On the Media · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
A Media Matters analyst maps how Fox News built Jim Jordan's power, and the show then turns to Haaretz and to what democratic socialism has meant in America.
Tap a chapter to open that moment in the transcript; the link to it is copied for you.
“Jim Jordan is the chairman of what I call the Fox News Caucus of House Republicans.” Matt Gertz · at 3:45 — open in the transcript →
“They didn't expect to win, but they expected to recruit more people to the cause.” Michael Kazin · at 35:15 — open in the transcript →
Matt Gertz of Media Matters argues that Jim Jordan's rise was built on Fox News. In Donald Trump's first term, Trump rewarded House Republicans who praised him on air and attacked his enemies with access, jobs and endorsements. Gertz calls them the Fox News caucus, a bloc that backed attacks on the Mueller investigation and claims that the 2020 election was rigged. The same path led Ron DeSantis and John Ratcliffe to power.
The midterms and Israel fill the rest of the show. Gertz expects Fox to thrive under a Democratic House in 2027, since the network does best when Republicans are out of power. Meanwhile AIPAC lost races it spent $55 million on, and a poll found more Americans sympathetic to Palestinians than Israelis. Haaretz, which has doubled its American bureau, has faced government pressure, according to its global editor Noah Landau, including a lawsuit from Netanyahu.
The episode ends with a history of American socialism. Michael Kazin, a Georgetown historian, traces Eugene Debs from the Pullman strike and his five presidential runs to the Socialist Party of America's failure at the ballot box. He blames the Electoral College, the force of race over class, and Wilson-era repression during World War I. Today's split is between social democrats who want reforms within capitalism and socialists who want to end it.
Matt Gertz is a senior fellow at the progressive watchdog Media Matters. He wrote about how Fox News helped Jim Jordan's rise within the Republican Party.
Noah Landau is global editor of Haaretz, Israel's oldest daily newspaper, where she has helped expand coverage abroad.
Michael Kazin is a history professor at Georgetown University, a DSA member and the author of What It Took to Win, A History of the Democratic Party.
Matt Gertz of Media Matters says Jim Jordan is the chairman of what Gertz calls the Fox News caucus of House Republicans. He says Jordan has made at least 716 appearances on Fox weekday programming since August 2017, and that the network helped build his standing in the party during Trump's first term.
“Jim Jordan is the chairman of what I call the Fox News Caucus of House Republicans.”Matt Gertz · 3:45
Gertz says Donald Trump watched Fox News closely during his first term and rewarded House Republicans who praised him on air and attacked his enemies with access, jobs and endorsements. He argues that this gave a group of backbenchers a path to power, including Jim Jordan, Ron DeSantis and John Ratcliffe.
“Donald Trump spent a lot of time watching Fox News”Matt Gertz · 4:32
Gertz says the Fox News caucus came together in opposition to Special Counsel Robert Mueller's investigation of Russian interference in the 2016 election. He notes that Jordan and Mark Meadows filed articles of impeachment against Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein, who had appointed Mueller, to promote an alternative narrative.
“This was an effort to bring more attention to this alternative narrative this Fox News caucus were trying to put together.”Matt Gertz · 6:18
Noah Landau, global editor of Haaretz, says Netanyahu built an empire of supportive media and that the pro-government outlets are pundits rather than journalism. She cites a lawsuit Netanyahu filed against Haaretz over its reporting on warnings he received before October 7, and a 2024 government resolution to cut ads and subscriptions to the paper.
“Netanyahu is one of these leaders who built an empire of supportive media.”Noah Landau · 19:52
Michael Kazin describes Eugene Debs as a great orator who did not become a socialist until he had led a big railway union. Debs ran for president five times, and his 1920 campaign from the Atlanta penitentiary drew about a million votes.
“The charismatic figure leading the charge was Eugene Debs.”Michael Kazin · 35:51
Matt Gertz argues that Jim Jordan's career was built largely on Fox News, which rewarded House Republicans who praised Donald Trump on air. He says Jordan, with at least 716 Fox appearances since 2017, became a leader of what Gertz calls the Fox News caucus, and that the network's coverage now shapes how Republicans respond to Democratic accountability efforts.
Matt Gertz of Media Matters says Jim Jordan is the chairman of what Gertz calls the Fox News caucus of House Republicans. Gertz says Jordan has made at least 716 appearances on Fox weekday programming since August 2017, and that the network helped build his standing in the party, especially during Trump's first term.
Gertz says Trump watched Fox News closely during his first term and noticed House Republicans who praised him on air and attacked his enemies. Those members were rewarded with access to Trump and sometimes with jobs and endorsements, which let a group of backbenchers build their careers.
Michael Kazin, a Georgetown history professor, describes Eugene Debs as the most captivating American socialist spokesman before Bernie Sanders. Debs became a socialist after leading the 1894 Pullman strike against railway owners and going to jail, and he ran for president five times, including a 1920 campaign from the Atlanta penitentiary that drew about a million votes.
Kazin says the Socialist Party of America never had electoral success for several reasons: the Electoral College made it nearly impossible to win a state, race mattered more than class in American politics, and the Wilson administration effectively declared the party illegal during World War I. He also says the New Deal drew many socialist voters into the Democratic Party.
Noah Landau, global editor of Haaretz, says Netanyahu has built an empire of supportive media that produces pro-government pundits rather than journalism. She cites a 2012 conversation in which Netanyahu allegedly named the New York Times and Haaretz as Israel's two big enemies, a lawsuit he filed against Haaretz over its reporting on warnings before October 7, and a 2024 government resolution to cut ads and subscriptions to the paper.
Matt Gertz says Fox tends to thrive when Republicans are out of power, because it can point to what it calls excesses of the left and energize its audience. He says Fox is already framing Democrats' calls for accountability as a witch hunt and a revenge agenda, rather than asking whether Donald Trump and his family behaved corruptly.
Noah Landau says Haaretz investigated the Gaza health ministry fatality list, which counts more than 74,000 Palestinians killed since October 7, 2023, and found it was largely representative despite criticism from some Israeli media and conservative US outlets. She says the paper also used satellite imagery and described specific incidents as war crimes, though journalists cannot enter Gaza without being chaperoned.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp or the link button on a paragraph to copy a link that opens this page there.
0:00Jim Jordan is the chairman of what I call the Fox News Caucus. Jordan has made at least 716 appearances on Fox Weekday programming since 2017. The new leader of the House Republicans rose to his new position via a novel selection process. From WNYC in New York, this is On the Media. I'm Brooke Gladstone. And I'm Michael Olinger. Also on this week's show, the longest-running newspaper in Israel is doubling its American presence. Meanwhile, because of its reporting on war crimes in Gaza and corruption... The government is explicitly fighting us. Netanyahu allegedly said that Israel has two big enemies. One is the New York Times and one is the Haaretz. Plus, American socialism is once again on
0:45the rise, along with its old arguments over methods and goals. Socialists who believe that sweeping changes can be made within a capitalist society and people in the socialist party who believe that's not going to do it. It's all coming up after this. From WNYC in New York, this is On the Media. I'm Brooke Gladstone. And I'm Michael Olinger. The dust has now settled on a series of stunning losses for the right in the midterms. And yet, if you're to believe the newly reelected Republican House whip Tom Emmer, this is just the beginning of the end for Democrats. Our colleagues on the left, enjoy this honeymoon phase because come January 3rd, 2027, you will regret ever putting your name on a ballot.
1:30House Republicans will hold each and every Democrat accountable for every vote cast, every committee hearing held, and every sentence set on MSDNC. Exit polls point to immigration being one of the reasons voters shifted leftward. The president kind of conceded as much in a post-election interview with 60 Minutes. So you think your deportation policy went too far? It was too tough. I think it might be too tough, yeah. And a lot of people would say that it's great, but a lot of people think it's too tough. I think ultimately that hurt me. And yet, on Monday, Trump promoted the architect of his immigration platform, far-right extremist Stephen Miller to White House chief of staff. He also stood up for Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth,
2:16who this week survived a botched procedural impeachment vote. We destroyed terror regimes capabilities. We sank the boats carrying poison into our communities. We put a narco dictator in handcuffs. For the first time in American history, a cabinet secretary overseeing America's military is being attacked not for losing conflicts with our enemies, but for winning them. Hegseth is safe for now, but maybe not come January when Democrats assume majorities in Congress. In the meantime, Todd Blanch, the president's personal lawyer, I mean, attorney general of the United States, is attempting to play an UNO reverse card against the looming threat of House oversight investigations. Well, what we've seen over the past several days and even over the
3:02past several weeks are outright threats, many by elected members of Congress and some senators, against anybody that's conservative and anybody that happens to be a Republican. And that is extremely troubling. Are you saying that you are going to investigate them? And what you just described, is there a crime there? Well, what I just described, it depends on what's said. So yes, there could be. In the face of clear evidence that Americans want less chaos, less corruption, and more change, the Republican Party is choosing instead to double down. Exhibit B. For nearly two decades, Congressman Jim Jordan has fought against lawfare, corruption, government overreach, far-left insanity, and now he will continue that fight as the next Republican leader.
3:45The congressman gave his first interview in the new role to his buddy, Fox News host Sean Hannity. Jordan has made at least 716 appearances on Fox Weekday programming since August 2017, which is when Media Matters' database begins. Matt Gertz is a senior fellow at the progressive watchdog Media Matters' database begins. Matt Gertz is a senior fellow at the progressive watchdog Media Matters. He wrote this week about how the network has been instrumental to Jordan's ascent within the Republican Party. Jim Jordan is the chairman of what I call the Fox News Caucus of House Republicans. Right now, Donald Trump is really the preeminent figure in the GOP. But back during his first term, he had won a presidential campaign with a sort of shoestring
4:32campaign apparatus. He was reliant on a lot of establishment Republican figures, and a lot of them weren't particularly loyal to him. He went looking for allies. He found them on his television. Donald Trump spent a lot of time watching Fox News, and a set of House Republicans figured out that they could go on shows that Donald Trump was watching and demonstrate their loyalty by praising the president and attacking his enemies, and that he would reward them with access to himself personally, at times to jobs, to endorsements. There was a whole set of these House Republicans who had been backbenchers, not really legislative successes, but they caught Donald Trump's eye and became a sort of Fox News caucus of House Republicans who bootstrapped their careers that way. Jordan really fits the bill because even in his two decades in Congress, he's not once been the
5:30lead sponsor of a bill that became law. When Donald Trump has watched Jim Jordan on Fox, what has he seen over the years? You know, this Fox News caucus really came together as a group of House Republicans who were deeply opposed to, or at least postured as opposed to, Special Counsel Robert Mueller's investigation of Russian interference in the 2016 election. Look, Bob Mueller had 22 months, $30 million, 19 lawyers, 40 FBI agents, 500 witnesses, 2,800 subpoenas. If he could have established obstruction, he would have done it. He couldn't do it. You know, at one point, he and Meadows filed articles of impeachment against Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein, who was a Trump appointee and the person who had
6:18appointed Robert Mueller as special counsel. This was an effort to bring more attention to this alternative narrative this Fox News caucus were trying to put together. And that is the focus of Jordan's career. It's been on trying to tamp down investigations of Republicans. And so the Mueller probe, the Hunter Biden investigations going the other way, the various efforts to reduce the political saliency of the January 6th insurrection, the 2020 efforts to subvert the election. 72 million Americans instinctively know something's not right here. What are the Democrats trying to hide? Let's get to the bottom of this. Let's count every legal vote. Let's figure out exactly what happened for the integrity of the American election system.
7:10There were lots and lots of House Republicans who were willing to play ball with Trump's election subversion plot. But Jordan stood out simply because of how frequently and how loudly he was championing the false claims that the elections had been rigged. You know, at one point, immediately after the election, the president tweeted out a clip of Jordan telling Sean Hannity, this is the first time in American history where you have a party systematically set out to win an election after the election, and that's what they're doing, and it has to be stopped. He was talking about the Democrats. Trump tweeted it out and said, incredibly stated, Jim. It's probably not a coincidence that Donald Trump awarded Jim Jordan the Medal of Freedom
8:02less than a week after January 6th in a closed-door ceremony. The award established by President John F. Kennedy is meant to recognize those who have made an especially meritous contribution to national security, world peace, or cultural or other significant public or private endeavors. It is really remarkable to revisit some of Jordan's grandstanding in his case against Joe Biden and Hunter Biden. He said from the House floor, this is a tale as old as time. Politician takes action that makes money for his family, and then he tries to conceal it. My favorite quotes from Jim Jordan from that period are when he was describing what he called the heart of the case against Joe Biden and Hunter Biden. He said, about an FBI informant who alleged that Joe and
9:06Hunter Biden had each taken $5 million bribes from a Ukrainian oligarch. And that informant was subsequently charged and pleaded guilty to lying to the FBI about that. He apparently made the whole thing up. So that was the heart of that Hunter Biden case, according to Jim Jordan. And I'm assuming that Jim Jordan appeared on Fox News to apologize for misleading the country? No, that I do not think happened. Fox has also helped launder Jordan's reputation at critical junctures in his career. In July 2018, NBC News reported that Jordan was, quote, being accused by former wrestlers he coached more than two decades ago at Ohio State University of failing to stop the team, Dr. Richard Strauss, from molesting them and other students.
9:54According to a university investigation, over 170 students were sexually abused during this time. How was all this covered on Fox? I think covered up would be the better way to put it. I mean, it was treated as a hit job targeting Jim Jordan. At one point, the way Hannity put it was, Congressman Jordan, welcome to the club. If you support Donald Trump, you had to know the lies, the smears against you are obviously a political attack. The whole thing is framed through the lens of all attacks on Donald Trump are illegitimate. Therefore, all attacks on any of Donald Trump's supporters can be assumed to be illegitimate as well. Jim Jordan has become one of the most recognizable faces of what you call the Fox News caucus.
10:47There's also John Ratcliffe, who is now head of the CIA, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis, one-time Chief of Staff Mark Meadows is part of the group. How would you say that Jordan and his cohort have turned their many appearances on Fox into real political power. In DeSantis' case, he had a sort of well-reported strategy of making as many Fox News appearances as possible to attract Donald Trump's attention and eventually endorsement, and that worked for securing him the Republican nomination for governor for the 2018 cycle against a more established politician in the state. For Meadows, the appearances created a sort of direct one-to-one relationship with Trump that he eventually turned into White House chief of staff. Ratcliffe was, again, a sort of
11:46backbench member who didn't have a lot of experience in the intelligence world, but was willing to say that there was nothing to the Russia story. And so Donald Trump eventually succeeded in making him the director of national intelligence and now in charge of the CIA. Matt Gaetz tried a similar strategy and it almost worked. He was nearly Attorney General of the United States until his bid was shot down by a massive sex scandal. Jim Jordan, I think, has played the long game. He's stayed in Congress. He's mustered the support of Donald Trump. And then from that, he tried to become Speaker of the House back in 2023 with a huge amount of support from Sean Hannity. Ultimately, it didn't work. But a couple
12:33years later, here he is, Senate Minority Leader. Beyond Jim Jordan, as someone who watches a lot of Fox News, how are these pundits and personalities metabolizing the midterm results? I think we're seeing the beginnings of what looks like a very competitive Republican presidential campaign. You know, Fox is often the kind of staging ground for different politicians who want to become president. They will often camp out on the network's airwaves to get their message out. Right now, we're seeing the network's hawks, people like Brian Kilmeade and other co-hosts of Fox & Friends, putting out a marker that J.D. Vance does not have the election sewn up and that he shouldn't, and that there are a whole bunch of other figures like DeSantis, like Ted Cruz,
13:31like Marco Rubio, who should be considered instead. Why is that? Well, J.D. Vance is a divisive figure on Fox because the war is something that the network's hawkish hosts really supported. If you go back to February and March, you saw a lot of beating the drums for a conflict with Iran from people like Hannity, from people like Mark Levin and Brian Kilmeade, they basically convinced Donald Trump through their coverage that this was a good idea. And so when J.D. Vance came out after the election and said that the war was the reason that they lost, you saw pushback from those hawks saying the war is good and J.D. Vance is trying to use it to boost his own campaign. How do you think Fox News is feeling about what they see coming in 2027? Is a potentially
14:36aggressive, democratically controlled Congress good or bad for the network? You know, that part is probably good. I think Fox tends to thrive when Republicans are out of power because they can point to what they say are excesses of the left and get their audience energized by that. already seeing them respond to Democrats calling for accountability, not by considering whether it's possible that Donald Trump and his family have behaved corruptly over the last several years, but by calling it a witch hunt, ruthless upcoming lawfare, a weaponization routine, a revenge agenda. They think that they can unify an audience that has been fracturing away from them by focusing on the danger posed by the left.
15:30And that is increasingly unpopular and the prospect of a Republican presidential nomination fight that can go in any number of ways. Well, I'm sure we'll have lots to talk about. Matt, thank you very much. Thanks for having me. Matt Gertz is a senior fellow at Media Matters. Coming up, America's relationship with Israel was also on the ballot this month, and an Israeli newspaper reckons with the changing landscape. This is On the Media. This is On the Media. I'm Brooke Gladstone. And I'm Michael Loewinger. One of the most prominent pro-Israel groups in the country, the American-Israel Public Affairs Committee, or AIPAC, spent $55 million on midterm races they ended up losing. Like in Michigan, where Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed prevailed.
16:42An ally that takes your money to push you into wars you shouldn't be fighting is not an ally. I think it's time for us to realize that, like, Israel is not actually our friend. In Illinois, Daniel Biss won his election against an AIPAC-backed opponent. And in New York, Brad Lander was elected to Congress just weeks after he was detained by the IDF in the West Bank during a volunteer trip. Surveys show that American attitudes towards both the Israeli government and the Israeli people have continued to sour since the Hamas attacks on October 7th and Israel's war on Gaza. In February, for the first time, more Americans told pollsters they were sympathetic to Palestinians at 41 percent than Israelis at 36 percent.
17:27Israel is losing support here in the United States, even amongst Republicans. There was this sense that Israel has this special relationship with the United States. And what we saw in this poll is at least among the American people, that special relationship appears to be in tatters. While many of us were anxiously focused on our midterms, Israelis voted in their own elections. After some parliamentary shuffling, opposition leader Gadi Eisenkot has been given a chance to form a coalition in the Knesset and replace Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. At this precarious moment for U.S.-Israel relations, Haaretz, the country's oldest daily newspaper, has more than doubled the size of its American bureau,
18:11hiring correspondents to cover issues affecting young American Jews and dispatching reporters to Michigan and Georgia ahead of the midterm elections. In Israel, Haaretz is a somewhat lonely voice on the left, overshadowed by a media ecosystem that's been shaped by the right wing and Benjamin Netanyahu's political dominance for nearly 18 years. But the paper continues to report on unpopular topics, like the extent of the Israeli military's destruction in Gaza. These kinds of stories could be hard for an Israeli audience to read, but it is still our responsibility to bring them. Noah Landau is global editor of Haaretz, where she's helped expand coverage abroad. Her paper recently investigated the Gaza
18:59health ministry fatality list, which counts more than 74,000 Palestinians killed since October 7th, 2023. Many Israeli media and even conservative outlets in the U.S. portrayed that list as misleading. But Haaretz found that it was largely representative. Yes, I mean, we covered not only the question of the death toll, but also specific incidents that we definitely described them in our editorials as war crimes. We covered a lot of the destruction using satellites, etc. But there is a real problem of access in the coverage. Because of the prohibition against journalists in Gaza. Journalists are just not allowed to go into Gaza without the idea of chaperoning them. Haaretz has been the target of quite a bit of political
19:52pressure. You recently wrote about a conversation between Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and the Jerusalem Post back in 2012. Explain what it tells us about Netanyahu's approach to the press. Netanyahu allegedly said that Israel has two big enemies. One is the New York Times and one is the Haaretz. Those wouldn't be the first two enemies I would think of coming from Netanyahu. Exactly. Netanyahu is one of these leaders who built an empire of supportive media. You know, we used to say Fox News style, but I think it's much more ridiculous than Fox News. They're not attempting to be journalism at all. They're just pro-government pundits. You're referring to Channel 14 and the like? Yes, exactly. But it
20:38started with Sheldon Edelson's attempt to, you know, build Israel Hayom as a pro-Netanyahu newspaper. There were all sorts of smaller initiatives. You know, he calls Channel 12 Israel's mainstream television channel Al Jazeera. He attacks the liberal leaning or center leaning or mainstream media, however you want to call them, and is building his own media empire ecosystem to support his policies and politics. And we'll see how ultimately that all works out for him. But it's not just nasty comments, right? I mean, he earlier this year filed a lawsuit against Haaretz because of your reporting into the warnings that he received ahead of October 7th. It's not only Netanyahu. The whole government has adopted in 2024 a resolution
21:28that's calling on the government bodies to cut the government advertising from Haaretz and all advertising ties, honestly, and other dealings with Haaretz, such as subscriptions. So ministers have moved to cancel subscriptions. So the government, you know, is explicitly fighting us. There was a lot of hand-wringing in American media about whether Michigan Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed was anti-Semitic because of some of his critiques of Israel. An enduring narrative formed that he was alienating Jewish voters. And while he did trail behind other Democratic politicians in the state, an exit poll indicated that he still got 50% of the Jewish vote in Michigan. That is such a good example, because very broadly speaking, the story that the Israeli
22:19media is telling about the Democratic Party and what happened in these midterms is a story about how they're anti-Israel, you know, is a big headline. What I think they don't necessarily understand about Jews in America is how they view this and the fact that they themselves are very, very critical of what's happening in Israel. So they don't see that as anti-Semitism and they know how to differentiate with much more nuance between criticism of Israel and anti-Semitism. And personally, I think anti-Semitism is a real problem these days, but the way that criticism of Israel is sometimes unfairly conflated with the anti-Semitism actually damages the ability to confront actual anti-Semitism. Haaretz was the first Israeli outlet to interview Hassan Piker, the popular Twitch streamer
23:13who is one of the more controversial critics of Israel in American left-wing media. In his interview with your reporter, Piker took a lot of shots at liberal Zionists, who he said are still Zionists and are therefore still participating in a fascist and exterminationist project. I'm curious to hear a bit about the editorial decision to publish the interview with Piker, which I imagine you knew would upset a lot of your readers. I was about to say that we're not afraid to speak to people from all sides of the political spectrum, but actually that's not true. I do think we have red lines when it comes to that, but we were not afraid to speak to Hassan Piker. By the way, I saw somewhere he said that he was doing Jewish outreach. I thought it was pretty funny.
24:03About his interview with Pa'aretz? Yeah, you know, he's influential whether you want it or not. So many people listen to him. He's part of that conversation. So yes, we wanted to ask him some questions about that. So, okay, yes, you've mentioned some of his criticism against liberal Zionists. That's fine. We have these debates and discussions within our own newspapers many times. When you say debates in your newsroom, what are you referring to? So people write op-eds from, you know, the perspective of being critical towards liberal Zionists. We have Palestinian journalists who have the same kind of criticism. And we had many debates, and by that I mean, you know, people writing op-eds and others
24:45answering them regarding these same questions. President Trump set off a storm of coverage here and in Israel when he told Fox News earlier this month that he's cutting $4 billion in aid to Israel. We were giving them $4 billion. We are, but it gets cut off at the end of the year. Why? Why? Because they don't need it, Brian. I mean, I asked them. Much of the focus on these statements I found to be pretty misleading because I believe he was referring to Obama-era funds that are set to expire in 2028. There is actually a current plan to preserve American military aid to Israel. Yes. The headline everywhere was basically Trump is cutting the aid, right? And the story is much more complex than that. They're actually trying not to cut aid, but to change the way that it's
25:37delivered. Netanyahu himself told Trump that he would like to do that. They kind of agreed on that together. So it wasn't necessarily, as many places reported, kind of a blow to Netanyahu. It's something they actually spoke about and agreed. Looking ahead to our next presidential election, it is possible that a major candidate from either party in 2028 might promise to untether our militaries and to actually shut off aid to Israel altogether. What exactly would that mean for Israel? It really depends on how this thing will exactly happen. Is it the aid in its current form? Will they shift that to joint military projects? All these dollars up until now, they all went immediately back to America, right? We need to also remember that,
26:33that the aid funds, they serve to buy military equipment only from the United States. It's essentially the U.S. giving money to U.S. companies and then donating that equipment to Israel. Yes. It's basically aid for Lockheed Martin, right? You recently wrote a column with the title, Israel's Opposition Take Note. The Global Pendulum is Shifting. column, you likened Netanyahu's focus on the loyalty of Israel's Arab citizens to Trump's scapegoating of immigrants in the United States, both of which you say voters rejected in our respective elections. You also advocated for the Israeli opposition to join forces with Arab parties in Israel. Gadi Eisenkot has spoken about joining with the Israeli Arab parties.
27:27But here's a clip from Balad leader Sami Abu Shahadeh, a Palestinian Israeli politician. He says, we are ready to pay a very high price to make this racist a prime minister because we think he is less bad than Netanyahu. We don't have good options. Because of some of his opposition to Netanyahu and his apparent openness to working with Israel's Arab parties to form a government, some coverage has cast Gadi Eizenkot as a sort of reformer. He's definitely a very mainstream, center-leaning, former IDF chief that's not a leftist in terms of Israeli politics and I think in general. But these are people that share, first of all, a deep concern about the Israeli democratic institutions, the way that Israel's mainstream
28:22political center always saw Israel as seeing itself or wanting to be a Western democracy, even a liberal-leaning one. And these people really opposed what Netanyahu was trying to do, which is to fight the concept of these institutions and the very delicate balance that the liberal center wants to see in the components of Israel being a Jewish yet democratic country. In the lead up to the election, I saw a number of clips of Israeli candidates being asked if they supported a Palestinian state. It's a hell no. Of course no. No, definitely not. No, no, no. The clear answer is no. Clearly not, and we'll fight it tooth and nail in every which way we can. If Eisenhower is successful in forming a majority in the Knesset with Arab-Israeli members, do you think Palestinians will be given
29:18any meaningful concessions? These are all, of course, my personal opinions and beliefs. The Israeli opposition, as I said, they're not leftists and some of them not even liberal. The more Israel shifts to the right, the more these people, in order to have more voters, they're not going to say things like they support a Palestinian state. It's problematic, but if I'm not purist about it, I think that sometimes it doesn't matter so much what people say, it matters what they do. The fact that the Israeli opposition doesn't say some of the things, you know, that a liberal crowd wants to hear, like that they support a two-state solution or Palestinian statehood, etc. In the end, if they do have to form a coalition with our parties, it will have an impact along the way on policies.
30:09We spoke with Oren Persico from the Seventh Eye back in January 2024, who told us, quote, basically, Israelis are inside a bubble and are unaware of A, what's going on in Gaza and B, how it's seen in the entire world. When you speak with your Israeli friend or relative or whatever, you should remind yourself that you're speaking with someone who is in a parallel universe and who does not see what you see. I think he's right. But there's also some aspects to add, I think, to that. It's true that many Israelis, they're not shown what's happening in Gaza. And it's also true that the trauma of October 7th is essential to understanding the public atmosphere. And journalists were part of a society that was experiencing that shock,
30:59the grief, the fear. Many of them had deeply personal connections to what has happened. On the other hand, you know, Israelis do have social media accounts. They do have grief, the fear. Many of them had deeply personal connections to what has happened. On the other hand, you know, Israelis do have social media accounts. They do have internet. They're also capable of finding information if they really want that. Of course. I guess what I'm trying to understand, though, is whether you as a Israeli journalist, at a time when the country is going through pretty significant political change, whether you ever feel disconnected or alienated from the sentiment that we just described? We and people that read us and people that do and can confront the information as it is, do exist. The country is shifting to the right,
31:46but I cannot think that this is something that is scientifically only going to go in one direction. What feeds this optimism of yours? People are capable of changing. I really do think that younger people seek better answers, also better questions. And that's why, you know, when I look at that, I am hopeful. There's always hope because things can always change. Noah, thank you very much. Noah Landau is the global editor of Haaretz. Coming up, socialism is as American as apple pie and vast income inequality. A history after the break. This is On the Media. This is On the Media. I'm Michael Loewinger. And I'm Brooke Gladstone. One notable datum in the post-midterm analysis is the number of officials headed to Congress with a scarlet S on their lapels.
32:55New York now has three Democratic socialists in Congress. Colorado, California, Michigan and Pennsylvania also elected DSA members to the House of Representatives, bringing the total there now to six. Of course, for months, Republicans have been warning of this scourge. They use the word social democrat because it sounds so nice, but it's really communism. Donald Trump. I think it's the biggest threat to our nation. There is, maybe since our founding. That includes World War I, World War II, September 11th. And yet in October, Vice President J.D. Vance, when asked to define the political philosophy, sort of, well... Oh, man. You know, I guess it's honestly, it's a hard term to define these days because very often socialism, you know, classically you would think socialism is about prioritizing workers.
33:52I think in reality what it actually means in the American context is that you want to replace American workers with foreign workers and you want boys to play in girls' sports. Socialism does have a definition and that's not it. It also has a long American history. It's a fire kindled by particular conditions like these in the early part of the 20th century. There was very little regulation of corporations. There was a huge income gap between the very rich and everybody else who worked for very little. Michael Kazin is a history professor at Georgetown University, DSA member, and author of many books on American political history, including What It Took to Win, A History of the Democratic Party.
34:36And the socialists spoke to the discontents, especially about the unequal economy, the lack of democracy in the Senate, in the Electoral College. Also, they were in favor of government being more powerful. They wanted an income tax amendment. They wanted municipal ownership of utilities. They wanted workers to have a minimum wage. The kind of things that liberal Democrats later on, especially in the New Deal, began to take up as well. The Socialist Party of America was the precursor to the DSA, with the big difference that it was actually a party and wasn't folded under Republicans or Democrats. Exactly. They really believed that if you want to get to socialism, to a collectively owned economy and society,
35:15you can't dilute your message by saying, well, we're for socialism, but we're going to run as Democrats or Republicans because we actually want to win. So their campaigns, at least for national office, were very much educational. They didn't expect to win, but they expected to recruit more people to the cause. And as with all political parties, there were factions. Well, the one thing that's always true about socialists is that they like to disagree. They enjoy debating with one another. Debating, I think, is a very gentle word to describe some of the knockdown dragouts, but go ahead. There was a difference, for example, in what kind of unions socialists worked in. Some socialists supported a revolutionary union called the Industrial Workers of the World
35:51who wanted to move as quickly as possible to a huge general strike and try to stop capitalism from operating. But most socialists were active in the American Federation of Labor, in which most members did not want a revolution. They just wanted higher wages and to be treated better at work. And it was the major labor federation in the country. It had about four million members in 1920, whereas the Industrial Workers of the World only had about 100,000 members. The charismatic figure leading the charge was Eugene Debs. He was a great orator, first of all, born in Indiana in a railroad hub in Terre Haute. And until he was 40, actually, he was not a socialist. He only became a socialist after he had led a big railway union.
36:31Yeah, can you paint that picture for us? He was a railroad worker. Then he became the head of his union, the Brotherhood of Locomotive Firemen. They engaged in a strike and they lost. He got embittered against the railroad owners. And then in 1894, he was frustrated with these different unions of different railroad crafts, firemen, conductors, engineers. He wanted one big railroad union and formed the American Railway Union in 1893. 1894, they got involved in boycotting Pullman cars, the sleeping cars and dining cars that used to be on every long distance train because the Pullman workers who made the cars in a little company town in Illinois had their wages cut, but the prices in the company store where they had to shop were not cut. So they joined the American Railway
37:13Union, and in support of the Pullman workers, every member of the American Railway Union said they would not work on any train that was carrying a Pullman car. And that meant trains that carried mail. President Grover Cleveland brought in the Army to break the strike. A federal court ruled that Debs and other American Railway Union leaders were in contempt of court for not stopping the strike, and Debs went to jail for several months. He emerged from jail having read a lot of socialist literature and met various socialist leaders proclaiming himself a socialist. By 1900, he's the head of a new socialist party and is running for president. How many times did he run for president? Five times. Four times under the banner of the Socialist Party of America. In 1900,
37:53the Socialist Party of America hadn't formed yet, and so he ran as the candidate of a different, smaller party. And the last time, he ran from jail because he'd been jailed by the Wilson administration for opposing the draft. He ran from the Atlanta penitentiary and got about a million votes. You wrote that he was the most captivating spokesman for American socialism until Bernie Sanders, and that both understood that invoking symbols cherished by most Americans help gain legitimacy for radical ideas. Debs used to celebrate the Fourth of July, the Independence Day picnics, and he said, this country was founded in a revolution, and we should have another revolution, this time against capitalism. He was not personally a religious man, but he understood most Americans
38:36were religious. He gave a speech at one point in which he said that Jesus Christ was the first communist. That reminds me of when he spoke to Lincoln Steffens in, I think it was 1908. So long as he must fight for a job or a fortune, he cannot love his neighbor. Christianity is impossible under capitalists. This was true of a lot of radicals back then. The populists, the original populists, the People's Party of the 1890s also had a lot of ministers who preached that Christianity had to be applied to help the poor, to help working people. You shouldn't let the modern-day money changers invade the temple. Christian socialism was a real thing back then, and to some degree perhaps still is. People like Scott Colombe, who just won in Mississippi, James Tallarico in Texas, people who believe that in order to be a good Christian,
39:25you have to believe in a larger welfare state. And that's what Debs believed. Very much so. But he wasn't always in lockstep with his fellow radicals. For instance, he was committed to racial equality, and many in his movement were not. Yeah, this is a time when Jim Crow was fastening its terrible grip, not just on the South, but in large parts of the North as well. And a lot of people in Debs' party, they just said, look, we need to win over white workers. Most white workers don't really want to mix with black workers or with Chinese workers or often with Mexican-American workers. So let's either not talk about Jim Crow or let's say, well, we'll deal with it over time. Whereas Debs was actually unusual in
40:05that more and more, he believed that it was both unjust to have racist policies, or at least to avoid talking about racist policies. But he also began to get to know people like A. Philip Randolph, who later on becomes head of a big black union, brother of sleeping car porters, and later on becomes the father of the March on Washington in 1963. And so it was both personal and political. In the end, Debs was true to his principles. I mean, socialists, after all, have always believed that there's nothing that should divide working people from one another. The SBA never saw electoral success. You noted that in the 1912 presidential election, at his peak, Debs received only 6% of the vote, never came close to winning a single state.
40:46Only two congressmen were ever elected on the SBA ticket. Tell me why. Well, this is one of the things historians and political scientists and socialists themselves have been arguing about for decades. First of all, socialist parties elsewhere in the world, especially in Europe, where they were much stronger than they were in the United States, were leading advocates of making sure that all adult men got the right to vote. And once they got the right to vote, with the help of socialists, adult men in Europe backed the socialist party for that reason. Whereas this country, most adult white men got the right to vote by the 1820s and 1830s before there was any socialist party. Also, you know, the key dividing point in American history has usually been race rather than class. After all, the most important event in American history is
41:30the Civil War. So socialists kept saying, no, class really matters. But other people sort of said, well, if you're Mississippi and you're a white worker, you might be very badly off, but you feel you're much better off than the black worker. But Debs said race matters. You can't love your neighbor if you can't feed yourself. But loving your neighbor is essentially the goal. Very true. But of course, Black and white people, we're not using neighbors. That's part of the problem. And also, the Electoral College is one reason, too, why socialists didn't get very far. Because after all, you can elect socialists to the House. But to really be a major force on the political scene, you need states.
42:06And socialists could never get a plurality of the vote in a state. So workers who went to his rallies and cheered him usually didn't vote for him because they didn't want to waste their vote. You suggest that World War I doomed the S.P.A. Well, the S.P.A. was in effect declared illegal by the Wilson administration during the war. Many socialist papers were closed down or prohibited from using second-class mailing privileges, so they were much too expensive to send to people across the country. You wrote that after Debs told draft-age men at a socialist party picnic, you need at this time to know that you are fit for something better than slavery and cannon fodder. He was tried and convicted for violating the Espionage Act and sentenced to 10 years in prison.
42:52Wilson's government response to dissent was the greatest repression of civil liberties in U.S. history. There was a real fear that the anti-war movement would be so large as to make it very hard for the United States to send troops over to France. So, Debs, he never got elected, but what about his ideas? Some of those got a lot of traction during the 20th century. FDR's New Deal was, in many ways, an offspring of so many of those pro-union, pro-worker reforms, the WPA, Social Security, the Fair Labor Standards Act, I'm just wondering why that didn't revive the SPA. Well, ironically, once FDR begins and Democratic Congress begin to institute these New Deal policies, a lot of socialists say, well, you know, I'd like to vote for someone who can win, who's sticking it to the very rich, to the economic royalists, the way Franklin Roosevelt called them in 1836. So I think I'll
43:49vote for Democrats now. And so it was the New Deal, which in some ways really killed the Socialist Party. And you also observed that the Cold War pointed out the differences within the factions of the party. Well, the communists became 1930s really actually a more influential party of the American left than the Socialist Party was, because the Socialist Party was... Absorbed by the Dems. Yeah, and the communists were very active in organizing industrial unions like the steel workers and auto workers. They were involved in the Civil Rights Movement at that point. They were an interracial party, the way the Socialists had not been. But then the Cold War begins. The communists were involved in very pure socialist causes.
44:29But as you say, the ultimate aim for many of them was creating a Soviet America in firm alliance with Stalin's USSR. And that was not popular among most Americans. Having a political party who really pays obeisance to a foreign leader, to Joseph Stalin. The communists were never going to really become a mass party because of that. It really wasn't until after the Cold War that the term socialism could be used again by Americans to say, no, this is an American cause. As I read about it, it struck me that maybe the specter haunting American socialism was, and maybe still is, the potential of the left eating its own. Well, there's really a conflict between socialists who really are what in Europe are called social democrats.
45:16People like Mamdani, I think, like Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, like Bernie Sanders, too, who believe that sweeping changes can be made within a capitalist society, like Medicare for All, like a higher minimum wage, like stronger labor unions, taxing the rich more, but are not talking about doing away with capitalism. Whereas there are people in DSA and there are people in the Socialist Party who believe that's not going to do it. Workers are going to be exploited as long as you work for somebody else. And what you need is to do away with that system of exploitation. That's real socialism with a capital S and not social democracy. And there are a lot of caucuses in DSA, one called the Red Star Caucus, another one called the Communist Caucus.
45:53And they don't oppose reforms, but they make clear that it's not going to be enough. You have to do away with the capitalists altogether. There's certainly risk of fracture. I want to play you two pieces of tape, both from interviews on Fox News. The first was in July when Fox host Shannon Bream quizzed DSA co-chair Megan Romer on her views. Okay, replace the presidency and Supreme Court as we now know them. Yep. Abolish ICE. Absolutely. Abolish borders and give amnesty to anyone currently in the U.S. illegally. As a long-term plan, yep. Abolish prisons, at least in large part. Yeah, again, as part of a long-term program, yeah. And then here's Mayor Mamdani with Fox's bream on the Sunday after the midterms. Okay, get rid of borders? No. Get rid of SCOTUS?
46:45No. Get rid of jails? No. So, do you think DSA is going to kick you out? No. If the far left of the DSA sees reformist takes as palliatives that sustain a corrupt and unjust system, is there a way to square that circle? Probably not, in the end. Megan Romer has no power really outside the organization, only inside the organization, whereas Mamdani, of course, has a lot of power. He runs the largest city in the country. I think you can say Mamdani is the candidate of the possible left, whereas Romer is more the candidate of the impossible left. It's funny. Jill Lepore said that there was a strange new twist in this argument between socialist determinism and technological determinism. The Democratic Party may well
47:34advance socialism's most practical and urgent demands, but Silicon Valley seems keen to turn socialism's most extravagant dream into a nightmare, a world in which people no longer have to do anything because they're no longer needed. Well, it's the kind of utopianism from the top. The people who really have the power in that scenario are people like Musk and other multibillionaires or even trillionaires. That's not, of course, socialism. Socialism is a democratic ideology, whether or not all socialists have followed that idea. The idea is that the working people, the majority, are in power, and that's not what the Silicon Valley utopians are talking about. But the end result would be the same. You'd get to go to the park with your kid in the afternoon
48:18and not have to work so hard. There's a group called Technocracy back in the 30s, engineers, including Elon Musk's grandfather, who believed that technology was going to solve all these problems, much like now. There was going to be no need for most human labor. I mean, the difference, of course, is that the AI utopians, if you can call them that, they want to stay in control. And also, they forget that most people want to work. Most people do not want to just sit around and do nothing. People want to be productive. Socialists talk about work being more creative, not about abolishing work. Right. So as a lifelong scholar of the movement, do you think it can overcome its historical obstacles and the political structural obstacles and the bad press and actually make America
49:02less corrupt and more just this time around? It really depends, I think, on whether the socialists who've been elected, mayors of D.C., New York, Seattle, and also socialists in Congress, can show they can govern, pass programs, enforce reforms, address the problems that Americans have. It won't be advertisement for revolutionary socialism, but it'd be advertisement for socialists being people you can trust to solve your problems and to speak to those problems in an eloquent and empathetic way. Michael, thank you so much. Sure. Michael Kazin is a professor of history at Georgetown University, DSA member and author of What It Took to Win, A History of the Democratic Party. That's it for this week's show. On the Media is produced by Molly Rosen, Rebecca Clark-Calendar,
49:59and Candace Wong. Travis Manin is our video producer. Our technical director is Jennifer Munson with engineering from Greg Rippin and Jared Paul. Eloise Blondio is our senior producer, and our executive producer is Katya Rogers. On the Media is produced by WNYC. I'm Brooke Gladstone. And I'm Michael Loewinger.





