preparatory work John is talking about, right? We didn't have hearings where he gets hauled up there and has to answer all these questions first. But the president has been running as an aggrieved person since 2020. I mean, Hegseth has been doing the the the aggrievement dance for his entire time. And they just lost they just lost a historic election by like all over the country and a Mississippi senator. Because there's a discrepancy between them claiming aggrievement and the actual reality, which is they're the bullies now. Wait. But I think Congress needs to keep reminding Americans of and all of us of the discordant reality in a like more in sorrow than in anger way.
56:12You mean the Republican leaders of Congress do? Because the Republicans are still in charge of Congress. No, I mean, when the Democrats take over. Well, that's when the Democrats take over. They're not in the power yet. Yeah. I mean, this was just a weird episode in which, like I said, it was all about punishing Hegseth, not about actually getting him to answer questions first. And to me, that just seems like the wrong order. And I'm not even sure that you need to get to impeachment. Yeah, well, that I agree with that. I'm not sure that. Well, first of all, by the time Democrats take control, it's unclear that Hegseth will still be around. But I'm not sure that. Yeah, I don't, I'm not sure that you need to get to impeachment. I
56:49just think you need to ask a lot of questions about how we got in this war and whether the president, I mean, this idea that the president wasn't informed, first of all, there's just, that's crazy. The idea that he wasn't informed about the missile shortages. You can spend a good amount of time there. I mean, there was an entire 1960 presidential campaign run on the missile gap. You can get some of that energy. He's probably like me. He was probably informed and he forgot it. There's a lot of him claiming that lately. That happens to me all the time. That's why Justin Wong said that. All the time. Talk about that in detail. Yep, he seems to be forgetting things that he doesn't want to remember a lot i alone can fix it except all the stuff i broke yeah and
57:33by the way there's nothing wrong with my mental faculties even though i conveniently forget all these things all right let's go to cocktail chatter we taped out of order so we've actually just finished there that that uh that segment about jensen wong and so we're a little bit giddy because i got out of hand um but uh when you'll probably be talking to our cocktail party emily will definitely be talking to her cocktail party about jensen wong is my suspicion that she will be holding forth about jensen wong um but and and as well she should be yeah i mean the point was the point was a quite a valid one um i'm going to take the first chatter today just because i i have an important chatter and i want to make sure people hear it uh and i need help so it as john and emily
58:19know i told my colleagues at citycast yesterday that i am stepping down as our CEO. That's a local media company I founded six years ago. And I'm handing the reins off to my co-founder, Andy McDaniel, who I've worked with so with so much joy and fun over the last six years. And so she has taken over CEO, I'm going to kind of spend a few weeks just helping her settle in. And it's just been an amazing run. Launching and building CityCast has been so fun. It's been exhilarating. It's been challenging, joyous, really difficult. And we've had an amazing parent company in Graham Holdings, which is actually the parent company of Sleep. They're the best parent company in America. And we created something from nothing. I'm really, really proud of sleep. Um, they're the best parent company in America and we created something from
59:05nothing. And I'm really, really proud of it. We have the only network of local news podcasts in America. We reach, you know, 1.5 million listeners and readers. Um, and we have a company that is ambitious and experimental and company culture that is boisterous and kind, and we're doing a really good thing. Um, but I have a very loud internal clock. And as John and Emily know, uh, maybe Gaff has listeners. No, I, every six years the alarm goes off and I realized it's time for me to reset. And so I, I left slate, um, after six years, editor in chief there, I left Atlas obscure after six years as CEO. Um, when I do that, I always go on the gap fest. I'm like, I need your help. I need your help listeners. I left Atlas Obscura after six years as CEO. When I do that, I always go on the GabFest.
59:45I'm like, I need your help. I need your help, listeners. I need your help. What am I going to do next? Because the way I go about this is I sort of take a break and reset my brain and figure out what it is. Just talk to people about what they're doing, get ideas. So if you have an idea for me, because I don't know what comes next. If you have an idea for me, it could be anything. It could be a job. It could be full-time, part-time. It could be a creative project. It could just be not job-like at all. Just email me at davidplotz at gmail.com. Just, that's my email. Just email me. Love to hear from you. I've had great outreach from GabFest listeners in the past. So if you have a thought, let me know.
1:00:28And John and Emily, if you guys have a thought, let me know. I have many thoughts. Also, you are both being brave in leaving when you decide it's time without knowing exactly what happens next. And also, I think the reason that you don't think extensively about it beforehand is that you're so loyal to the project that you're working on so congratulations and it's going to be great and so right and so engaged in what you're working on i totally agree uh yeah yes um it's amazing congratulations and also it's been fun to watch your love of washington um come through in your uh passion for the for city cast and particularly city cast dc but um so that's been fun too thank you and it goes without saying but like gab fest continues this
1:01:13does not change yeah yeah you got nothing else to do now exactly everything else it's going six days a week uh all right uh so anyway email me my name name at Gmail. Emily, what's your chatter? Judge Richard Posner died this week, and it's such a huge loss. I mean, there's like really no one like him in the law, both his influence as a judge and a scholar. He was just an amazing pragmatist as a judge. I mean, he basically was very blunt about the fact that he didn't really start with the statute or the rule or even the constitution. He said, like, my job is to settle disputes. What's the sensible resolution here? I bet I can figure out a way in which it is also legal. And he also created the whole field of law and economics
1:01:59and was an enormously kind person. I mean, there's been an outpouring on social media from people who disagreed with him strongly, to whom he was kind, spent time reading their work, sending them comments. books. And it was one of the first book reviews I wrote. I labored over it, but I made a mistake in it. And it was a mistake to his detriment. Like it was a criticism that was wrong. And instead of pouncing, he wrote this incredibly generous note to me, pointing it out, but just in a very gentle and respectful way. And when I got to know him later, he was always like that. I never managed to call him Dick, which was his nickname, even though he urged me to do that, I think in the way he urged everyone. But that was my fault. Yeah, he really was a towering figure. He's had Alzheimer's
1:02:58for years now. And I hope that now we can really just like think about him and mourn his loss. That was, I loved reading that obituary today for him. Adam Liptak did such an amazing job with that obit. I didn't know. It was a lot of, it was new, new to me. And I was, it was really amazing. His description of himself as being like his cat. Well, do you remember that was a profile in the New Yorker by Larissa McFarquhar that like was one of the reasons I wanted to be a writer. I mean, it's an amazing profile. Totally worth it. While John does his chatter, I'm going to find that quote. Yes, totally do. John, what's your chatter? Oh, hi. Uh, my chatter, um, is about the fastest passenger liner in the world, which crossed the Atlantic Ocean in less than four days. And this Wednesday, it sank
1:03:49in five hours. I'm stealing that lead from NPR. The USS United States launched in 1952 or 51. It was longer than the Titanic. It transported presidents, Marilyn Monroe, Walter Cronkite. And anyway, you know, time marched on. And then it sat in kind of storage for until 2024 when it was bought by a county in Florida for the purposes of sinking it to create an artificial reef. And it is now Wednesday. It was successfully sunk after a year-long process of basically stripping out anything that could actually hurt the marine life that it sought to save or it seeks to save. So it took a year or so to fix that up. And then in a controlled non-explosion using process. It sunk the ship to the bottom of the sea,
1:04:47I think like 180 feet below the water surface. And it now sits down there as the largest man-made reef to deal with the fact that we're killing our coral reefs. I am so fascinated by shipwrecks and just like the ghostly frozen in time quality. Well, I used to go kayaking and there was a shipwreck you'd have to kayak over in this way. And it like always freaked me out. Um, and so I find this mildly spooky, but also just sort of a cool act of recycling. And also the pictures of the SS United States, um, from the, when it was in storage or are also quite ghostly. Um, uh, anyway, so that's that. I found the quote, uh, so that in the time from the times, um, that in person, he was mild, a little distant and sometimes seemingly indifferent to ordinary social niceties.
1:05:38Posner was the first to acknowledge his own oddities. I had quote, I have exactly the same personality as my cat. Judge Posner said in a memorable New Yorker profile, I'm cold, furtive, callous, snobbish, selfish, and playful, but with a streak of cruelty. Amazing thing to say about yourself. Listeners, you keep sending us great chatters. Please keep them coming to us at campfestitslate.com. Email them to us. We can use the diversion, the excitement, the joy. And our listener chat this week comes from Suli Hussein. Hi, Gapfest. My chatter is about the Blue Ridge Parkway, a single roadway connecting Shenandoah National Park in Virginia to the North Carolina side of Great Smoky Mountains National
1:06:19Park. At 469 miles long, it is the longest linear park in the United States and the longest road conceived of as a single unit, with construction starting in 1933 and not ending until 1987. In my quest to visit all 64 national parks, I was able to drive most of the road over the course of three days this October. Not only does the parkway have seemingly endless, jaw-dropping views of the Smoky Mountains, the driving experience itself is profoundly pleasant. There are no billboards, stop signs, stoplights, or commercial traffic. Instead, there are campgrounds, visitor centers, and hiking trails. Any lover of our public lands or motorized travel should be sure to have the Blue Ridge Parkway on your bucket list.
1:07:06We have other Slate podcasts in the Slate universe, the extended Slate ecosystem. And this week you could give a listen to Slate Money, which has an episode about the political ad splurge and has the incredible fact that there was $11.87 billion spent on political ads for the midterm. And the hosts of Slate Money bring on Sarah Fisher of Axios, a brilliant media analyst, to explain where the money went and what role it played in the election. So check out the political ads at political ads splurge episode of Slate Money. That's all for our episode this week we also have a bonus episode in your feed we're going to talk about the new new york charter school that is open seven days a week 12 hours a day 12 months of the year um that bonus episode however is only for slate plus
1:07:56members so slate plus members thank you go listen to it but if you're not a slate plus member subscribe to slate plus directly from the political gab Fest show page on Apple Podcasts and Spotify, or visit slate.com slash gabfestplus to get access wherever you listen. Also, if you're a Slate Plus member, you can get a discount to our live show. So we have a live conundrum show coming up Tuesday, December 15th in New York. Love to see you there. It's always the funnest night of the year for me. I learn more about John and Emily that night than any other night. And you can get tickets at slate.com slash gabfest live and why, or you can't get tickets yet, but you can sign up for tickets and we will get you tickets once those tickets are
1:08:35available. Slate.com slash gabfest live and why. That is all for our episode this week. Our producer is Nina Porzuki. Our researcher is Emily Ditto. Our theme music is by They our episode this week. Our producer is Mina Porzuki. Our researcher is Emily Ditto. Our theme music is by They Might Be Giants. Ben Richmond is Senior Director for Podcast Operations. Mia Lobel is Executive Producer of Slate Podcasts. And Larry Fry is CEO of Slate. For Emily Bazelon and John Dickerson, I'm David Plotz. Thanks for listening. We'll talk to you next week. To learn more, visit bill.com slash proven for a special offer. Hi, this is Brooke DeVard of Naked Beauty. Make your home feel like the holidays with Pura.
1:09:29From fresh pine to sweet nostalgic scents inspired by your favorite childhood memories, Pura's holiday collection brings the scents of the season to every room. Whether you're hosting a small gathering or a big holiday celebration or enjoying a quiet cozy night at home pira makes holiday hosting simple and memorable set the perfect seasonal mood with pira explore the





