Oh God, What Now? · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
A panel of UK journalists tests the Brexiteer objections to rejoining the EU, from bacon crisps to military bases, then runs through the week's news.
Tap a chapter to play it from that moment in the show's own player; the transcript opens there too.
“The thing is that he's opened the door, which is the first step to actually talking about this.” Jason Haisley · at 21:52 — ▶ hear it from here
“I think the David Walliams story has a long way more to run, and we may find out a lot more.” Jason Haisley · at 36:46 — ▶ hear it from here
Ros Taylor, Marie Leconte, Jason Haisley and Seth Tevles open with Andy Burnham's suggestion that Britain might rejoin the EU, and with the objections Brexiteers now raise. Some are practical. A food standards deal could strip the word bacon from plant-based packaging, which would put smoky bacon crisps in trouble. The government puts the alignment at five billion pounds in growth. The panel sees it as small, and finds the Telegraph's full English breakfast campaign overblown.
The harder obstacles are political. Any member state can veto a rejoin, and Cyprus has pressed for British military bases that cover roughly 3% of the island to be removed. Gibraltar and Britain's old opt-outs, including the pound, could come back as bargaining chips. A rejoin would probably need a referendum, and the panel debates whether it should come before or after negotiations. Burnham has opened a door that Keir Starmer kept shut, but the panel wants Labour's red lines retired first.
The final stretch turns to persuasion and recent news. The panel argues a rejoin campaign must appeal to feelings as well as the economy, and blames Remain's 2016 focus on four regions and a disastrous press conference. They also cover the David Walliams allegations, Russell Brand's conviction and the Guardian's earlier enthusiasm for him, the Commonwealth meeting, and Kemi Badenoch's plan to cut welfare.
Jason Haisley says Andy Burnham has played the rejoining question pretty well, because he has opened the door that Keir Starmer could not find the key to. He thinks what happens next depends on whether Burnham calls an early general election and what happens to Labour's red lines, which Chris Ward has said need a dignified retirement.
“The thing is that he's opened the door, which is the first step to actually talking about this.”Jason Haisley · 21:52
Seth Tevles argues the EU should revisit a special status for Canada, such as associate membership, which Ursula von der Leyen has floated and Germany, France and Greece have blocked. He says Canada has been a very reliable ally for Britain, is a bilingual power, and sits in a strategically important Arctic position.
“Canada has been a very, very reliable ally for us.”Seth Tevles · 24:37
Marie Leconte says the main objection likely to come from a member state is Cyprus, where some politicians have asked the European Commission to demand that Britain remove its military bases. She says a Cypriot MEP called the sites a remnant of colonialism, and she expects Cyprus to be a big sticking point in any rejoin talks.
“colonial bases from every corner of Europe”Marie Leconte · 11:56
Marie Leconte says the Conservatives claim their plan would save £36 billion a year from the welfare budget, including £2.8 billion from ending disability living allowance for many children with milder conditions. She is sceptical, questioning how severe cases would be defined and whether the plan would cost a lot to assess everyone.
“the plans will definitely work and have definitely been thought through very well”Marie Leconte · 47:14
The panel argues that the obstacles to rejoining the EU are real but not decisive, naming the euro, possible Cypriot demands over British bases, the loss of Britain's old opt-outs, and a likely second referendum. They conclude that a rejoin campaign has to appeal to emotion as well as the economy, and that Britain should stop calling it Brexit.
The panel says Andy Burnham has done what Keir Starmer would not, by opening the door to talking about Britain rejoining the EU. They think he is playing it well, but they argue Labour's red lines, such as Chris Ward's, need to be retired first. Ros Taylor and the others also say the word Brexit should be dropped from the debate in favour of simply talking about joining the EU.
Seth Tevles says a full rejoin would almost certainly mean another referendum, because a manifesto commitment would be hard to stand on alone. The panel notes that Britain's first referendum came two years after it joined the EEC. The big open question, they say, is whether the vote happens before or after renegotiating the terms.
Jason Haisley explains that the UK and EU are aligning food standards in an agreement due later this month, and that words such as bacon, chicken and beef may have to come off plant-based food packaging. Smoky bacon crisps are bacon-free, so the name could no longer be used and they may need a new one, such as smoky crisps.
Marie Leconte says some Cypriot politicians have called on the European Commission to demand that Britain remove its colonial bases from Europe, and that one MEP described them as a remnant of colonialism. Seth Tevles adds that the bases cover about 3% of Cyprus and that the United States also uses them. Because any member state can veto a rejoin, Cyprus could make demands.
Marie Leconte reports that the Conservatives say their plan would save the taxpayer £36 billion a year from the welfare budget. The breakdown she gives includes £2.8 billion from ending disability living allowance for families of children with milder cases, £13.7 billion from changes to sickness and disability benefits, and £3.1 billion from reintroducing the two-child benefit cap. She questions how severe cases would be defined.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.
0:00Hello, and welcome to Oh God, What Now? The politics podcast that can't help wondering whether Nvidia chips or frozen chips are more at risk. I'm Ros Taylor. On today's show, we're looking at the arguments Brexiteers are making against rejoining the EU. Some of them are practical, and some of them are about crisps. What are the real obstacles we'd face? Plus, the panel discuss some of the biggest stories of the week, including the David Walliams accusations, the NVIDIA honey trap, and how Kemi Badenoch plans to cut welfare. And in the extra bit for Patreon supporters, it turns out a member of U2 wrote a sequel to the Elf movie. What sequels would the panel like to write? All that and more on Oh God, What Now?
1:03Hello again, and before we start, a date for your diary. Be at home with a glass of something festive and cold on the evening of Thursday the 3rd of December. It's the Oh God What Now Christmas live stream, just for Patreon supporters. Christmas elves John Elledge, Marie Leconte and James Ball will be gathering around decrepit supermarket Santa Andrew Harrison to review the year, play some festive games and answer your questions, all live from the Podmasters grotto. It's possible that Christmas jumpers might be worn. It's all free to Patreon supporters, no registration required, so follow the Patreon link in the show notes, sign up to back us and we'll see you for Oh God, What Noel? Let's meet the panel.
1:46Joining us today, she writes for The New World and The Observer and she's the star of a new generation of London art curators. It's Marie Leconte. Hello. You bled your radiators today. How did that go? Real high and low there, Rose, thank you. I'm actually delighted you asked. No, I actually bled my radiators a few weeks ago because I'm really, really handy. I'm really good with DIY, etc. And I was about to go repressurize my boiler, except I'd not realized my flat, in a very kind of London renting sort of way, has a very ungodly sort of setup. So I kind of looked at all the bits and none of the bits are where the bits ought to be. So I made that my landlord's problem. And actually what happened today
2:25is that a bloke came in to actually look and it was very satisfying because he opened the door and went, ah, and I was like, yeah, right. So it was a horrible kind of setup. I'm not stupid. I'm not. But yeah, so I now officially have like full strength heating back in the flat, which is really nice. Well, the way journalism's going, we'll both be doing a BTEC in plumbing soon. He's a musician and writer who worked on Kung Kong Cinema, starting this week on BBC Two, and iPlayer. It's Jason Haisley. Hello, Ros. Who's Philomena interrogating this time? You're not going to ask me about radiators, no? No. I mean, I did the one in the bathroom recently, because that's the highest one in the house, so just to keep the pressure up,
3:02you know, and then repressurise the boiler as well. You probably have got a BTEC in plumbing, haven't you yeah yeah i'm ready i'm ready i've got my fire exit ready who's um filomena interrogating this time or a variety of people directors dops a composer um she talks to michael bay um i don't know whether it's him but i did write a question for her that said um you obviously like explosions in films when are you going to make an explosion the main character? So we'll see whether that gets through. She also talks to Benedict Cumberbatch, who looks, you know, when you put Diane up against someone, they kind of know what's going on, but they have to behave in a certain way. But Cumberbatch in it
3:37does look genuinely quite at sea. So enjoy that. Yeah, it would be worth it for that. Completing the panel, he's a journalist and historian who's the world's leading expert on private members clubs. It's Seth Tevles. Hello. I have radiators as well. And actually, they were switched on today without my doing anything about them. My flatmate had apparently done them. He'll be finding out about this because he often listens to Oh God, What Now in the shower. And so I hear the strange sound of my own voice coming from the bathroom. So I don't listen to this show, but my flatmate does. I think it's without first I was like, oh no, it's your flatmate listens to you now. Oh no, your flatmate listens naked.
4:18I don't ask. You don't ask whether he wears anything in the shower? I mean, I wouldn't ask anybody that question. Should we all say hi by the way? Should we all say hi to Seth Flatmate? I always do, Seth. Hello, Seth Flatmate. Are you dressed? Don't forget the hair. During my days in the Brexit trenches, I remember some quite high-minded arguments being made for leaving the EU. Things like national sovereignty, self-determination, the dictatorship of supranational institutions. So now that Andy Burnham suggested we might rejoin, it's been intriguing to see what arguments the Brexiteers are making for why we should stay out. We'll be getting into the genuine obstacles to rejoining shortly. But first, let's consider some of the more urgent objections.
5:02Jason, tell us about the threat to the smoky bacon crisp. Yeah, of course you're going to ask me about crisps, aren't you? As, oh God, what now is crisp correspondent? Because I recommended that crisp book a few weeks ago by Natalie Whittle. So the threat to the smoky bacon crisp. The headline here is effectively the EU and the UK are aligning on certain food standards. They're signing an agreement later this month. The agricultural lobby was very keen for this but one of the side effects is that some words might have to be removed from plant-based food packaging so words like bacon chicken beef which is where the smoky bacon crisps are in trouble but also words like fillet ribs and steak are going to have to come
5:44off things so i mean i've eaten a cauliflower steak in a restaurant before but that's not in packaging so maybe that won't be affected um sausages and burgers are two words that aren't affected by this curiously but the thing is that smoky bacon crisps we learn are bacon free so because they're bacon free the eu is going well you can't really call them smoky bacon crisps, can you? So they may have to find some new name, smoky crisps or whatever. The government's very pleased about this idea because it says that it's worth five billion pounds in growth. The Food and Drink Federation is very pleased with the idea because it will reduce red tape. Guess who's not pleased with the idea? Wait for it. It's the person that listeners to this show will know as Frank Mansour,
6:28chairman of the ERG, who apparently is still a thing, according to The Telegraph, but who knows. He's unhappy about it because this is the EU telling us what to write on our crisp packets, apparently. Surely we should call him Mansour just to wind him up. Fran-Mansour? Fran-Mansour. Yeah, let's him up. Fran, Fran Monsoir? Fran Monsoir. Yeah, let's make him properly French, shall we? What? I object to properly French there. Yeah, no, there's no way he would like to be properly French. He'd object to that as well, I'm sure. So this is not a bad thing. You know, it's just a small realignment. The Food and Drink Federation are perfectly happy with it. The agricultural lobby is perfectly happy with it. and there's also something to be said for what if i buy like a
7:08packet of i don't know smoked salmon or something from the supermarket now it's stamped on it not for eu which i find quite depressing because that just reminds me that this fucking arrangement robbed us of prosperity and freedoms and work opportunities and friends and things. And so to get that off packets of things, I think would be quite pleasing, because it's a bit like getting a reminder from your phone every morning going, hey, remember your dad's dead? Yes, I know my dad's dead. I don't need to be reminded of this. Thanks very much. I'm just going to jump in here to say that David Cameron, friend of the podcast, just told Michelle Hussain that he does not believe that Britain should rejoin the EU.
7:48And he has warned Andy Burnham that starting a conversation about rejoining would be, I quote, very long and painful. And to which I say, by which I mean nothing I could possibly ever want to say about this should be broadcast. I thought that was the idea of flatlining there, which would have been. Yeah, no, no, no. It was just a lot of like C words, essentially, I think, arranged in a florid manner. No, I yeah, I have no interest in in knowing about his opinion on this. I felt, you know, it was worth mentioning, bringing as a piece of breaking news. But it is Jesus Christ. I know exactly. He needs to get back to the footnotes, doesn't he? Well, there are wise elder statesmen in British politics.
8:26And then there's David Cameron. No, that's not him. It's Liz Truss. Jason, food has been a Brexiteer obsession ever since Boris Johnson first started wanging on about bendy bananas back in the day. The Telegraph claims that the British breakfast is in jeopardy and there's a risk ketchup sachets might be outlawed. Yes. It's time to be alive. Sorry. Why do we lack so much confidence in our food choices here? I mean, you never hear other countries complaining that the EU stops them eating their favourite food. Well, I presume it's because the EU doesn't stop people eating foods. Unless someone said, well, excuse me, Brussels, why can't I have puppy on toast? I'm pretty sure Brussels would be happy to go,
9:07you eat what you like. The Daily Telegraph ran with this this week with a photo of a full English breakfast, which they detailed with arrows and things that were wrong with each of the items. So on tea, there was an arrow saying, rules on pesticides, which is like, okay, we want fewer pesticides on tea leaves. That doesn't sound like a bad thing to me. Similarly, the EU wants fewer pesticides on mushrooms and fewer fungicides on tomatoes. Now that all sounds like good stuff, doesn't it? Like not having food covered in chemicals. Next to jam, there was an arrow saying must have 450 grams of fruit per kilo, which is, well, that's good. You know, currently the rule is 350 grams. You can put 500 grams per kilo in
9:51and then you have to describe it as extra jam, which is not a phrase I've ever heard, but it's very exciting, isn't it? There's an arrow next to sausages saying banned in the EU, which is absolute crap. Sausages are not banned in the EU. What was banned was the export of fresh ones ones but the frozen ones could still be transported so this is just just absolute nonsense dreamed up by the telegraph to say your full english breakfast is under fire and i'm not the first person to point out and say how many people actually have a full english breakfast every day most people have just like yoghurt, porridge, something small. Not everybody wants like two fried eggs, a sausage, two rashers of bacon, beans, tomatoes, mushrooms, toast, blah, blah, blah.
10:30Not Franck Mansoir. Franck Homme Soir. I think Franck Homme Mansoir is actually great. Like Franco Manca, but twatish. Francois Mansoir. Oh God, what now? The Sproke podcast. Marie, rejoining does pose challenges that didn't trouble us before and serious ones, some of them. One is the euro. We might have to indicate that we're willing to join the single currency, even if we don't join it right away. It would mean the Bank of England could no longer change interest rates, which is, you know, maybe not optimal. Is this the biggest potential obstacle to rejoining as Britons are attached to the pound, even if we don't use cash as much as we used to? Well, actually, I think your last point, and I have no idea, to be clear, this is me guessing a bit, but I wonder if it wouldn't
11:18play quite a massive part, actually, in the changing debate, because I think just not having the currency, not having notes and, you know, and coins, I think, basically ever, probably really changes your relationship to the currency. And I suspect that, you know, I still obviously remember, remember the time when lots of stuff was cash only, despite only being 22. But I think, you know, like new generations, the actual young people probably have never really meaningfully handled cash all that much. So yes, I do wonder if that changes the kind of emotional nature of it a bit. And aside from that, I do slightly worry that, and I hate this, but you know, free movement will be the thing actually, I think the Brexit is will really, really hammer any kind of plan to rejoin
11:56on. But yes, I don't know, I think that the euro again, and there's not, I tried to look for it, there's not been any recent, I think, polling on that specific topic, to the best of my knowledge. I'd be curious to see it because I'm not really sure. I'd be surprised if it really were a massive issue, especially with anyone under kind of, you know, 60, 70. But yeah, whereas I think immigration, annoyingly, is still proven to work as a kind of like big scare story. There's also the fact that any member state can veto us rejoining. And that raises the prospect of them demanding things from us. What beefs do they have with us? Well, I think the main one comes from Cyprus. I mean, some Cypriot politicians have called on the European Commission to demand that Britain just removes all, I quote, colonial bases from every corner of Europe.
12:41And there are several army bases still in Cyprus, which, yeah, clearly some of the parties there really, really object to. And including that one MEP who described the military sites as a remnant of colonialism depriving the Republic of Cyprus of the exercise of sovereignty over European territory, which are quite strong words, really. So, yes, I think that that's going to be quite a big one. I'm not really sure how attached Britain is to those military bases. I suspect we're about to find out. But, yes, it'll be interesting to see what else comes out, especially because we're about to have a number of elections as well. You know, France is about to have an election. I have no idea what Le Pen, you know, President Le Pen would say
13:18to Britain wanting to rejoin. At the moment, she looks quite likely to win. So we'll have to contend with that. We've got Poland having an election later at the end of next year. It's not, you know, obviously very hard to guess what's going to happen there. But the populist right may come back in, which I would hate, but that is a possibility. What would they do? What would they ask of Britain? You know, what would be their pound of flesh? I think it's, yeah, the worry there is that I think different governments will have kind of different unpredictable demands. Seth, what might our neighbors demand from us? I mean, the Cyprus dimension is a really interesting one because it's not just the UK that wants the use of those air bases in Cyprus.
13:55It's actually the US. And this was a real sort of talking point actually during the recent air raids around Iran. Keir Starmer made a great point of saying we're not going to get dragged into that war. Naturally, we got dragged into that war. And although they were ostensibly just launching purely defensive missions from there and supply missions and things like that, in reality, they ended up making themselves a target. I perfectly understand why the Cypriots resent having airstrikes launched against their country. And yes, they only went against the airbases, not against the rest of the country. But those airbases do cover 3% of the entire country. I mean, it's a not inconsiderable proportion of
14:33the island of Cyprus. So that's the obvious sort of territorial thing. The other obvious sort of thing to come up would be Gibraltar. Spain at every opportunity likes to talk about this a lot. I'm not sure Spain is in the best bargaining position on this. I think you need only mention Ceuta and Melilla, the portion of Morocco. I am Moroccan-ly nodding. Indeed. That's a Moroccan nod, is it? All you need to do to point out that it's more or less a stalemate on this argument is if you're having a map of Gibraltar on screen, pull out just slightly wider because it's across the same straight of water. It really is sort of parallel to that. The other sort of longer term thing, which is all quite technical and messy,
15:13is actually the question of our opt-outs. Because we spent 40 odd years being an absolute nuisance member of the European community, demanding an opt-out at every single opportunity. The end result of which is that we were able to opt out from an astonishing number of things, including, for example, the European single currency. We're not going to get any of those opt-outs if we join. In fact, we may have to offer some sweeteners in the deal out of a sheer position of desperation. I think, I mean, the French might demand of us that we start referring to him as François Monsoir, I suppose um i don't know honestly what occurred to me was that like the entire eu might might say to us yeah we have an idea could you
15:51just fuck off please you were at this party for many years and you were a pain in the ass now you're outside tapping on the window and going yoohoo it's us again i can see why they would ask for almost anything frankly and just in terms of being the the more pissed off they are, the more demands they might make. So I think we'd have to go in there very carefully and expecting that we might lose the pound or something. By the way, Murray, congratulations on using the phrase pound of flesh and not 454 grams of flesh. That's very, very British of you. You've assimilated beautifully. I actually still don't know what a pound is. So I see pounds quite often and someone will be like, oh, my God, I lost three pounds.
16:24And I give it the Moroccan nod. But yeah, I have no idea what it means. Seth, when Burnham first started talking about rethinking our relationship with the EU, I thought he would go for the Norway option in the single market and the customs union, but not in the EU. But the mood music seems to be turning against that. Yeah. I mean, I might respond here with a very Swiss nod because Switzerland, having tried this actually over the last 50 years with several dozen bilateral treaties that effectively give them most of the rights and responsibilities of EU membership, except the fact that they can't actually elect anyone towards that. They are rule takers rather than rule makers. And if you speak to Swiss politicians who tread this very careful line because they keep losing every single vote in referendum of Swiss public opinion
17:11on the idea of EU membership, but at the same time, they all know that it's a no-brainer, but they will tell you, it's not really worth it, actually. It would be so much better if we just went through with it and were formally recognised as a member of the EU. So if you're starting that whole conversation now, let's not even pretend that this is a sensible option. Full fat rejoin would mean another referendum. Sure. And I can't see a way around that. Would it though? Could it not go into a general election manifesto? Manifesto. Started that before realising that it doesn't quite. Would it? Yeah. I mean, tell me. The counterfactual, of course, is we went into the EEC originally via a manifesto
17:47commitment for the Tories. But then we introduced two years later was our first ever referendum was introduced on should we now leave promptly now that we've arrived. I don't think it's particularly easy to not go for a referendum. The big meaningful question actually will be whether you do this before or after the negotiations, because everyone's saying was saying at the time of the last referendum, why on earth are we having this on a hypothetical when we don't know the terms of the treaty? And this was actually a perfectly reasonable argument for a second vote. It was now we do know what the terms are. So the meaningful choice arguably, if you argue that, would be, well, let's wait until we've actually renegotiated something. On the other hand, you can see how that referendum then gets hijacked by, well, on paragraph 27, subsection 3, has one particular sentence we don't like.
18:33And we're going to quote out of context because we know that the Leave Brigade are so fair-minded in doing these things. A referendum every six months until we all die. Well, I think anyway. The EU can-can. We're in, we all die. Well, I think anyway... The can-can, the EU can-can, we're in, we're out, we're in, we're out. It's easier to host the referendum beforehand on the principle. It's not particularly legitimate, but not hosting one is also not particularly legitimate. So you get it out of the way and then just press ahead. Marie, the Norway option means we wouldn't have a seat at the table. And in some ways that might suit the EU as Jason was sort of hinting earlier. We had a reputation for blocking things and being half-hearted about the project,
19:11not to mention electing Nigel Farage to the European Parliament. Does Brussels want us hanging around the place again or would it be simpler if we just weren't there? So I think I'm actually going to defend Britain slightly here in that I don't think Britain is in any way the exception in sending complete twats to the European Parliament. I think, you know, MEPs, every country like France definitely has its own very fair share of like insane MEPs. Many, many other countries do. And I think that is one of the problems of the EU as a political project as it stands. I think a lot of, you know, that's where a lot of the French parties end up making their gains. You see that actually with the National Front, with the Rassemblement National now, sorry.
19:51Anyways, so I don't think that's a sadly a uniquely kind of Farage or British issue. And then, I mean, I don't know, again, I think it slightly comes back to what I mentioned earlier, which is that the politics of the EU at the moment are very unequal and complicated and messy. And every election seems to be the kind of, what was it that that mean that does the run on loose code, the 50-50 between puppies for everyone or diarrhea forever. And it really sticks in your head as a, yeah, so the vote is always like 50.50 or 49.5. So it's not, again, I don't think Britain is unique in maybe doing stuff. You know, France at the moment, again, not to come back to my people again, but as things stand, it looks like we're going to have a second round
20:34next year of an election between two parties who have incredibly unreasonable demands on what, you know, on France's relationship with the EU. So I don't, from what I've seen, Brussels actually seems to be like, why not? I don't think there's been any great... There was certainly a lot of frustration. You'll have heard that as well at the time, I think, during the kind of Brexit negotiations. I think there was no love lost, I think, for some time. Whereas now, I think people do seem to maybe, I don't know, cautiously, obviously, but welcome the idea of Britain rejoining. And I think it also massively helps politically the EU as a project, because it kind of is like, look, you know, the only guys who actually fucked off came crawling back, not even 10 years later,
21:16because of how miserable it was to be outside the club. I think if you're looking at lots of countries, or not lots, at least some countries kind of thinking whether to maybe leave or not, or start toying with it as an idea, very useful to be able to point to Britain and say, well, look what happened. Jason, what do you think of the way Burnham is playing this? For so long, it was utterly taboo for the Labour leadership to question Brexit. Yet at the moment, it is all talk and a cynical part of me wonders if it's a way to keep people like us distracted and on side with the Burnham project. Ross, you old cynic. I know. Sorry. No, I don't think it's, I'm not that cynical about it. I think Burnham's playing this pretty well.
21:52The thing is that he's opened the door, which is the first step to actually talking about this. Now, Starmer couldn't find the key. So it's delightful that we're in there now. I think a lot of what happens now depends on two things. One is whether, and I don't think this is likely, but I know plenty of people do, Burnham calls an early general election, say in May next year, which is a date I've heard knocked around. I don't think it's going to happen. Rachel Cunliffe does, for instance. John Elledge does. John Elledge does, yeah. The other thing I think it might depend on is what happens to the red lines. And this is effectively the same issue as whether there's an early election. It's a bit like, what do we do about the manifesto promises in the
22:32rearview mirror? Because Chris Ward, who's the MP for Brighton, Kemptown and Peacehaven, who helped write those red lines for Labour post-2020, was in the press at the weekend saying they need to be given a dignified retirement which sounds like the kind of thing you do to a racehorse um because he says they were designed those red lines to shut down the brexit debate because it becomes such a big target for labor and we don't need that now um he also says the main reason is not economic now but it always was but the main reason now is like strategic reason we need to get rid of these red lines because we need not just a trade partnership, but we need a defence partnership with the EU. Now, if Burnham can get the argument as far as that point
23:14that Chris Ward has got to, I think we're away. But the other thing is, and this is just a footnote, I think everyone needs to get rid of the word Brexit when it comes to this argument. Just forget it. Make that yesterday's issue and just talk about joining the EU. Don't use that word anymore because it will just dial up all those toxic feelings from the referendum. Seth, Burnham is going to the European Political Community Meeting in Dublin this week, and then there's a bilateral with the EU on 20th of November. What are you hoping to see him do there? Yeah, I mean, this is going to be an interesting thing because this week is going to be the summit of Ireland's six-month EU presidency. And we're sort of expecting to see deals on youth mobility, on agri-food, on emissions trading.
23:55But I would like to see something a bit more ambitious around the EU more generally. And what I'm thinking of is a real vicious cycle we found ourselves in around Canada because every few months Ursula von der Leyen puts out some very positive feelers saying we are very open in principle to the idea of Canada having something like associate membership of the EU. yes, please. And then it's usually the same countries. It's usually Germany, France, and Greece that say, veto, no, no, that's not going to happen. And they've most recently sort of watered it down to ever closer relationship. Well, let's actually look at this ever closer relationship. I think this could be really, really exciting. Let's look at some sort of
24:37special status for Canada within the EU family, certainly on trade and certainly on defence. If you think about how much the last few years have shown the US to be an unreliable ally and has left a gaping hole in that sense, Canada has been a very, very reliable ally for us. Helps that also they're a bilingual power with two of the most widely spoken languages in the EU. It helps that strategically they occupy one of the crucial positions in the world around the Arctic Circle. And if you're looking at defense agreements, Canada is really a good place to be making friends with. It's not actually population-wise even that big a country that would skew the population of the EU. It's two-thirds the size of Britain and France.
25:16It's half the size of Germany. So it would be great, but it wouldn't necessarily completely transform the nature of the EU. And I think that's a conversation we should really revisit because it would open up questions of what kind of thing is the EU about? Does it go broader? Are we open to democracies like Georgia, for example, who've made no secret of their EU aspirations, becoming members and expanding in other ways? What is the one mistake that Remain made in 2016 that we must not do again? Jason, you already mentioned it. Yes, I can do this in three words. David fucking Cameron. Okay, so yeah, presumably we just tell him to not get involved. Yeah, Rose, I think just like I completely agree.
25:56I think really it should have been all George Osborne all the time. Like it just didn't spend enough time, I think. God, I couldn't even get to the end of that sentence with a straight face. I'm not surprised. No, I was going to say, I think my serious one is, I think, and I remember I found it so frustrating at the time, but never really doing anything on the emotional side of things. I found mad. I think you can't just make the case about the economy. That doesn't work. That's not how this works. You're not just talking about, oh, well, you know, line goes up when EU and line goes down when no EU. Clearly, that does not work. You have to actually appeal to people with sentiment, with emotions, with feelings.
26:31And I hope a rejoined campaign would get that. I would guess that Andy Burnham gets that instinctively. He does feel like someone who's maybe a bit more tuned into his mental health than other male politicians. I mean, I'm partly saying as a joke, but also partially entirely seriously. So, yeah, I would say a joke, but also partially entirely seriously. So, yeah, I would say a bit, you know, obviously lots of factual stuff, but you need to do more than that, I think, to capture hearts and minds. We used to be a lot better at that. There's some really interesting nerd alert advertising, election advertising from early European parliamentary elections and indeed the 75 referendum, which is much more emotional.
27:06Yeah, you can look it up if you on the LSE website, something I did a while ago. But yeah, it's fascinating. Sorry. Yeah, no, I was I was thinking that that emotional thing we know you're right. We never heard it over here. But like if you go last time I was in Paris, which was I think last year, there were some posters up on them on the metro, which were just they were just saying how great Europe is and what it's done for you and it's like we could have done with that you know we could have done with quite a lot of that that actually plugged into the emotional bit of it like you know these are your friends for instance just saying something like that and there is absolutely right that actually much of the campaign was made up of people who were secretly europhile but thought
27:41the way to win this was to say well on balance I mean I'm not very keen on this whole European thing and on bureaucracy and on taxes and on lack of accountability and they would list all of the key themes of the Leave campaign and then at the end of it say but on balance I think I'll probably, that's the worst possible way to persuade anyone of anything. On balance think of the FTSE 100 and it's just like. But even then I wonder if like with business should have been more involved because so little in terms of business leaders spoke up at the referendum. They just wanted to remain neutral, which seems like a stupid idea to me because we know that it's cost us between 4% and 6% of our GDP. These people should have been saying, don't do this.
28:19It's going to get worse for you. We're going to put our prices up. Stuart Rose briefly got involved and it was a disaster. There was this disastrous press conference involving Stuart Rose. I've got to put our prices up. Stuart Rose briefly got involved and it was a disaster. There was this disastrous press conference involving Stuart Rose. I've got a vague memory of that in the manner of PTSD and things like that. But I think it's also the last thing which I nearly tried to do actually in 2016 but I was 24 and no one so it went nowhere. But I was a bit like there are a lot of Europeans here. Surely we can be showcased, we can be relied on to help. You know, at the time, I felt very strongly
28:47that it was in all of our interests to stay in the EU. I maintain that now. So, yeah, I think also kind of doing something, both saying, again, these are your friends, your neighbours, your colleagues, etc. But also, use us. We think it's good to be in the EU because we're Europeans who moved because of the EU. So, yeah, use us. There was also the tactical point about, you know about this being a really badly run campaign and without getting into individual personalities and how utterly inept they were at campaigning. I remember thinking at the start, you've already lost the Overton window because you've conceded so much ground. But even then, the point at which it hit me several weeks out, this is going to be
29:23lost, was a briefing around the Remain campaign and it was very much saying, right, so we're focusing all of our efforts, all of our strategy, all of our resources at the four key regions, which are London, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. And there I am with my jaw on the ground thinking that's 27% of the population. You are literally admitting that you're not bothering campaigning in 73% of the country. And this rolled over even on election night, where people were in denial. They were way behind at the sort of mid-election night point. And they say, you wait till London gets, you wait till London borough of Lambeth with, well, that's only less than a couple of hundred thousand people.
29:59That's not going to decide 17 and a half million votes or overcome that. So what you need to do is actually be much, much more aggressive and much more realistic in saying, OK, where else? I mean, they actually misjudged Wales hugely. It didn't occur to them that it was really leave central. On the other hand, they were astonished that the southeast, well, they thought, well, Farage is an MEP there, so we won't bother. Well, no, actually, the southeast was really competitive and really close. In fact, it was a remain area. The southwest was lost, but not by much. People said, oh, well, fishermen will mean the southwest. No, actually, I think fishermen now are furious enough that they'll help carry it over to remain quite firmly.
30:39The northeast and the northwest were completely abandoned. Both of them should have been really fertile ground for remainers. They just didn't bother. So, you know, at that stage, we're actually looking at most of the map being coloured in. Where am I saying don't bother? You're not going to win in the Midlands, East or West. You're not going to win in the East of England, even though you might get pockets of support there. But you can probably win, barring that and Wales, pretty much everywhere else. Hmm. for flights, but one that's right. And cars and hotels too. And cars and hotels too. Search holiday travel with Kayak. Got that right. As AI infrastructure scales, deployment time shouldn't. At SC26 in Chicago,
31:41Gigabyte is showing their latest innovations, including a modular data center design that drastically cuts deployment time. And also on display, rack-scale NVIDIA-based solutions built to succeed in the era of agentic AI. From a single server to an entire AI factory, Gigabyte has you covered. Visit us at booth 2229 at SC26, November 17th to 19th. We can't wait to see you there. I'm Lorraine Kelly, and I'm the new host of Experience Is Everything, the podcast where I get the chance to sit down with some of Britain's best-loved national treasures for an in-depth chat about their lives, from their childhood to their big breaks, from their successes to their failures breaks from their successes to their
32:25failures we find out the real life stories behind some of the most recognizable names in tv film radio and the stage search for experience is everything on youtube or wherever you get your podcasts that's experience is everything with me lorraine ke, on YouTube or on all podcast platforms. Brought to you by Saga. But that's not the only thing happening in the world right now. And so we're going to round them up in a section called Yes, but what about? Jason, first the Russell Brand sentencing, now the allegations about David Walliams. The Guardian and ITN have reported that the children's author and comedian is alleged to have groomed fans as young as 15 and to have harassed women for sex in the workplace.
33:17He denies any wrongdoing and is not facing criminal charges. The Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy has summoned TV bosses to discuss the case. Is this likely to make a difference? I'm afraid to say I don't know what difference this can make, let alone what it will make. I should say, first of all, by the way, because it would be really disingenuous of me not to, I have written for David Walliams. So I need to say that out loud, I think, in case anybody says, oh, you didn't mention that. And these are some horrible accounts to read. I didn't. It was a horrible thing to read. So, look, Lisa Nandy getting involved. What I don't understand there is how does the conversation go? What does she say to Priya Dogra, the CEO of Channel 4?
33:58And what does Priya Dogra say back to Lisa Nandy? I sort of think this might be kind of duty of care theater I don't know whether they can get anywhere here because this isn't a political thing and it's not even a managerial thing it's a it's a it's a cultural thing it's an and it needs to be tackled tackled at the cultural level um now I saw that there were some people there was talk of like if you were around Russell Brand if you were like a female runner, you were told to take another person into the room with you. And I heard various people saying, well, this is disgraceful. If you know that, why are you allowing people to go into those rooms? And it's like, sometimes that's the best somebody can do. Because the problem is with someone like Brand, or really anybody who's big,
34:43like the talent, if the talent is the problem who do you speak to now the answer could be the ceo of channel four for instance but that would be requiring to know who the problem is now and then doing something about them now otherwise very often you you as someone on the production you have to work out well who is it i speak to because the most important person on this production is the talent and if if they're the problem, I've got to go quite high up. And if I'm a runner and I'm saying I'd like to go and talk to someone who is above the talent in Channel 4, you're probably not going to get that audience. So it's a tough one, but it needs to be tackled from within. And I'm not sure whether you can do it sort of from the outside as as the culture secretary.
35:22And I think briefly on that, I've not experienced this in the entertainment sector, but I've certainly had a lot of this in politics of, you know, the MPs where other journalists or other women will say, yeah, I wouldn't go for a drink with him or, you know, don't get in a cab with him, etc. The problem is also, you know, quite often the version of the story you get is not, you know, because, you know, last year on this date, he assaulted this woman. Here's her full name. Here are her contact details. If you want to double check with her. These are stories you hear. And, you know, I'm not saying you're not trusting them, but, you know, there's not much you can do. I think if it's a story you've heard second or third hand, you can't really go up to anyone really.
35:57When you're talking about, you know, either someone who's very famous or a minister of state or something to go, well, I've heard credible stories, but I don't really have the names. And also, I don't even really know if the victims would want to be named, etc. It's also I think, the problem is, it's really hard to report something when it's not happened to you. So yes, as you said, again, I completely agree. Sometimes, the best you can do is the best you can do, which can just be like, yeah, just I would avoid X or Y. And we are dealing with the breaking of the taboo at this stage. But I think it's two very different stages with both of them. Because in the case of Russell Brand, one of those processes has played out. He is now a convicted rapist. We can say that openly. Whatever we might have thought previously, we haven't been able to say hours ago, barely over that. I suspect, you know, in both cases,
36:46what has transpired is going to encourage people to come forward. I think the David Walliams story has a long way more to run, and we may find out a lot more. While we're on the topic, we have a very pertinent But Your Email's question from a listener this week, and it's from Keith Braithwaite. He says, brand in the way that the Guardian did? Which serious thinkers and high-profile commentators on the right lauded him the way that George Monbiot and Owen Jones did in the Guardian? Isn't there an asymmetry between Brand's treatment by right and left, in that one, his support from the left was greater in volume, enthusiasm and weightiness, and two, the conservative right don't take strong moral positions anyway, but the progressive left often emphasise their own virtue and probity. I suppose I can speak to this a little bit because I was in situ at the Guardian
37:51working on the comment desk in 2008 during the time when my bookie book was published and there was a large amount of love for Russell Brand. And I was pretty junior. I mean, I was a deputy editor, but in the scheme of things, I was not what was known as top 50 at the time. And so I observed this and I remember thinking, this guy talks a load of poor shit. I can see what he's doing. At the time, I had no views or anything on his or there were no rumors that I knew of circulating about his sexual conduct. So if that wasn't, I mean, I was more, but clearly he was a grifter. If you ask why the Guardian bought that line so enthusiastically, it's because he represented someone young, at the time sexy, someone who was from, you know, he was always talking about how he came from Essex and he was, you know, he talked about how he hung out with'm a real man, me. I know what real life's like.
39:07You guys are just, you know, tossers who talk about stuff you don't understand. I've seen how bad it, you know, I've seen, I've been a drug addict, I've been, et cetera, et cetera. There's also the power that he had, which I think is the main reason why he was able to get away with it for so long, is because he was able to make women who didn't like him feel that if they objected, they were being a bit uptight, a bit snobby, a bit, you know, humorless. That was very much his gift at the time. It was really something that cut through. And I remember thinking that and I think I could, you know, I could bring this up, but it makes me look like a poshh humorless Guardian journalist, doesn't it?
39:48So I'm just going to keep quiet. And yeah, I regret doing that. But if you want to know why that happened at the time and why he was so much admired, I think that is a big part of it. Well, Keith asks which mainstream conservative paper accommodated and celebrated brand in the same way that the Guardian did and I will answer his question. The answer is The Sun. The Sun named Russell Brand Shagger of the Year three years in a row and in the third year they renamed the award after him. They celebrated him on his terms in the same way that the Guardian celebrated him on his terms except the Guardian looked at his, in inverted commas, politics, and the Sun just went for his kind of Lothario lifestyle,
40:29which we now know to be actually a lot more toxic than that. And I mean, I would disagree with quite a few of the assumptions in Keith's question, because I don't think you can entirely liken this thing of left versus right. Now, I have been quite uncomfortable about these things of, oh, he was such a hero on the left, or he was such a hero on the right. There's no denying the Guardian absolutely lauded him for a while, ditto the new statesman. But he then went and made a serious sort of recalibration of himself on the alt-right. Well, which paper on the right? I would say which platform on the right? You know, he's big on Rumble. He's big on Twitter. He's got all this online following, which he has monetized. Why did he shift from the left to the right? Well, I think the left gave him more fame and the right gave him
41:09more money. And whichever way he goes, this is somebody who was a comedian and a grifter in plain sight in that way. But I don't think it's answering very much to say, well, it was a left thing or a right wing thing. He gave people what they wanted to hear. You know, something we were discussing beforehand was this idea of people saying that they never liked him. I'm afraid I never liked him in the first place. I just didn't find him funny. I thought there was a sort of cruelty in his humour that was an essential component. You know, you see it in the whole Andrew Zak's answer phone message. It's just shitty and unpleasant to do that to anyone. I don't know. I think on that specific topic, and I actually quite like the premise of the question, I'm afraid.
41:49But I do think there is quite a specific left-wing progressive social media-y thing about, you know, whenever someone who, you know, someone who is famous, previously thought to be good or whatever, gets found out to be a wrong-un, to have done problematic things, have done bad things, you will just get this tidal wave of, I'm sorry to be a wrong-un, to have done problematic things, have done bad things, you will just get this tidal wave of, I'm sorry, boys, usually men going, well, I never liked him. I never thought I always, you know, and it does. It really, really is a thing that I think is quite left, has become quite left-coded certainly over time of everyone going, well, no, not me, not I, certainly not I. And I get, and to be clear, I'm not criticising any specific individuals
42:24doing it because I totally get criticizing any specific individuals doing it because I totally get the individual impulse to do it. But I think when you see it happen, there's a bit of a like, okay, well, great, do you all want a medal? And also, how can we really discuss? For example, Russell Brand, you know, again, on the left, like who does it actually really help for everyone to say, well, I never, you know, I never liked him. I never, and it's okay, but he was still very popular among our circles, among our people, among the newspapers we read, although probably not quite the podcast we listen to. But yes, I think when the context is trying to understand why something happened, I just think, yeah, it's just a bit unhelpful to go,
43:01I'm personally not the problem. Well, I will come back on that because I think there is actually value in saying that, which is it comes out of the Jimmy Savile experience. Because the thing he used to say constantly to his victims was, no one will believe you against King Jimmy. I'm too big. I'm too important. Everyone would believe me over you. And actually, I think it helps genuinely in this current context to say, abandon the group think it wasn't always the case that everybody was saying this guy was God's gift. Actually, there were lots of perfectly sensible people who were just not really taken in and not, you know, didn't think that much of it. I was neutral on the question. I feel like I remember finding him somewhat funny on the big fat quiz of the year when
43:40I think I was 19. And that I think that was the only time I found him vaguely funny. But the same, but are we grading ourselves on how on the right side of history? I wouldn't take it to the extent that you should suddenly punish people for having found him funny. I like Wagner opera. The man was utterly reprehensible in his views. That doesn't mean that everybody who likes his music is guilty by association. So yeah, there's that element. I didn't find him him particularly funny i saw him do one stand-up routine twice and it made me think that he only had one stand-up routine it was only 10 minutes as well and it was quite old um but i wonder whether for some people marie to your point the i didn't find him funny is
44:22basically them trying to say he made me feel fucking awkward because he I never met him so I didn't have the chance to be made to feel personally awkward by Russell Brand but what I did think to him increasingly over time is especially as his inverted commas political views wandered all over the place everything here is a performance everything here is a front there's just noise And when someone is just broadcasting noise like that, eventually you have to say, what's behind this noise? Because you clearly don't want me to hear something that's behind this noise, do you? And it turns out in his case, it was something absolutely reprehensible. Seth, the King was in the Caribbean last week, schmoozing at the Commonwealth Heads of Government meeting,
45:10which I'm happy to call Shogham. The same to you. Can we do the French? Shoghoff. Shogham. Eel. I don't even know why, but eel. Andy Burnham went along too. What did we learn about the state of Britain's relationship with our ex-colonies? Well, it was very enlightening. I mean, I tend to think of these things as being a complete waste of time and space. They're held every couple of years. It's a big international junket, usually more often than not in quite nice resort towns around the world. And just on a side note, but I'm fascinated by this odd group of billionaires who seem to have seen them as the ultimate in high-status selfie tourism. Because if you offer a free flight to one of the Chogham delegates, then you can have unlimited selfie opportunities with all
45:56the sort of international statesmen who attend. And that's the most it seems to achieve. I mean, other than that, they all get around a happy-clappy circle and agree that doing something about climate change someday would be awfully nice. But this sort of strikes at the very identity of the Commonwealth itself, because they had a big turning point about five years ago, where they were pre-empting the death of the previous queen, saying, you know, when her time comes, we want to make it very clear that because the crown is not officially,ded in as the head, when Charles' time comes, he will still be head. And we sort of interpreted that as a show of unity around the whole Commonwealth that they were really, really keen on the thing.
46:34So it turned out that when the king had all his bilateral visits with various heads of government, they all said, actually, can we abandon this whole monarchy thing? It's a bit silly and it makes us look silly. And particularly because he'd spent most of the week as king making speeches about how he frightfully regretted slavery and how it was terribly a real shame. And this wasn't a formal apology. He couldn't make a formal apology, but he could say that he very much empathized with all their suffering. He wasn't in any position other than to say, right, OK, yeah, whatever you want. Sure. So we've got this sort of very embarrassing non-meeting, which may become even more of a meeting in the future.
47:14Marie, Kemi Badenoch has plans to cut the benefits bill. It's notoriously tricky to do that, but that won't stop Kemi. How's she going to do it? Oh, God. Well, so apparently the Conservatives are going to save the taxpayer 36 billion a year from the welfare budget, which feels slightly eye-watering, you may be thinking, but that's fine because the plans will definitely work and have definitely been thought through very well. No, it's puzzling. So the speech itself, so she said, so she was talking about the fact that, you know, I think different disabled people, for example, have different abilities. And she said, double amputees run marathons, people with autism run some of the biggest tech companies in the world. And they're like,
47:53yeah, but these are not, which was such a weird understanding, I think, of disability. And again, I think a double amputee still presumably needs help with the fact that, you know, they do not have legs, there will be that accessibility issues, there will be, you know, they'll need prosthetics, et cetera. And I think, and again, autism, and I'll come back to that in a moment, but is very much, I mean, I think spectrum, I don't know, we're still discussing, I think, the vocabulary at the moment. But, you know, there's a sense that not everyone with autism is going to be the same. But, no, so if you look, yeah, if you dig into it, so I think there's, they're going to save apparently 2.8 billion a year
48:23by ending the disability living allowance payments to families of children with milder cases of behavioral disorders, learning difficulties or ADHD. By which I mean, apparently, they're only going to still send the money to 30% of the most severe cases, which is something I have a number of questions on. Because, A, how do you define more severe? For example, in the case of ADHD, that's a really tough one. And especially in the case of childhood, things will go up and down and change, I think, from year to year. Also, will it not cost an absolute ton of money to presumably assess everyone to the extent that you have to pick those 30%? There's also going to be 13.7 billion, which will be saved from changes to sickness and disability benefits,
49:03including restricting payments to claimants with milder mental health issues and neurodiversity conditions such as anxiety, depression and ADHD. And again, I'm a bit like, you know, people with anxiety, depression, ADHD, like a lot of those probably will not magically become considerably more, you know, productive if you stop them from trying to, again, live a life that works better for them also depression kills people it really does the number one killer of men under 50 is suicide and it but it's also again i i really have a problem with the kind of like severe not severe thing because a because again it can yo-yo quite fucking famously i have a lot of friends had my own dealings with anxiety and it's not not a case of, oh, yes, I have four out of 10 anxiety.
49:47And that's really, really not how it works. And then the rest. Oh, yes. So there's 3.1 billion, which they'll regain from reintroducing the two child benefit cap, which it was just so unpopular. I found that completely baffling. This idea of, again, doing a policy cam cam like this as well, of being like, oh, the bad thing, you know, that Labour removed. Actually, the Grinch party is here to put it back again. And then a bunch of other things. But yes, it was kind of weird. I think the reception in Westminster was definitely like, oh, a big policy speech by Kemi Badenoch, who shows that, you know, she's back on track. But I don't know, I thought the ideas all sounded either quite mad or quite cruel or quite useless or like a funky mix of all three.
50:28If Camille Bajenoch were to apply for jobs while declaring that she has a disability, she might find the results more surprising than she expects. I'm Lorraine Kelly and I'm the new host of Experience Is Everything, the podcast where I get the chance to sit down with some of Britain's best-loved national treasures for an in-depth chat about their lives, from their childhood to their big breaks, from their successes to their failures. We find out the real-life stories behind some of the most recognisable names in TV, film, radio and the stage. Search for Experience Is Everything on YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts. That's Experience Is Everything with me, Lorraine Kelly, on YouTube or on all podcast platforms. Brought to you by Saga.
51:32That brings us to the end of the show, which means the traditional finale, Escape Roots, where our panel and guests reveal the books, films, TV, music or any other business that is helping them get through the tempest of politics this week. Marie. I went to the cinema to watch La Bola Negra, which is a Spanish queer historical epic. I mean, I wouldn't say I loved it. I think quite a lot of my friends have talked about it, the movie of the decade. I would say I really enjoyed it. It's probably where I put myself. So I wouldn't say it completely blew me away. But it is very good. And it's kind of this movie across that spans across the 20th century and 21st. And it's sort of about being gay in Spain today, but also a lot of it is about being gay during
52:13the Spanish Civil War, and kind of, you know, the legacies of that. And then there's a lot of kind of, you know, yearning, and it's actually quite sad, but it's really beautiful. The music, I will say is very, very good. But yes, I would recommend recommend it it is two hours and 40 minutes um but the best compliment i can give is that that was fine which is quite rare for me for a movie that long so yeah la bola negra would recommend looking forward to seeing that seth what about you um i had a purchase in a secondhand bookshop which was very exciting it's um it's a compendium of tallis's lond London street views of 1838 to 1840. These are great. So a guy called John Tallis, who he was putting a sort of a bit of an Elon Musk and putting his name all over it, though he didn't actually draw anything.
52:55He just owned the company that did this. He did line drawings of every single London street and the buildings all along it on both sides. And there are 88 sheets of these. And it's just really fascinating. It's a much lower rise city at the time, you know, two, three stories at most. And you'll very often find that there are one or two buildings we still recognize today, and the rest of the city is completely unrecognizable. It's like a different world. So it's a fascinating window into that. And although secondhand copies can be quite scarce to find, It's entirely free online, so I'll happily share a link in the show notes for the digital version. Please do. I'd love to see that. Jason, how about you?
53:32I have started reading Jonathan Coe's new novel, Lessons in Harmony, which is about the relationship between two composers, Raythorne Williams and Maurice Ravel. It's funny, it's touching, it's beautifully written. And one of the questions it asks is, is there an English music and is there a French music? And there is a point in the book at which there is a concert of both their music, where the narrator of the book says, I felt I was witnessing a fusion of two nations and that this fusion had created something entirely new and beautiful to which the times replied by reviewing the book under the headline please jonathan co stop writing about brexit and if that's not a recommendation for ogman's listeners i don't know
54:17what is absolutely well i read a piece a couple of weeks ago in the ft which was really good by the irish poet paul maldun which was really good by the Irish poet Paul Muldoon, which was basically saying Northern Ireland needs to get to grips with its past and we pretend we do, but we don't. And it was part of an introduction to a new edition of Patrick Radden Keefe's book, Say Nothing, a true story of murder and memory in Northern Ireland, which is all about, it follows the stories of various people through the troubles and what they experienced and what they suffered. And I hadn't read it before. It's really good. I highly recommend it. Everything by Patrick Reddenkeith is good. He's brilliant,
54:54isn't he? Yeah, but this is really exceptional. And that's the end of the show. Marie, thank you very much. Thank you. Seth. Thank you. And Jason. Thank you. Listeners, thanks for joining us. We can only make Oh God, What Now? because of your generosity. It pays for our team, including all the producers and back office, and it funded our studios. On Patreon, you can support the projects you love with a regular donation. It can be as little as three pounds a month for at least eight podcasts plus specials. Patreon backers get every episode early and ad free, plus extended episodes and merch and a shout out on the podcast. Most importantly, you'll get the satisfaction of supporting independent podcasting.
55:36Follow the link in the show notes to find out more. We'll be back on Tuesday. See you then. but The Edge, that guy from U2 for younger listeners, stop sniggering, Jason, wrote a sequel to the Elf movie, but it petered out and never got made. Sadly, it doesn't divulge what happened to the eponymous Santa helper, but if The Edge wants to come on Ogwen and tell us, we're definitely up for that. There are lots of sequels out there. Too many, some might say. But which sequels would the panel like to see? What are the ones that got away personally I'm looking forward to Top Gun 3 2036 where Tom Cruise flees the care home in a Cessna I feel the need the need for what was it again Jason unlike the rest of us
56:39you have actually helped write a sequel Paddington 2 and the original too I can't believe you genuinely worked on one of the best movies ever made. Yes. That's amazing. That's pretty cool. So I helped rewrite it, not write it. When I came on board it had already... It was just fucking shit. No, it was great. Yeah, we got rid of some of the more violent scenes. It had been already written by Simon Farnaby and Paul King but they brought in some people they called the brains trust just to have a look at it and thrash out any bits that had lumps still under the carpet you know sequels then I mean the Wicker Man had a sequel didn't it which I've not been brave enough to look at because like the original
57:20film just doesn't need anything either side of it frankly that's not Wicker is it that's something else no that's not Wicker no that's a different one that's the one that's no that's olivia coleman falling in love with a basket um so no the italian job was there was a sequel mooted to the italian job at one point if you know the ending of the italian job the coach is hanging over the edge of the cliff and the gold is sliding slowly out of the back of it and michael cain is lying prone on all fours and saying hang on lads i've got an idea well there was a sequel planned in which the idea was that he drove a screwdriver into the diesel tank and emptied all the diesel out of the bus thus writing it and they could get away with the gold now that's a great idea but it is it's scene
58:03one of a film and you need another 90 minutes. That was a teaser for the bonus extra bit of this week's podcast. If you'd like to hear the whole thing every week, plus get every episode without ads and a day early, then sign up to back us on Patreon for as little as £3 a month. You'll also get access to live Zooms, our exclusive merchandise, and most importantly, the warm glow of supporting independent podcasting. Thanks for listening. We'll see you next week. the world kayak compares deal let's save a dough on your trip and what a trip it is find options for flights book one that's right and cars and hotels too and cars and hotels too. Search holiday travel with Kayak. Got that right. Build your front end and back end together on Base44.
59:12Describe the product logic with a managed database, authentication, and hosting included. Spend less time assembling infrastructure and more time getting your product live. Go to base44.com.





