podcasts / Motley Fool Hidden Gems Investing / episode
Motley Fool Hidden Gems Investing cover art
podcast
📅 2026-11-14 ⏱ 42 min episode · ~2 min read 📝 Transcript · 7,416 words 🎙 Robin Wigglesworth

Robin Wigglesworth: Motley Fool Hidden Gems Investing transcript

Motley Fool Hidden Gems Investing · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe

A bond-market historian shows how Venetian war loans, Dutch finance and Hamilton's Treasury shaped the world, and why debt can be a blessing that also becomes a danger.

Read the transcript
In this episodeRobin WigglesworthIan FlemingVeniceAlexander HamiltonThomas Babington MacaulayNeil FergusonPhilip IIJ. Cooke & Co.Reserve Primary FundVanguardLehman BrothersBear Stearns

▸Chapters

Tap a chapter to play it from that moment in the show's own player; the transcript opens there too.

Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →

▸Notable quotes

“We don't borrow money from Mars or Venus. We borrow money from ourselves.” Robin Wigglesworth · at 9:17 — ▶ hear it from here
“the optimal number of financial crisis is not zero” Robin Wigglesworth · at 23:27 — ▶ hear it from here

▸What this episode covers

Robin Wigglesworth, editor of the Financial Times' Alphaville blog and author of A Fabulous Debt, argues that bonds have shaped much of modern history. He begins with 12th-century Venice, a city of refugees with no farmland or natural resources. When the city needed more money for a war than local moneylenders could supply, it forced wealthy residents to make a loan at 5% a year and made the receipts tradable. The Dutch later turned the idea into a true bond market, funding dikes, towns and the Dutch East India Company while fighting Spain at about 3% a year.

A recurring theme is the debate over debt itself. Wigglesworth argues that critics confuse household debt with government debt, and he treats a national debt as a potential blessing when it lubricates trade. Alexander Hamilton applied that logic to a bankrupt young America, exchanging defaulted state war debts for federal Treasury bonds that made the country creditworthy and gave creditors a stake in its survival. Railway bonds later financed the expansion across America, and when a 1873 crash in Germany and Austria forced European sales, the collapse of J. Cooke & Co. set off a long depression.

The later sections move to recent finance: the early money market fund built to get around interest-rate caps, and how the Reserve Primary Fund broke the buck in 2008 after buying risky commercial paper. Wigglesworth's verdict on America is measured. Its debt is manageable because its economy is large and its currency is unique, but interest now costs more than defense, a pattern Ferguson's Law flags as a warning sign, and political fixes look hard. He points to the Social Security trust funds as an early test of whether Washington can agree on anything.

▸Robin Wigglesworth on Motley Fool Hidden Gems Investing: the answers

Who is Robin Wigglesworth?

Robin Wigglesworth

Robin Wigglesworth is the editor of the Financial Times finance blog Alphaville and the author of A Fabulous Debt, the book about how bonds shaped history.

What did Robin Wigglesworth say about national debt?

Robin Wigglesworth argues that a government is not a household, so debt is not borrowed from outside the country. He says that because governments borrow from their own citizens, a national debt can be a national blessing, used as collateral and to lubricate trade.

“We don't borrow money from Mars or Venus. We borrow money from ourselves.”Robin Wigglesworth · 9:17

What did Robin Wigglesworth say about Alexander Hamilton?

Robin Wigglesworth calls Alexander Hamilton an incandescent genius who, as the first Treasury Secretary, saw that the states' war debts could solve two problems at once. Wigglesworth says Hamilton's plan restored American credit and used federal bonds to bind the young country together.

“I think his genius was realizing that this problem actually could solve two problems”Robin Wigglesworth · 12:17

What did Robin Wigglesworth say about Dutch East India Company?

Robin Wigglesworth says the Dutch East India Company was the first listed public company and also issued the first corporate bonds. He says it sold shares only once, while its ships, colonies and soldiers were financed through bond sales.

“the Dutch East India Company also issued the first corporate bonds.”Robin Wigglesworth · 6:49

What did Robin Wigglesworth say about railroad bonds?

Robin Wigglesworth says American railroads were financed mostly by debt, because the banking system had no Federal Reserve and was made up of small state banks that collapsed easily. Foreign investors, including Dutch, British and German buyers, bought American railway bonds in large amounts.

“But the vast majority of the financing came from the bond market.”Robin Wigglesworth · 20:26

What did Robin Wigglesworth say about Reserve Primary Fund?

Robin Wigglesworth says the Reserve Primary Fund, one of the oldest money market funds, was conservative for years until it began buying commercial paper and was exposed to Bear Stearns. He says it broke the buck after Lehman Brothers collapsed in September 2008, and he was dismayed as he researched the story.

“I was almost shouting to myself, please don't do it, don't do it.”Robin Wigglesworth · 29:11

What is Robin Wigglesworth's main argument on Motley Fool Hidden Gems?

Robin Wigglesworth argues that bonds have been one of the most valuable financial technologies in history, because credit lets countries and cities bind themselves together and fund growth. He says national debt is not automatically a danger, but America's rising interest costs, which now exceed its defense spending, deserve attention.

Mentioned in this episode

Episode facts

Released
November 14, 2026
Length
42 minutes

▸Key takeaways

01Venice borrowed from its citizens at 5% a year in the 12th century, and making those war loans tradable turned debt into an asset.
02The Dutch financed dikes, cities and the Dutch East India Company with bonds, funding their war for independence from Spain at about 3% a year.
03Alexander Hamilton, the first Treasury Secretary, exchanged defaulted state war debts for fresh federal Treasury bonds to bind the young United States together.
04A 1873 German and Austrian crash forced European sales of American railway bonds, and J. Cooke & Co.'s collapse began a long depression.
05Robin Wigglesworth says America broke Ferguson's Law in 2024, spending more on interest than defense, though he is not that worried about its debt.

▸Questions this episode answers

Q1What did Robin Wigglesworth say about Venice and the first bond market?

Robin Wigglesworth says Venice created the first modern bond market in the 12th century. Facing a costly war with Constantinople and no way to borrow enough from local moneylenders, the city forced wealthy residents to make a loan paying 5% a year and made the receipts tradable. Venice lost the war and the loan became permanent, but Venetian paper was widely accepted because the city was good for its debts.

Q2How did the Dutch use bonds to fund independence from Spain according to Robin Wigglesworth?

Robin Wigglesworth says the Dutch built the first real bond market, with many issuers from provinces and towns to the Dutch East India Company. Bonds let them borrow at about 3% a year to fund their war for independence from Spain, while the Spanish crown kept defaulting. The Dutch East India Company sold shares only once, but its ships, colonies and soldiers were financed by bond sales.

Q3What did Robin Wigglesworth say about Alexander Hamilton's debt plan?

Robin Wigglesworth says Alexander Hamilton, the first Treasury Secretary, proposed that the federal government take on the states' war debts, which included continental currency and bonds sold to investors in America, France and the Netherlands. Hamilton framed repayment as the price of liberty and a way to restore American credit. Wigglesworth also says the new federal bonds would circulate almost like money in a shattered economy, and that creditors gained a stake in the federal government's survival.

Q4Why did railway bonds lead to a long depression, according to Robin Wigglesworth?

Robin Wigglesworth says American railroads were financed mostly by bonds, because the country had no central bank and its state banks were fragile. When a 1873 financial crisis in Germany and Austria forced European investors to sell American railway bonds, prices collapsed. J. Cooke & Co., the banker who had helped finance the North in the Civil War, failed, and the panic that followed produced what he calls the longest economic downturn in American history.

Q5What happened to the Reserve Primary Fund in 2008, according to Robin Wigglesworth?

Robin Wigglesworth says the Reserve Primary Fund, one of the oldest money market funds, abandoned its conservative rules and began buying commercial paper, including exposure to Bear Stearns. When Lehman Brothers collapsed in September 2008, the fund broke the buck, meaning its net asset value fell below one dollar. Roughly $40 billion in outflows forced it to gate, and Wigglesworth says the government then guaranteed all money market funds to stop a wider collapse.

Q6What is Ferguson's Law and does Robin Wigglesworth think America breaks it?

Robin Wigglesworth explains Ferguson's Law, coined by historian Neil Ferguson, which holds that a great power tends to decline when it spends more on interest payments than on defense. He says America violated the law in 2024 and is still in violation, but he is not very worried, because the US borrows in its own currency and has more capacity to borrow than other countries.

▸Transcript

Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.

0:00Robert Brokamp How bonds built the modern world this week on the personal finance edition of the Motley Fool Hidden Gems Investing Podcast. I'm Robert Brokamp, though I go by the nickname of Bro, and let's face it, many people find Bonds boring. After all, there's a reason Ian Fleming gave his fictional spy the last name of Bond. He called it, quote, the dullest name I've ever heard. However, dig into the history of Bonds and you will find that it is a centuries-long story of wars, empires, innovations, fear, greed, and an interesting cast of characters. Here to talk to us about the intersection of human history and bond history is Robin Wigglesworth, the editor of the Financial Times finance blog, Alphaville, and the author of a fascinating and dare I say, rollicking new book,

0:54A Fabulous Debt, the epic story of how bonds built the modern world. Robin, welcome to the show. Thanks for having me on, bro. I've been looking forward to it. So your book covers many ways that bonds funded big events and developments over the course of history. But I have to say that my first impression after reading particularly the first third or so of the book is that bonds funded a lot of wars or defense, depending on how you look at it. And this includes the very first bond market in Venice. So let's start with that story. Tell us about how bonds got birthed in Italy. Yes. I can't remember which Greek philosopher that first said that war is the mother and father of all invention, but it's certainly true for pretty much everything. But

1:35certainly in the financial realm, war has been brought out the worst and the best in human ingenuity. So Venice, this is the 12th century. Venice is a weird city. Have you been there, bro? I have indeed. It's beautiful. And I was just struck at how, frankly, very focused on mercantilism. And it occurred to me reading your book that that's been that way for centuries. Well, so I visited once when I was anckless student, essentially, and I wish I appreciated the history more because it's a unique city. It was founded by refugees fleeing the vandals, basically some Visigoths, some German barbarians, and they settled where they settled because nobody else wanted it. It was a swampy hellhole. It had zero natural resources, no farmland, no nothing. So they were left to

2:27peace there. And they realized they had to live off their wits. And the Venetians became really the Mediterranean's most brilliant merchants, the traders. And they were well positioned between East and West. So they had no natural resources, but they were very smart. They were very cunning, very driven, very ambitious. And they were perfectly positioned between East and West. So they were technically part of the Byzantine Empire, based in Constantinople, today's Istanbul. But they're also part of Italy, of course, and they owed some fealty to the Pope. But essentially, their only loyalty was to money. They liked making money. And it was one of those rare places where there was lots of social mobility as well.

3:10So there's dozers who rule the town that you literally go within several generations, go from being a slave to being the head of the city. If you were good enough at business, that's really the only thing that mattered. But this really annoyed everybody else in Europe at the time. These were these nouveau riche, uppity merchants. Nobody likes merchants, right? So they ended up in war with Constantinople at one point, their liege, and they needed a ton of money to fight that war. Wars are very expensive. More money than they could just borrow from the local banks. Not really banks in the way that we understand, but local money lenders. They were called banks or banky because of the wooden tables they had.

3:52And they therefore forced everybody in the town to pay a proportional wealth tax, essentially. So they assessed everybody's wealth and made them pay a forcible loan to the government to soften the blow. It was a republic. So to soften the blow, they made it a loan, paid 5% a year, and made the receipts tradable. And that was the crucial bit. Yeah, because loans have been around for centuries before then. It was the tradable part that was important because it then became a financial asset. And you had people with both liabilities and assets that were sort of the key to its success. And it kind of gave a sense of, especially the more affluent people, feeling like they had a stake in what was going on.

4:38Yeah, and this was, dare I say, the magical bit that I hadn't quite appreciated before doing the research on A Fabulousulous debt was how bonds quite literally have bound countries, states, cities, people, the governed and the government together. Venice lost that war against Constantinople. The Doge was murdered by his own citizens on the streets of Venice for his sins. And this loan, this in theory, temporary war loan became a permanent debt. But in fact, that proved a blessing because the Venetians, because they were great merchants, they realized, well, it's really valuable. You can buy an income stream. So Venice couldn't repay the loan, but it could keep paying the 5% from the taxes it raised from its customs duties

5:22and so on. And being able to buy an income stream was hugely powerful. And you could sell that income stream as well. And then, therefore, you could use it as collateral for trade. So it kind of became like money in a world that was always desperately short of something that people accepted as money. So Venetian bonds were broadly accepted around the world because Venice was good for it. And therefore this monument, the failure of the Venetians or this embarrassing war became a monument to their commercial genius really. And it was incredible. And then you saw the other Italian city-states quickly copy this invention and it spread around Europe and took off from there. Will Barron Your book is not only a history of bonds,

6:04but to a certain degree, a history of which countries were more powerful, which countries had empires. There's a bit about Spain and its empire. And one of the subjects of that empire was the Netherlands. But eventually they were to get their independence with the help of bonds. So tell us a little bit about Dutch finance. Yeah. Though the bond, the Prestiti it was called in Italy, spread around Europe. Everybody copied it because people were always keen to borrow. But I think it was really the Dutch that first created what we'd understand to be a bond market in that there were lots of different issuers. So the Dutch first used it to finance the incredibly elaborate system of dikes that they have built

6:49to keep their country dry. Then over the time, cities, provinces, towns, villages would issue more and more bonds and they'd lend to each other. People in Amsterdam would buy Utrecht bonds and vice versa. Ultimately, when they also invented the first listed public company, the Dutch East India Company, the Dutch East India Company also issued the first corporate bonds. So they'd issue bonds to finance their activities. So the Dutch first then financed their war for independence against Spain at the time with bonds, they could fund themselves almost to infinity and beyond at 3% a year. Whilst the Spanish crown, you know, was infamous for defaulting. Philip II defaulted, I think three or four times in his life, which is, I mean,

7:37a world record, which you have to respect. But he's the goated sovereign debt defaulter in history. And because of that, Spain just had to periodically deal with its finances whilst the Dutch could keep on fighting. So they won independence and then they built the global empire actually on the back of bonds. The Dutch East India Company only sold shares once, but its activities, its colonies, its ships, its soldiers were financed by bond sales. And that's why I think the Dutch managed to evolve from what people slightly cruelly, but not inaccurately called the bog of Europe, to be one of the great powers in the world, really. Your book then moves on to other empires, including the British Empire and the consul

8:24market. And I think one of the interesting aspects of the book is that you address how people react to the debt. In fact, the title of the book comes from a book written in 1848 by Thomas Babington Macaulay. I think you labeled them debt scolds and saying that bankruptcy and ruin were at hand, but that didn't happen. And instead, McCauley argued that a bond market could actually be an economic boon, which is why he called it a fabulous debt. So what do the debt scolds get wrong or did they get wrong? Well, actually a lot of the arguments that Thomas Babington McCauley was countering, you can see to this very day. First of all, it's the conflation of household debt with government debt. It's a classic mistake, but a government is not a country.

9:17There are asterisks around it. Every country is different. Every financial system is different, but it is different. We don't borrow money from Mars or Venus. We borrow money from ourselves. And that's why he thought that that obvious, that naked obsession with just the level, the nominal level of the debt is a distraction. What I think Thomas Babington Macaulay also captured so brilliantly is that a national debt can also be a national blessing, to steal the wording of another character in my book, because you can use it as collateral. You can use it to lubricate trade. You can use it to grease commerce. Credit, really credit, as you said, predates everything else in finance. It predates money.

10:02Credit has pretty much always been around with us. And it is the countries that use credit to get commerce flowing that tends to be richer, they tend to be more successful, they tend to be therefore also be more powerful. And Thomas Babington Macaulay saw that the massive debts that Britain had gradually incurred fighting so many wars in Europe Europe because there was always a war actually had not led to the brewing of Britain. In fact, Britain had gotten richer and richer and richer every time. It would occasionally pay down some of those debts and then there'd be a new war and they'd inflate again. But broadly speaking, this actually was an asset to Britain, not a curse. And that's why I still think

10:44to this day that, you know, it wouldn't be human not to worry occasionally about debt levels and how much debt governments today are having could. But I also think it's important to remember the nuances that this is not a household and debt can be a tool. It can be abused, but broadly speaking, it's arguably the most valuable social technology we've invented, certainly the most valuable financial technology we've invented. You mentioned earlier that the bond market could actually bind a society or a country together, which brings us to the start of the United States, which in 1783, the Treaty of Paris was signed. The new country had an awful lot of debt. In comes Alexander Hamilton, the first head of the newly created Treasury Department.

11:35What did he do that set America up for success? Do you notice how I did the foreshadowing there and said, talk about a national blessing? Yeah. I'm quite happy about how I did the foreshadowing there and said, talk about a national blessing? Yeah, quite happy about how I did that. So Alexander Hamilton was, I think, an incandescent genius. I mean, we know he was brilliant, of course, but I think having now read some of his papers, his letters, not just the biographies, but some of the underlying writings, it is incredible how prescient he was. And he had studied the British financial system whilst he was still fighting in the Revolutionary War and had realized that Britain's sea of credit was not a weakness as many other Americans

12:17thought. It was actually a source of Britain's strength. He suggested ways that maybe America would try to weaken it. But when he became the first Treasury Secretary, his first job really was, apart from hiring two assistants and getting one emergency loan from a bank in Philadelphia, was to present a report to Congress about what to do with all the debts that the various states or the colonies until then had incurred in fighting this war. And that was a mix of greenbacks and dollars, basically currency, continental dollars, continentals that they'd issued, and bonds they'd sold both to American investors and to overseas investors, primarily in France and the Netherlands. And I think his genius was realizing that this problem actually could solve two problems

13:11at once. First of all, and he couched this very much in terms of this is the price of liberty. We want to be seen as a serious country, hold our head up aloft among all the other serious countries on the world and serious countries, they our head up and off among all the other serious countries on the world and serious countries, they pay their debts. These were debts we incurred fighting for liberty. We have to pay it. We will restore America's credit worthiness and we will be respected by other countries. That was one of the main public rationales. The two other that were more subtle. One is I think he also realized that credit or these bonds, by taking responsibility for all the state debts, Washington, it wasn't Washington then, but the new federal government

13:56in New York at the time could issue new bonds and those bonds, as long as they were current, would get treated like money. And that was hugely important in a country where the economy was a shambles. I mean, it had been wrecked by the war. It was cut off from its biggest trading partner, Britain, pretty much its only trading partner. And it was a desperate shortage of anything that kind of looked tooked and quacked like money. And these bonds, and there's a great line actually in the musical which mentions this obliquely but uh alexander hamilton raps in the musical this will be a financial enema for the american economy which is quite evocative right uh but very true and that's how it functioned and i think the third

14:36reason is this this binding issue that you you mentioned uh i hadn't found any evidence he studied the venetians, but he'd studied the Dutch as well. And he saw that by lending to each other, you can bind countries together. So in Venice, for example, once you borrowed money from your citizens, the town or the city, well, the citizens had a vested interest in your good governance. They also had a vested interest in your good governance. It also vested interest in your continued survival. Same thing with the Dutch. The Dutch towns became kind of a country by lending to each other. Britain, again, also became a united kingdom by setting up a consolidated annuities market. It's called the consult market.

15:17World's first treasury bonds, really. And he saw that with a very, very vulnerable, weak federal government, and he wanted a strong one, you could actually give all Americans who also held this debt a vested interest in the federal government surviving by making them creditors. So by exchanging all these defaulted bonds in new, fresh, printed, well not printed at the time, but fresh treasury bonds, you could actually give the federal government a fighting chance. Because now we think of history as a series of natural and inescapable conclusions, one B follows A and C follows B. History doesn't work that way. It's just a series of accidents. It was not written in the stars that America would become the mighty country it is. There

16:02were 13 squabbling colonies that didn't always get on, and it was not assured that it would emerge as one country or stay as one country. In fact, there was a civil war, of course, later. But I think a lot of the steps Alexander Hamilton made in those first fateful few years were hugely impactful in binding the country together, healing the economy, and restoring America's credit around the world. Buy stocks to sell before the end of the week. You might be missing the opportunity of the year. You're not being positioned right now. My guy says now's the time to go all in. Real traders still hear the noise. They just know when to stop listening to it. Find and research opportunities to fit your strategy with thinkorswim trading platforms from Schwab. Discover features like

16:49robust charting, nearly unlimited customization, and built-in risk management technology. Plus, get 24-7 support from real trading specialists. That's Schwab Trading. Learn more at schwab.com slash trading. Investors have never had so much information at their fingertips, and as incredible as that is, it's also made it harder to sift through the noise and find the signal. And that's why I use Claude every single day. Claude is the AI for problem solvers. It's the collaborator that understands your entire workflow and thinks with you, not for you. Whether you're debugging code at midnight, building a financial model, or strategizing your next business move, Cloud extends your thinking to tackle the problems that matter.

17:27Cloud is a lot more than just a souped-up search engine, too. You can give it a whole task, you can dig deeper, find better sources, and help you find information that you would have missed otherwise. You can factor that into your decision-making and come to better conclusions. One of my favorite things about Claude is since it runs in the cloud, the same conversation that I start on my desktop moves to my mobile and keeps going even when I close the app on my laptop. Hand off the tedious work to Claude. Try it on any paid plan at claude.ai slash fool. That's claude.ai slash fool and check out Claude Pro, which includes access to all of the features mentioned in today's episode. claude.ai slash fool and check out Claude Pro, which includes access to all of the features mentioned

18:05in today's episode. Claude.ai slash fool. Nowadays, we're talking a lot about the AI build-out and the increasing role that bonds are playing. And when people look back at history for maybe a comparable period, some have suggested the build-out of the railroads, which you cover in your book. So tell us about how bonds built the rails and led to one of the railroads, which you cover in your book. So tell us about how bonds built the rails and led to one of the worst economic downturns in US history. Yes, it was a humdinger. I love traveling by rail. I'd much rather travel by rail anytime I can. So that chapter was fun. And we think of rail as a very sort of everyday, old-fashioned transportation now,

18:45but it was a revolutionary technology. It was hard to fathom for us today how awestruck people were at this new invention and the impact it had. I mean, everything from the AI fears we have today, people feared that the railway, that the human body wasn't built for these kind of mad cap speeds. People thought that there were lots of newspapers that write about people going mad at speeds over 30 miles an hour. And at 40, 50 miles, I think, they feared the body might disintegrate. Because we just weren't built, us humans weren't built for those sort of magical speeds. But everywhere in the world went railway mad. Britain, of course, started, but it spread around Europe, Tsarist Russia, even China. But nowhere on the planet went as railway

19:31mad as Americans, because it was kind of the perfect lab for it. It was the mix of America's kind of can-do, dreaming spirit, a country that was vast in geography, but quite sparsely populated and quite spread out and quite balkanized as well. And also, you know, they started building railways before the Civil War, but after the Civil War became a very potent symbol of unifying the country after this horrific civil war. So the transcontinental railways became this potent sign of America and its belief in the future. These were kind of like, in The Fabulous Dead, I call them like a series of Apollo programs, these kind of big, titanic, civilizational missions, and that's how they were seen. But unfortunately, they were almost all financed by debt.

20:26So there were railway stocks as well. And there were people would sign, paid locals in the town would finance it by signing up for shares. But the vast majority of the financing came from the bond market. Because the American banking system was a bit of a mess. There was no Federal Reserve then. There was no central bank. It was just a series of very small state-by-state banks that would collapse very quickly. So bonds financed a lot of it. And people went a little bit mad. Foreigners also chucked money at the American bond market, the railway bond market. So they were financing everything. The Dutch, Brits, Germans, Austrians, Spanish, everybody would buy railway bonds, American railway bonds. And in 1873, ironically, it wasn't really America's fault, though there

21:11were all sorts of scandals around the railways with so much corruption. Even the vice president was implicated at one point. So people were worried about the railway boom. But there was a financial crisis in Europe, here, in Germany and Austria, that essentially caused massive stock market drop in Germany and Austria, that caused all these European investors and as you know in a crisis, you don't sell what you want to sell, you sell what you can sell. So they sold American railway bonds. And then suddenly you had a series of American banks with extremely precarious position because the prices of these bonds were cratering. They had them on the balance sheet. And primarily there was this one bank called J.

21:49Cook & Co. And he was the John Pierpont Morgan of his era. He was the giant financier that had helped bankroll the North's victory in the Civil War. He was the most famous most powerful man in american business at the time and and his bank went belly up and the shock must have been incredible i mean there's all sorts of newspaper reports about the panic that gripped new york when this happened when they literally barred the doors because that's how a bank would basically say we're shut for business you can't pull your money out uh but it's a bit like if jp morgan today suddenly said oh we're bankrupt well that's how big a shock it was and then that financial crisis just cut i mean everything collapsed and that ricochet back in europe and you have a classic thing where

22:35things start feeding on themselves and it was for a long time called the great depression until we actually had the great depression and now we call it typically the Long Recession or the Long Depression because it's still the longest economic downturn in American history. And it was all because of railway bonds was the real culprit there. It's another example of, you know, there can be overinvestment, there can be a mania, there can be a bubble, but in the end, what came out on the other end was still very beneficial. Yeah. I mean, it's a great point, isn't it? I mean, financial crises are no fun. I've lived through one and a half, two and a half, depending on, I wasn't old enough to remember the sum of them. And they are destructive and socially debilitating but they are probably unavoidable

23:27and quite often that kind of mania like one of the things i i often like to say is that the optimal number of financial crisis is not zero that we occasionally need investors to take leave of their senses to dream not worry about what could go wrong but think of all the amazing things that could go right because they pour money into new technologies and quite often they lose money. And sometimes they lose so much money it causes a financial crisis. But quite often what they finance, that's how we make these big leaps forward. And the railways is an amazing example. I mean, this made America a superpower. It was not recognized in America at the time. It was only really seen by the world, the contours of it, by World War I,

24:09so 50 years after this big crash. But the railway system became this physical skeleton of the American economy, transformed America. And I think you cannot underestimate how impactful it was in creating the United States of America we know today. And yes, to use the technical word, sucked for a few years, and lots of people lost a lot of money. But long term, these manias are actually quite good for society as a whole, not always, but most of the time. Your book has an interesting history of how things used to be, right? And not really all that long ago. So I think a good example of that is the rise of money market funds. Yeah. So tell us the story of Bruce Bent and Henry Brown and the conditions of the 1960s that led

25:00to the creation of the modern money market fund, which I guess starts with a depression era law known as Regulation Q. Yeah. So I often paraphrase one of my favorite bands from when I was younger, Wu-Tang Clan, that said money rules everything around, cash rules everything around us, sorry. But I say financial arbitrage rules everything around us. And the US after, in World War II and afterwards had something called Regulation Q that regulated how much interest you could get on a bank account. And if you're a big institution, a big company, or a very wealthy person, you could buy treasury bonds that paid a high interest rate. You could buy lots of things that would pay you above inflation interest rates. But most people were stuck in deposit accounts that paid far below inflation.

25:48So they invented the first money market fund. But basically using the mutual fund technology as a way of pooling lots of money so they could buy treasury bills, bonds, commercial paper, ASBAC commercial paper, certificates of deposit, the whole thing so really to bring uh democratize access to some of these products that wealthy people and and companies already have access to and i think it was a hugely valuable thing uh then the money market funds eventually kind of morphed into something almost like the, if we think of credit as the lifeblood for any sort of real economy, the money market funds, especially in America, is kind of the bloodstream of the blood that goes through the US financial system. Because they grew so big so quickly,

26:39even when Regulation Q was scrapped, it just became a huge part of the American financial industry. It was basically bailed out a lot of asset managers in the 70s and 80s when there was really struggling. It was growth of mutual funds. Money market funds really helped Vanguard survive many lean years in the 80s. Fidelity as well might not have been around if they didn't have the money market fund franchise. And now it's kind of this dark force that binds the entire financial system together. It's what, seven, eight trillion dollars just in the United States. It's how vast amounts of finance and financial transactions get lubricated every day. It's really a financial wonder of the world. What I love about the story is that, first of all,

27:30it's the vision of two guys sharing an office. One had to basically put a second mortgage on his home for the business to continue. It succeeds. They have the oldest money market fund, but the reserve primary fund. But in the end, that didn't come to such a great ending no uh it's it's quite tragic actually i was i was you want to root for the pioneers right and i like that this was an independent money market fund complex they were hugely successful they were copied by everybody else who had like these vast ass management groups like Fidelity and State Street. But they were the plucky outsider, the plucky pioneer. And they were, for a long time, exceptionally conservative. So the two founders felt that money market funds should be conservative.

28:19This is all about capital protection and making it work a little bit from you but being careful but as money market funds started buying commercial paper and then ultimately so this is short-term ious issued by big companies like rbm or ge um they also started buying asset-backed commercial paper which was short-term is that investment banks used to lubricate their securitization engines before 2008. That was a bit of a disaster. And the first reserve fund famously, one of the founders said that, I don't do drugs, I don't do booze, I don't cheat, and I don't buy commercial paper, or some words to that effect. They were very conservative, very long, but they eventually obviously lost market share. And this is just a tragedy that you see happen

29:11again and again. And even as I was researching this and I could see where things were heading, I was almost shouting to myself, please don't do it, don't do it. And then they did it. Literally in 2007, they take out a line from their prospectus where they say, we don't buy commercial paper and started buying commercial paper. And then first were exposed to some of the Bear Stearns funds that first went belly up in the summer of 2007. Then more problematic, they were extremely exposed to Bear Stearns itself when they went belly up in March 2008. But beer got kind of bailed out by JP Morgan, which had basically the Federal Reserve pushing them together. But by the time Lehman went under, they still hadn't gotten out of it. They'd still basically kind of been trying to squeeze more and more yield out,

30:01had been lending more and more risky stuff, and they lost money uh to when when Lehman went under and obviously in dollar terms the loss was not big but they broke the buck like also their net asset value went below one and to many people in the stock market or bond market world that sounds inconsequential like oh you've lost 0.02 percent of your money but of course this is not where you're supposed to lose money this is supposed to be the the financial financial equivalent of a steel vault and and obviously it causes this kind of incentive that you want to get out it's a bank run incentive because if you can get out quickly you can get out of the nav quite often but of course that causes everybody to rush for the exit because they want to get their money out first from the bank and that's what happened and

30:48the first reserve fund basically suddenly had when lehman went bust and they broke the buck they had i think something like 40 billion dollars of outflows uh it's like an electronic bank run uh in the matter of a few days and they had to gate and shut and that just paralyzed the entire industry and because so much of the financial machinery depends on money market funds to lubricate things things were not good in september 2008 either it forced the government to basically bail out the entire industry i mean they didn't send the money but they basically said look it's better for us to just guarantee all money market funds. Just we guarantee the federal government stand behind all of them to prevent this already

31:34cataclysmic event escalating into, I guess, being Norwegian, something I call a financial Ragnarok. It would have been horrifically bad. 2008 was bad. If the money market fund industry had been allowed to collapse, it would have been immeasurably worse. It would quite possibly have been something like the Great Depression all over again. Shop Black Friday Appliance Savings and get up to an extra $1,250 off select appliance purchases like GE Profile. Plus, free delivery on appliance purchases of $398 or more. Make life easier with the fridge that doubles as your personal kitchen assistant. Or upgrade your laundry room with the ultra-fresh Vent System Plus front load washer. So your clothes stay fresh after every single wash.

32:22Shop Black Friday Appliance Savings with fast free delivery at the Home Depot. Offer valid November 4th through December 2nd at participating stores and at homedepot.com. U.S. only. See store online for details. When it's time to scale your business, it's time for Shopify. Get everything you need to grow the way you want. Like, all the way. Stack more sales with the best converting checkout on the planet. Track your cha-chings from every channel right in one spot. And turn real-time reporting into big-time opportunities. Take your business to a whole new level. Switch to Shopify. Start your free trial today. So your book talks a lot about, again, the benefits of the debt, but also has some of

33:07these stories of where too much debt was a problem. The final chapter of your book is titled, How Much is Too Much? And you point out that if you add up all the world's debt, government, corporate, banks, personal debt, we're like $340 trillion. And in that chapter, you introduce something called Ferguson's Law. So tell us about the law and your answer to how much is too much. Yes, I think we're at $350 trillion now. So it's already gone up a bit since the book came out, since the book was edited, I guess. So Ferguson's Law is coined actually by Neil Ferguson, the financial historian, but he actually dedicates it to almost an intellectual predecessor called Adam Ferguson, who was the Scottish philosopher who first said that debt was one of the main sources of ruin for

34:01all great nations. So Neil Ferguson took that observation and turned it into an idea or a suggestion or a thesis, or he calls it a law, that says that when a country spends more on simply paying the interest on its debt than it does on defense, it tends to lead to decline. So this is in the context of great powers, superpowers, but also great powers. So when England essentially essentially was paying had borrowed so much money after world war one that it wasn't able to pay to maintain its empire its military its navy and had to shrink it tended to hasten that decline it made the country poorer and then it starts feeding on themselves and the reason why this is so resonant now is America, for the first time in a century,

34:47because occasionally you can violate the law because you suddenly jack up interest payments because you're borrowing a lot of money or whatever. But America violated the law, Ferguson's law, in 2024, so two years ago, and is still in violation of it now. It's spending more just servicing its debts not paying it down just paying the interest than than it does on its entire military so given your review of the history of how debt has both contributed to the rise but also maybe the undermining of empires what What's your advice for America? There's no easy solution. Is it just you have to bite the bullet for a while and get it under control? Well, to paraphrase Warren Buffett, it's an easy solution.

35:38It's just very hard to do. The easy solution is to increase taxes a little bit and cut spending a little bit. America, I am actually, I mean, bro, I'll bring you good news. I'm not that worried about America. I think the size of the economy, people stare too much at just the nominal size of the debt, $40 trillion. I mean, that is a scary amount of debt and how quickly a lot of that has come in just the past 10, 20 years. And don't forget in the 90s, we were in the 90s, people were worried about the American financial system, how it would function with zero treasuries. America had such big budget deficits as recently as the late 90s that they stopped auctioning 30-year treasuries and people genuinely

36:21worried, how do things even work without treasuries if America pays down all its debts? That obviously sounds like fantasy land today. But it's just to show that things can change quite quickly. And America still has an incredibly vibrant, dynamic economy. And frankly, does not tax nearly as much as many other developed countries does. So in percent of GDP, America spends around 3.5% of its GDP on servicing its debts. And that is almost mechanically going to go up because the budget deficit is huge and is not narrowed and interest rates are higher now than they were. So it's refinances. The US is constantly repaying treasuries it issued 10 years ago at two percent a year that now costs at five percent a year so it's just mechanically going

37:10to go up probably to four five percent that is again that has been fine for many other countries before it they're around five percent it can start snowballing a bit um and that's what we've saw for example happened happen in the UK. They hit 5% of GDP on servicing its states in 1980. Then you had Margaret Thatcher came into power. She turned the ship around. Things changed there. Canada, hilariously enough, because we don't really think of Canada as financially profitably good, but Canada had a huge debt problem. They spent 10% of GDP or 9.6% of GDP in the mid-90s. And then they had a bipartisan agreement to say, well, this is kind of silly. It's just wasteful to spend so much of our financial, of our budget and our economic

38:00wealth on just paying our debts. So there was a bipartisan agreement to cut spending and increase taxes. They did at a time when the economy was growing fairly well. So the austerity was painful, but it was fine. And within a few years, Canada had turned the financial ship around. And it went from a AAA country to a single A country and back to AAA. Those are the grades that the credit rating agencies use. And those countries have the advantage that they borrow in British pounds or Canadian dollars. But, you know, I like Canadian dollars and I like British pounds, but the American dollar is unique. I think America has far more capacity to borrow than anybody else on the planet. Now, the downside of that, and this

38:47is why I am a little bit worried about the US on the other hand, because of that advantage, it kind of makes America a little bit immune to all those other pressures that other countries can feel. Like the UK in 2022 felt the heat of the bond market and they haven't turned the ship around, but at least they learned that maybe they're in the danger zone and they need to get out of it. France is now butting up against that as well. They're also getting a little bit worried about the bond market and that they might rebel. Canada also felt this a little bit in the 1990s. But America, I just think interest rates can go up, bond yields can go up borrowing costs can go up i just don't think they're going to go up as much enough to put enough pressure

39:31what looks to me if i'm being honest like a fairly broken political system or struggles that kind of bipartisan agreement that you saw in canada i struggle i'm not a political scientist, but I struggle to stay in America today. So therefore, the most likely outcome, I suspect, is that America totters on. And there will be maybe some more budgetary discipline at some point. It'll wax and wane. Interest rates will go up, they'll go down. But over the next 10, 20 years, America's debts will keep inflating. With not enough pressure on the other side, no political will to increase taxes enough or cut spending enough that the debts will just keep on inflating for the next generation or two. And maybe at some point there will be enough political will to change things, but I don't

40:23think it's going to happen anytime soon. Yeah, I think one of the earliest tests of it will be when the Social Security trust funds go bust in 2032 or so. At some point, there's going to have to be a hard choice there. And I think it'll test your theory of whether we can get enough bipartisan agreement to solve something. Yeah. I mean, look, I'm an optimist. I generally think that by profession, I love bad news. I love it when I love financial crisis. It sounds horrific to say, but they are professionally fascinating. I get my rocks off with big crises. But as a human being, I'm actually quite, so I am inherently cynical as a journalist, but as a human being, and I actually think humans, we don't, things don't move in a straight line

41:08and we mess up things all the time. But I actually do believe that at some point, America will feel, will look and say, well, look, we're spending 5% of GDP or 10% of the budget on just paying interest on our debts. That is silly. There are so many other things we want to spend money on. We want to spend more money on healthcare, education, AI data centers, rockets to the moon, to Mars, whatever. And there will be some sort of bipartisan agreement to cut spending and increase taxes. And America actually doesn't. We're not talking about swinging to budget surplus tomorrow. That'd be economically devastating. But just getting the lines pointing in the right direction would not take that much effort.

41:54And getting them pointing forcefully in the right direction would take a bit of an effort, but one I think is entirely possible. But right now feels hard to predict that it's going to happen anytime soon. But I think it will be fine. Countries have had those kind of positions with a pension savings. I think that's going to be quite difficult. But, you know, Americans have triumphed through harder challenges than this. So I believe in you guys. Thank you, Robin. I appreciate that confidence and I certainly hope that you are right. Well, congrats on the book. I really enjoyed it. And thanks so much for joining us. No, no, bro. Thanks so much for having me on and letting me bang on about the bond market.

42:35It is my favorite subject in the whole world, as you can probably tell. Thank you so much. And that's the show. Thank you so much for spending part of your weekend with us. And thanks to Bart Shannon, as always, the engineer for this episode. People on the program may have interest in the investments they talk about, and The Motley Fool may have formal recommendations for or against. So don't buy or sell investments based solely on what you hear. All personal finance content follows Motley Fool editorial standards and is not approved by advertisers. Advertisements are sponsored content and provided for informational purposes only. To see our full advertising disclosure, please check out our show notes.

43:10I'm Robert Brokamp. Fool on, everybody.

▸More episode summaries

Motley Fool Hidden Gems Investing cover art
Motley Fool Hidden Gems InvestingNvidia After Jensen Huang: Is the AI Bubble About to Burst?2026-11-13 · 40 min
Motley Fool Hidden Gems Investing cover art
Motley Fool Hidden Gems InvestingHuang is out, Kress is in at Nvidia2026-11-12 · 23 min
Motley Fool Hidden Gems Investing cover art
Motley Fool Hidden Gems InvestingBonds Are Back — And BlackRock’s Fixed Income Chief Explains How to Take Advantage2026-11-15 · 28 min
Transcribe your links. Paste a YouTube, Google Drive or podcast link and WhipScribe gives you the transcript. Transcribe a link →
New Motley Fool Hidden Gems Investing transcripts by email
One email per new episode, unsubscribe in every message. Not shared with the publisher.