Football Daily · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
Football Daily unpacks why Manchester United fired Carrick, what Pochettino brings, and whether the club's leadership is the real problem.
Tap a chapter to open that moment in the transcript; the link to it is copied for you.
“there's more noise around the Manchester United job than any other job in the world” Tom Allnut · at 19:26 — open in the transcript →
Manchester United have sacked head coach Michael Carrick after a poor start that left them 18th in the Premier League with one win from 10 games. Hosts Rick Edwards and Lloyd Griffith are struck that the club's statement praised Carrick as a legend while dismissing him, and they argue the real problem sits above the manager. BBC reporter Simon Stone walks through how the decision was reached: it followed a 4-0 draw with Aston Villa, needed sign-off from Sir Jim Ratcliffe and the Glazers, and was delayed by a meeting in Monaco, so Carrick kept taking training during the international break while his exit was already decided.
Fan Jay Motti calls the handling unedifying, arguing Carrick deserved better as a club legend who got the side into the Champions League last season. Across the panel, sympathy for Carrick is strong, and a recurring theme is that the club has churned through managers since Alex Ferguson left, from Jose Mourinho onward, with no lasting change in results.
Attention then turns to Maurizio Pochettino, whose 7 million pound release clause from the US team is being paid by Manchester United, with training expected around November 18th or 19th before a game against Liverpool. Times writer Tom Allnut argues he handles media pressure well and has the experience to cope with the scrutiny at Manchester United, though his record at PSG and Chelsea is less convincing. The panel debate whether he will get the control he wants, and why Daniel Levy's doubts ended any Spurs return.
BBC Sports reporter covering Manchester United, who explained how the decision to sack Michael Carrick was made.
Times football writer who covered Maurizio Pochettino at Spurs and Chelsea.
Manchester United fan speaking from the Stretford Paddock, who gave the supporters' view of Carrick's sacking.
Tom Allnut said there is more noise around the Manchester United job than any other job in the world, so the next manager needs to handle intense scrutiny. He said that is one of the boxes Maurizio Pochettino ticks.
“there's more noise around the Manchester United job than any other job in the world”Tom Allnut · 19:26
Simon Stone said Jason Wilcox and Omar Barada decide the club's strategy, and that the Manchester United executives reached the decision to sack Michael Carrick after the 4-0 draw with Aston Villa.
“Basically, the process is that Jason Wilcox and Omar Barada decide on the strategy.”Simon Stone · 6:02
Jay Motti said the way Manchester United handled Michael Carrick's sacking was unedifying, because Carrick had to keep working with players during the international break while everyone knew he was leaving. He called Carrick a club legend who cares about the club.
“to treat someone like that isn't great”Jay Motti · 13:03
Jay Motti said he likes Maurizio Pochettino because he comes across well in interviews and handles the media well, which Manchester United fans need from a manager given the scrutiny at the club. He also said Pochettino has a lot of experience, including managing at Chelsea and at a World Cup for a host nation.
“he always comes across well in interviews and handles the media well,”Jay Motti · 22:10
Tom Allnut said Daniel Levy always had reservations about bringing Maurizio Pochettino back to Tottenham, because of how his last year there ended and the emotional damage left behind. He said the new Tottenham regime is reluctant to make the signature decision of the old one.
“Daniel Levy always had reservations about going back to Pochettino”Tom Allnut · 26:33
Manchester United sacked head coach Michael Carrick after 10 Premier League games and one win, which left them 18th in the table. The club moved to appoint Maurizio Pochettino, who is reported to be finalising a deal with a 7 million pound release clause paid by Manchester United, with training expected on November 18th or 19th.
Manchester United sacked Michael Carrick after 10 Premier League games with one win, which left them 18th in the table. BBC reporter Simon Stone said Jason Wilcox and the club's executives decided after a 4-0 draw with Aston Villa that a change was needed. The decision then had to be signed off by Sir Jim Ratcliffe and the Glazers, and a meeting in Monaco pushed the timing back.
BBC Sports reporter Simon Stone said the decision came after Manchester United lost 10 Premier League games and collected only one win, and that the club wanted to find out who was available before making a change. He said Maurizio Pochettino became the clear choice as the process moved on. Omar Barada wanted to speak to Carrick personally, which is why Carrick was still taking training during the international break.
Times football writer Tom Allnut said there is more noise around the Manchester United job than any other job in the world, so a manager has to handle intense scrutiny. He said Maurizio Pochettino ticks that box through big jobs at PSG and Chelsea and through his press conferences. Allnut questioned whether those spells were football successes, but he said Pochettino has a charming style that works well with journalists and players.
Jay Motti, a Manchester United fan speaking from the Stretford Paddock, said the way the club handled Carrick was unedifying. He said Carrick had to motivate his players during the international break knowing he was leaving, and he called him a club legend who got the team into the Champions League last season. Motti said he felt sorry for Carrick even while accepting that he had not been good enough as a permanent manager.
Tom Allnut said Maurizio Pochettino is a throwback to the old-school manager who believes the manager knows best, a style he links to Alex Ferguson and to Marcelo Bielsa. He said it would be interesting to see whether Manchester United give Pochettino the authority he craves, since most Premier League clubs now spread that power across sporting directors, analysts and agents.
Tom Allnut said the timing never quite aligned for Pochettino to return to Tottenham. The one summer it could have happened was when he went to Chelsea, and Spurs considered it but decided against it. He said Daniel Levy had reservations about going back because of how the first spell ended and the emotional wreckage left behind, and that the new regime at Tottenham is reluctant to make the signature decision of the old one.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp or the link button on a paragraph to copy a link that opens this page there.
0:00This BBC podcast is supported't just about the grid. That same racing mindset, the obsession with engineering, the pursuit of perfection, lives in the Cadillac V-Series lineup, giving you the chance to experience the precision and performance of the grid on the open road. Cadillac V-Series, distinctive luxury performance, engineered to thrill. Discover the V-Series lineup at Cadillac.com. Host Thanksgiving with industry-leading quality standards from Whole Foods Market. There are no antibiotics in their meat department ever, so carve up turkey and spiral-cut ham with peace of mind. Shop organic sides like stuffing mix and cranberry sauce from 365 Brand. And guess what? All their delectable pies are made with no high fructose corn syrup.
1:06Gourmet Thanksgiving flavors with the quality you want. Only at Whole Foods Market. The Football Daily Podcast with Rick Edwards and Lloyd Griffith. Well, it's official. Manchester United have sacked their head coach, Michael Carrick. You're joking. I am not joking. Out of the blue? Completely out of the blue. I did not see that coming. He's been doing well. They'll be flying. As a Liverpool fan, they've been doing very well. I'm sure you'd agree. Yeah, no, he's gone. Wow. I mean, we're joking about being surprised. We have been on standby. We've been basically on Carrick Watch for the last 24 hours. I was walking around Soho yesterday waiting to come into the studio. Exactly. We were like,
1:52producer Finn was saying things like, what's your journey time into the studio? It was that sort of military operation. You're like, okay, soon as we hear, 25 minutes, get it. And then it didn't happen yesterday. It didn't. But then I stayed up, just in case, I stayed up all night. No, you didn't. You go to bed at eight o'clock. I do, actually, yeah. I still feel tired, amazingly. This is what Manchester United have said. After a disappointing start to the season, depends on your perspective, the club has come to the extremely difficult conclusion that a change is necessary in order to achieve our ambitions. Michael is and always will be a Manchester United legend. Just as he is a player he's conducted himself
2:29with the highest standards of dedication and professionalism throughout his time back with the club. His leadership and achievements last season will always be fondly remembered. The club intends to appoint a permanent successor as quickly as possible. Do you know what I think they're missing there? Because it's a lovely sign off from you know the people upstairs. They missing there? Because it's a lovely sign-off from, you know, the people upstairs. They should just say, the problem is with us. Because there's not a lot. When you read between the lines, they're like, look, this guy's great. He's dedicated. He's professional. He's a legend. Always has been. Always will be. He did really well last season.
2:59We're the issue. I just, do you know what? I felt really sorry for Carrick yesterday because obviously everyone was talking about whether Carrick was going to get sacked and reports that he was at Carrington with some of the players that had been called up for international duty and, you know, the academy and youth team. And he's just there, you know, and at that point, I think you've lost all discipline within the squad, which is a bit of a shame. And then the meeting was happening in Monaco, which I think is quite indicative of what is going on at this club the reason why the meeting happened in Monaco is because Jim Ratcliffe lives out there reportedly saved four billion pounds by moving to Monaco
3:30he just likes the place I think does he? it's a fringe benefit you don't have to pay the tax but like I think he just likes Monaco he's from Manchester yeah yeah I think he just likes Monaco that was my understanding fair enough but he's also reported that he's gone there for tax reasons. And then they've gone out there to have a meeting whilst Michael Carrick's in Manchester, the Manchester United legend. And it's just seemingly that this club is operating in the same kind of way. They're just penny-pinching. They're cost-cutting. They're not employing the right people. They're taking money from the wrong kind of purses. And I just think that unless there is a change at the top, we will keep having these.
4:08Like, do you mind just staying around Soho? Because I think Manchester United are about to sack another manager. It is not going to change until everything changes at the top. To be fair, you are normally just knocking about Soho, aren't you? We're just waiting for jobs, really. Yeah, just keep waiting. The thing that is different about this, for me anyway, is that normally when managers are getting sacked or on the brink of getting sacked or in trouble, the fans are all fuming at the manager. And it's like they are sort of a lightning rod for all of the frustration that the fans feel. And that, as far as I can tell, is just not the case here. Well, I think there are some fans online that are a bit angry with the frustration that the fans feel. And that, as far as I can tell,
4:45is just not the case here. Well, I think there are some fans online that are a bit angry with the way that Carrick was managing. But overall, I think they just feel sorry. Yeah. He's a scapegoat. Yeah. He came in, he did a really good job, should have been appointed manager. Again, that splits a billion. It's not on him, is it? It's not on him. He's not going to say no. We've all taken, I mean, you and I especially, have taken jobs that we go, I think we're a little bit underqualified. Here we are. Well, literally, here we are. But, you know, he's had a go. And I just, I genuinely feel really sorry for Michael Carrick because you just go, well, good luck to whoever's coming in and having to deal with the situation
5:20because they're not going to let you buy players. But also, no, probably not. Also, this is a case where I don't think Michael Carrick's reputation as a manager has taken any sort of hit, which is weird. They've had a terrible start to the season. But I don't really feel that Michael Carrick is going to have to try and explain that because the explanation is clear. It's just like, ah, well, the Monaco lot. What am I supposed to do with the Monaco lot? Any interview that he goes into, what went wrong in the last job? Well, you know. Yeah. You saw what happened. Let's bring in BBC Sports Manchester United reporter Simon Stone. Hi, Simon. So we heard all about, I mean, everyone heard all about
6:02this trip to Monaco for their regular Monaco meeting yesterday. The timeline of it, I think, is interesting because everyone knew that this was, I think, everyone knew this was going to happen. Why did it take as long as it took, do you think? Well, I think even Michael Carrick was on Michael Carrick watch at one point. Basically, the process is that Jason Wilcox and Omar Barada decide on the strategy. And I think they decided after the 4-0 draw against Aston Villa that Michael Carrick had to go. That 10 games, oneth in the Premier League is not sorry 10 games one win in the Premier League is not acceptable. So you bite your hand off for 10th in the Premier League Simon. I just raised them up quite a lot.
6:5318th in the Premier League was unacceptable but they have to communicate that to Sir Jim Ratcliffe who then has to basically sign it off then the Glazers have to do the same thing. And then there was this meeting in the middle of the week, which was for all INEOS chief executives. So Omar Barada was committed to going to that. So that's why he went and presumably Jason Wilcox went as well. Then they have to speak to Sir Jim Ratcliffe. They have to decide that that is the strategy that they're going to put into place. But also Omar Barada was very keen that he wanted to speak to Michael Carrick. So he has to clearly come back from Monaco and the first day that he could speak to Michael Carrick after the decision was made was this morning and that is why we've ended
7:54up in this weird situation where Michael Carrick has come in and taken training on Tuesday and Wednesday they didn't make him stay on and do today. I'm pleased to report, but that is why we've ended up where we have. Manchester United accept that it doesn't look good, but don't feel as though there was any other way of doing it. Was it inevitable that it was going to happen? Obviously, after the four-all draw, you said they'd made their mind up. Obviously, and we'll talk about Pochettino in a minute, it looks like he's probably going to come in. Do you think talks had already happened or was it quickly after the Villa draw? feet by Bournemouth but after that game Manchester United communicated that they were going to take
8:46some time to reflect on where Manchester United effectively as a football team were Carrick was allowed to turn or try and turn the situation around it was stressed that the players were given the opportunity to turn the situation around as well. But I think it's then that Manchester United thought we need to put feelers out to find out who's available if we need to make a change. Then it becomes apparent that Maurizio Pochettino is willing to do this job. In the meantime, Manchester United play decently in the first half against Chelsea but lose. They played terribly in the first half against Chelsea but lose they played terribly in the first half against Roma but come back and win and then appallingly at the start of the game
9:33against Aston Villa pull that back play quite well and then throw it away again and consider another two goals and then they've got to come back with another late injury time survival mission so I think at the end of that Manchester United thought this is not good enough this is not going anywhere we have to make a change and by that point they'd already decided that Maurizio Pochettino was the right guy for them and then they put into into motion that the wheels almost that that are going to lead to Maurizio Pochettino, I think, next week coming to Manchester, taking over for the game against Liverpool a week on Sunday. So to confirm, they'd been speaking to Pochettino for a few weeks? Well, I don't know if it's a few weeks, but I think it's more than a week. It's a period of time, I think, that has allowed them to execute this deal
10:28almost once the decision is made that Michael Carrick was going to be sacked. So given all of this, given Richie Pochettino's commitments to the US team, you're expecting him to get to Manchester sometime middle of next week, would you say? Yeah, they've got a game against Haiti. I think it starts at midnight Tuesday, our time. That's kind of Tuesday evening in the United States. Well, that means that in reality Maurizio Pochettino is not going to be in the UK until probably Thursday at the earliest maybe Friday I would imagine he will be on the training pitch on Friday I would be surprised if he didn't do some kind of press conference on Friday because that's a contractual obligation for the Premier League
11:27ahead of Premier League games. And then obviously the final kind of build-up to the Liverpool game on Saturday and the Liverpool game itself on the Sunday. Just before I let you go, Simon, before we came on, you were just chatting about looking at yourself in the camera and sort of bemoaning your lack of hair. Now, I think you look great with the bald sheen. Have you thought about a wig? Funnily enough, I haven't. I've probably gone for the Jay Motty bald look. That's probably the way that I'd go. And Jay has trademarked that look as well. You're right. Well, I'm quite pleased on the positive side at the lack of greyness given A, I'm nearly 59 years of age and B, I've been covering Manchester United for so long
12:22and that's enough to send anybody grey. So it's thankful for small mercies, I think. Well, I think you look fantastic. Thanks very much for joining us. Cheers, Simon. No worries. We are now joined by Manchester United fan, Jay Motti from the Stretford Paddock. Hey, Jay. Look, we knew this was coming. We've all known it was coming. But just in terms of the way it's all played out, as a fan, how are you feeling right now, now that it's done? Yeah, I'm not exactly surprised. We all knew it was going to happen. I spoke to you lads after the Como game and I thought actually that might be his last game in charge. And I just feel a bit sorry for Michael Carrick. I don't think it's been very tasteful,
13:03the way it's been handled. When he's coming into training and trying to motivate his players, the players that he's working with during the international break, everyone knows he's leaving. Everyone knows that he's not going to be the Manchester United manager even until the end of the week and to treat someone like that isn't great, especially someone like Michael Carrick who you might argue with some merit that he hasn't been good enough as a permanent manager but he is a club legend. He's someone that cares about the club. He's someone that's always handled himself in the right way with professionalism and dignity. And yeah, it just felt like a bit of an unedifying way to treat someone like that.
13:34And I did actually feel sorry for Michael Carrick. I felt sorry for him a little while now. We could see it wasn't working and he's been strung along. And yeah, it's a sad sort of end to his tenure at Manchester United. And let's not forget, you know, end of last season, he promised so much, he got us into the Champions League. United fans were buzzing, he got the place pumping again. And then to see it sort of end, what, in the middle of November, after he only appointed a permanent manager in the summer. Yeah, it's just, it's really sad, to be honest with you. A lot of Manchester United fans are saying, it doesn't really matter what manager you bring in. I mean, the club is in a mess. Obviously, you talked about Pochettino coming in, not been confirmed yet.
14:11But bringing Pochettino in, does that change any of that for you? I think we needed a change. I think you can see it's flat. You can see the players aren't responding. They're not doing what they should do. And the players are speaking out against the manager you saw with Bruno Fernandes. So I think there had to be some change. I get the argument that almost United feel doomed. It's like, you look at the managers we've had, not just since Ineos came in, but before Ineos. We've had the likes of Jose Mourinho and Louis van Gaal. You know, some of the most successful managers ever. Who ultimately end up getting sacked. Bringing bright, younger managers who've done well in Tanag and Amarim. More recently, it's not worked. So
14:45you get the feeling there's something fundamentally wrong at Manchester United and sort of since the Ineos era began you look at their set up and their sort of actions, they haven't worked. They stuck with Tanag then sacked him anyway, they brought in Dan Ashworth then sacked him within three months, they brought in Ruben Amrim, end up sacking him after he speaks out against them, bringing Michael Carrick now they've sacked him. You get they brought in Ruben Amrim end up sacking him after he speaks out against them bringing Michael Carrick now they've sacked him you get the impression don't you that almost regardless of which manager you've got nothing's going to change but I still feel like
15:14we have to change the manager you can't just say let's just stick with Michael Carrick because nothing's ever going to change that would be a very risky sort of idea especially with the club in the relegation zone you're just looking at what's gone on basically post Alex Ferguson it's difficult to see light at the end of, especially with the club in the relegation zone. You're just looking at what's gone on. Basically, post-Alex Ferguson, it's difficult to see right at the end of the tunnel with the way this club's being run. It does sort of make me think about what Ralph Rangnick said about Manchester United after his brief spell in charge and the kind of problems that he identified. And at the time, I don't know if everyone sort of bought what he was saying.
15:46And now, like those comments have aged, I think, very, very well. Yeah, I mean, he said, he spoke about, was it open heart surgery? I think he said, was what the club needed. And a lot of people looked at that and they were like, really? A lot of people agreed with him. That's a bit much. Yeah. But since then, you know then he's been proven to be right. I mean we've had the irony is in terms of an overhaul we've had a pretty big overhaul in terms of the squad. There's a lot of players that were there when Ralph Radnick was there that aren't there anymore. We've got a lot of new players in. There's still a lot of players that are there though. There's still a lot of players that are still at the club
16:22that have been here for a long time and you think it's not just about the playing squad. Obviously that is important and it matters but you still at the club that have been here for a long time. And you think it's not just about the playing squad. Obviously, that is important and it matters. But you look at the people above the manager. Are they making the right decisions? Do you trust Jason Wilcox and Owen Brada to move this club forward? Because so far, since they've arrived at Manchester United, all the decisions they've made have been bad ones. And it feels like the next decision they make is to try and make up for the previous bad one. So they bring in, sort of, Dan Ashworth and Saki and they
16:45bring in Ruben Amrim and Saki and they obviously stuck with Tananga and Saki. It always feels like they're playing catch up. So that's not good enough and yeah you mentioned earlier Ralph Ragnick's words look very prophetic and it wasn't that insightful to be honest with you. I think a lot of people could see this club was flawed. I think it's just sad to me as a fan how accurate his words are and how we've still not been able to fix the problems that he spoke about in what seems like an eternity ago. PNC Bank brings you Call of the Wild Money Moves. You hear that? YOLO That's an internet troll telling you to put all your money into a single investment YOLO YOLO YOLO He wants you to liquidate your emergency fund
17:36YOLO And buy a digital racehorse named Silicon Steve YOLO Stay vigilant, he's very persistent YOLO Guard against wild. He's very persistent. YOLO! Guard against wild money moves with PNC Bank. Brilliantly boring since 1865. Host Thanksgiving with industry-leading quality standards from Whole Foods Market. There are no antibiotics in their meat department ever. So carve up turkey and spiral-cut ham with peace of mind. Shop organic sides like stuffing mix and cranberry sauce from 365 Brand. And guess what? All their delectable pies are made with no high fructose corn syrup. Gourmet Thanksgiving flavors with the quality you want. Only at Whole Foods Market. Buy Live Sports. Don't miss out on a whole world of live sports.
18:35With the BBC Sounds app, get access to the biggest sporting moments as they happen on 5 Sports Extra, Sports Extra 2 and Sports Extra 3. Oh, what a throw! Champion in Paris for the first time. Scroll through the live radio dial and put yourself at the heart of the action. This is the Football Daily Podcast with Rick Edwards and Lloyd Griffith. Let's bring in Times football writer Tom Allnut now. Hey, Tom. You spent a lot of time covering Pochettino at Spurs and Chelsea, so you will have been in there with press conferences that he's held. Does he strike you as a guy who is ready for the intense scrutiny and speculation and pressure that comes with being Manchester United manager? Yeah, I think it's one of the boxes that Pochettino ticks, if I'm honest.
19:26I think Manchester United now, I think there's an argument to say that there's more noise around the Manchester United job than any other job in the world. And I think, in a way, you need a manager who can handle that kind of scrutiny, can handle that kind of glare. And I think if you look at Pochettino's career, he's done some of those biggest jobs. You think about PS PSG with when it was you know still a kind of VIP lounge right with like Messi and Neymar and Mbappe all there think about the Chelsea job which was still kind of you know in that that swirl post you know Todd Bowley taking over he dealt with that pretty well very bloated squad and then this job he's just done now with the USA you know I mean okay
20:03it's not a it's not a huge club job but in terms of the context you know the World Cup all the kind of politics and controversy that went around it you know I think Pochettino he knows how to handle that you know and I think that stands him I think in good stead in terms of this United post and we should also say he's very good with the media you know like you know he has a way right with journalists where he kind of, you know, he has that kind of charming, cheeky sort of South American side to him, which I think is kind of a big part of his lure with players. But I think it also works with the media as well. I remember all the way going back to when he was doing a press conference as a Spurs manager against Real Madrid at the Burnabout.
20:43And we were all very used to kind of Pochettino doing his press conferences. And then afterwards, he'd kind of gone off into the corner of the sort of press conference and sort of done another little separate huddle with the Spanish journalists over there. And he thought, maybe he's just kind of, you know, buttering them up for the future. Like, he knows Pochettino how to handle this kind of thing. You know, he's an experienced operator. I think that side of the job, I think he'll handle pretty well at United. the only the only thing i'd say in response really is that those jobs that you mentioned so psg chelsea even the usa job because the weird thing about the usa job we know because we were out there is that going into that tournament he was not popular with fans uh the
21:23fans did not think he was doing a good job. They didn't know who he was. Well, there's a bit of that. And then they had a good tournament, although the way they went out was quite disappointing, but there was a lot of circumstance there. But certainly PSG and Chelsea, I don't think you could brand those as being successful tenures, really. He may have handled himself okay but I don't think he did brilliantly football wise and I wonder if that is a bit of a worry for you Jay in that he's done he did a good job at Tottenham, he did a good job at Espanyol but more recently I'm not quite so sure. Yeah I get the reservations, and I get that there's like, you know, you can look at it and say it feels like he's done a good job
22:10to certain degrees and not a great one. If I'm trying to be positive, I look at it and go at times at Spurs he was working under financial constraints. I think it was in the season they got to the Champions League, I don't think they spent any money. Champions League final, sorry, they didn't spend any money. So there was always an element of at times he was having to push back with Daniel Levy and stuff. So that might help him at Manchester United, where we've seen managers, especially Michael Carrick in the summer, not being back fully. I just... I do worry. One thing I quite like about Pochettino is, and I agree with what Tom said, he always comes across well in interviews and handles the media well,
22:39which you need to do at Manchester United because the scrutiny is unreal. But he's also got a lot of experience. That was one of the sticks he used to beat Michael Carrick. He didn't have any experience. He'd been manager at Middlesbrough where he ultimately ended up getting sacked. You look at Pochettino, he's managed in the Premier League for quite a long time. He's managed under Chelsea which was a bin fire when he got there. He managed at Chelsea and he's had to deal with all that. He's managed at international level during a World Cup of a host nation. So there's a lot of experience there for a manager who's still, you know, he's in his 50s, but he's not that old. So that sort of thing is something that I get a little bit of confidence from
23:13because I think if you're looking at one of the problems that Carrick had was probably just that lack of real managerial experience. You mentioned it, Eric, you know, Pochettino's managed some of the biggest players in the world when you look at PSG. So he's used to handling big egos, which is obviously a bit of an issue at Manchester United at the minute, as we've already seen. He's used to a lot of screwing it. He's used to managing the Premier League. I'm just hoping that he can use all those talents and those assets in the right way at Manchester United, because this is going to be his most difficult job. I really believe that. I think it's twofold. For me, there's alarm bells ringing. I think he's a very good coach
23:46and I think he's a very good manager. We've talked about on this podcast, on other Football Daily podcasts, how he is one of the best coaches. He'll make players better. And obviously, he's got to make a lot of these players. He's got to be very good with young players. Harry Kane talks about how he developed so much under Pochettino's wing. What, for me, Jed, one of the alarm bells is, what do you think they promised him that they haven't promised Carrick or other managers? Because he's not going to go in there and go, oh yeah, I'll just take it on as is. He's going to want players in the summer. And every single time a manager gets released from Manchester United, they come out and talk about how they weren't allowed
24:20various different players. Yeah, I mean, you saw it in the recent interview where he spoke about how he wanted the likes of Harry Kane and Declan Rice, look, everyone can have a wish list, doesn't mean necessarily it's going to come true. But you look at some of the signings we made under Eric Ten Hag's tenure and they just weren't up to it. I'm guessing that the board or whoever's interviewed him or spoke to him is going to say, yeah, in the summer we are going to back you. I also think with Pochettino, with someone like him, there's going to be a certain level of control he's going to want because we know that someone like Jason Wilcox, for be a certain level of control he's going to want.
24:47Because we know that someone like Jason Wilcox, for example, has spoken about how he sees himself as a manager. He's very hands-on. Is Pochettino going to be listening to him? Is he going to be sort of letting him influence the team? Weird that Wilcox was in in Ten Hag's ear. Even in the FA Cup final, there was this rumour that he was sort of trying to get involved in tactics and stuff. I can't see a man with the experience and relative success of Mauricio Pochettino coming to United and then having almost one hand tied behind his back where he's got to listen to Jason Wilcox in terms of the team and the tactics and all the rest of it, so I'm guessing there's going to be a certain promise about the amount of control he's got
25:19I'm guessing as well they're going to say look we are going to help you rebuild, because let's not forget in the summer Manchester United have a lot of players that are out of contracts, a lot of players that are probably going to move on. You look at someone like Lissandro Martinez, who's already more or less got one foot out the door with his recent comments. You look at, I think, Harry Maguire, Bruno Fernandes, there's a decision to be made there. I think Luke Shaw's out of contracts as well. There's quite a few senior players that are going to be looking to move on. Then you've got players that probably aren't up to scratch. You're going to need reinforcements. You're going to need to go big in this summer.
25:48So I'd be very, very surprised if Maurizio Pochettino wasn't promised a sort of war chest, if you will, in the summer and more control over the team than perhaps previous managers have had. Jay, thanks very much for joining us. Cheers, mate. Thanks, lads. Thanks, Tom. See you later. There have been opportunities, I think, Tom, and correct me if I'm wrong here, for Spurs to get back together with Richo Pochettino. A couple of years ago, that was definitely being discussed in the media. I don't know how far it went behind closed doors. What was Spurs' thinking in not going back to him or, indeed, his thinking in not going back to him or indeed his thinking in not going back to Spurs? Yeah, I think in some ways the timing has never quite aligned
26:33I think the one summer when it could have happened was actually the summer when he went to Chelsea which, you know, when Spurs thought about it but in the end decided against it I think Daniel Levy always had reservations about going back to Pochettino. I think he felt that the way it ended at Spurs, it had gone badly in that kind of last year. And also the kind of emotional wreckage of it. I think he always felt that it was not necessarily the best thing to go back. And I also think that since Daniel Levy has gone, subsequently the new regime at Tottenham, if you like, they sort of want to take a new step. There's kind of like a reluctance to sort of make the big first decision of the new regime, the kind of signature decision of the old one.
27:15So I think for Spurs, you know, they've always, I think, seen their future at some point with Pochettino coming back and Pochettino has obviously used plenty of media opportunities to kind of talk about Spurs and how he wants to go back one day and kind of complete that circle but you wonder now I sort of feel like the path for Spurs is very much narrowing like what what kind of scenario now is it that he can go to Tottenham after United if he does well he stays at United if he does badly then perhaps his stock goes down and Spurs are less interested so I don't know quite how that journey ends now. But I mean, I agree with Jay. I just wanted to kind of say that I also think they're a dying breed now,
27:53this type of manager who wants to be kind of have total control. Like more and more, I think we're seeing up and down the Premier League, right? The authority from managers is very much delegated across the club, sporting directors and analysts, you know, agents, whatever you want. But Pochettino is a throwback in that regard. You know, he's a sort of old-fashioned, old-school type where he thinks that the manager knows best, you know, and I think that comes from Ferguson, but it comes, you know, going all the way back to his days of playing under Marcelo Bielsa. You know, he wants to be the number one manager and it'll be very interesting, I think, at United to see if he gets that kind of control that he craves.
28:25Yeah, you mentioned Sir Alex Ferguson there, Tom, and we know that he is a fan of Mauricio Pochettino and United and Pochettino have been doing this kind of dance now for, it must be like 10 years, where he's been in that conversation, in and around, he's having dinner with Ferguson. They love their red wine, apparently. They do love red wine. Well, you know that, Argentinian. You just haven't recovered. And so it's kind of, it's almost felt inevitable, although actually, as a sort of casual onlooker, I thought maybe the opportunity had just passed. But here we are, and it does feel like the culmination of, yes, a long, long time, long courtship period. Yeah, I think that's right. I mean, you know,
29:12I think Pochettino has two things here. One, he kind of comes across as sort of like a very kind of cuddly type, right? He's like brilliantly kind of creating cohesion and togetherness. But he's always been a very ambitious coach. You know, even when he was at Tottenham and kind of professing his love for the club, he always sort of had an eye on other big jobs, Man United, Real Madrid, even England has kind of been talked about here and there, you know. So I think he knows that he has this kind of like, you know, journey to the kind of top of the game, which is what he's always, where he's always wanted to go. But I do think he's also, he's kind of a romantic, you know, like he also is a kind of one of those football types who sort of, he doesize Ferguson you know he does have photos in his office of sort of Maradona and
29:49Ronaldinho like he's one of those kind of managers I think who still believes in the kind of magic of Manchester United if you like um I I guess in a way I mean I know what you were saying at the beginning how you know this job is a difficult job know, and a lot of it will come from what, you know, the, what goes on around the manager. Can any coach make this Manchester United into a successful force? I guess the other way I might look at it is that if you are a sort of a coach who, who really believes in yourself, you're taking over a huge club who at the moment are 18th in the Premier League, you know, and ultimately there's a huge upside there. You don't often get that kind of time, right?
30:24A big club where there's so much demand and so much attention but what what success for Pochettino this season it's probably finishing mid-table right next season it might be finishing in the top eight it feels like you're getting this kind of slow gradual kind of backing which you probably wouldn't get any other big club so yes you know the club is very much in crisis now but I think if he can kind of get it right slowly, then Pochettino will see a real opportunity here as well. Bit of a cliche, but how do you see it panning out? Like, let's just say we do a podcast in 18 months' time. What are we talking about? We're on Pochettino watch. You're lurking in Soho. He's gone back to Spurs. Listen, I think initially,
31:07I think Manchester United have too many good players to still be in the situation they're in. I do think keeping Carrick was a high-risk move. The force of uncertainty isn't changing, but the Premier League as it is now, as we saw with Tottenham last season, if you get into a slide, you can quite quickly end up in a relegation battle, a serious relegation battle, and that could have been the case I do think Man United with a coach like Pochettino who is good at instilling the fundamentals you know in terms of culture and team spirit I think quite quickly they should pull up the table whether or not they can then take that next step you know from becoming a sort of you know top eight team whatever it is a more stable
31:43European force, into then becoming what Manchester United fans want, which is becoming title challengers again and winning trophies. I think that will, further down the line, will rely on other things. That's what we're talking about, isn't it? The backing from the club, all the dynamics in the background being right. But I think in the first year or first 18 months, I think Pochettino has all the tools to turn this around and by the way I'm interested in Harry Kane because I mean we saw Harry Kane you know the England press comments the other day talking so highly of of Pochettino we know the connection there is is still really strong and and you know you're asking me about Pochettino perhaps going back to Spurs well
32:17if Man Utd pull up and Pochettino is doing well then that seems like a pretty a pretty obvious and open move for Kane if he ever wants to come back to the Premier League as well. Bring in a lovely slice of Spurs. Yeah. Get Spurs to come to you. Yeah, I think you're right. I think, you know, this is a team that finished third in the Premier League last season. And largely it's the same players. I know, minus Casemiro. That's it. And we're very early very early in the season so there's plenty of time to turn things around and if he were to get top eight top six which I don't I genuinely don't think is beyond the realms of possibility it's a tight league he'd be he will look at that and think this is a great opportunity
33:01I know I also think you know we talked earlier about players out of contract I think having Pochettino in now might change players minds this is a great opportunity. I also think, we talked earlier about players out of contract. I think having Pochettino in now might change players' minds. If it was still Carrick, they're being outspoken. They weren't necessarily happy. Pochettino's there, are more players staying? Yeah. Charming man. Very, very charming man. Loves his red wine. Also, in Qatar in 2022, Pochettino's working for the BBC as a pundit and I was staying in the same hotel as the pundits and it meant that I get to see Pochettino and the others but mainly Pochettino just in his swimming shorts
33:36wandering around the rooftop pool Why have you left it to him now to mention this? This is, I've got to tell you he's a very sexy man He just is. I don't think anyone's surprised. You dress it up any way you like. This is an attractive guy. I couldn't take my eyes off him. I had to go downstairs. I keep staring at Pochettino. Swam into the wall. You didn't need to hear that bit, Tom, particularly. Just before we go, PSR has just been sacked by Crystal Palace. He's only in charge for 16 games. That, again, like they were having a terrible, terrible time. The latest is that the clubs have been in talks with Thomas Frank. Is that something that you'd expect to be confirmed soon? Yeah, he looks like he's the leading contender to take over, doesn't he?
34:23And I think in a lot of ways it makes sense. You know, looking at Palace under Piersage and, you know, struggling with set pieces, struggling in defence to not concede soft goals. You know, there's a lot, you know, around Palace, isn't there? We know they've sold so many good players and so far I don't think they've really replaced them adequately. They've also been hit by injuries this season in terms of Mateta and Sarr. So, you know, they've got a lot of difficulties there. But I think Thomas Frank, although his reputation has definitely taken a hit in terms of whether or not he can do it with the big clubs, I still think, you know, this is one of the most kind of pedigreed managers in terms of the more middling Premier League teams. And if you want someone to go in and restore some stability,
35:06some defensive solidity, and, you know, improve the set piece element of the team, then I think he's the perfect man for the job. I would have loved it if they'd have come out and said, oh, we're appointing Michael Carrick. And then Michael goes, yeah, I've been chatting to him for about three weeks now. And everyone's like, what? You little scamp. Yeah, the talks were all taking place in Luxembourg thanks so much Tom appreciate your time cheers mate here is the latest by the way coming in at time of recording the move for Pochettino is being finalised and Manchester United are going to pay it looks like his 7 million pound release clause understood he'll arrive in Manchester to take training on either the 18th or
35:4619th of November, as Simon was saying, ahead of what is quite a big game against Liverpool. £7 million to the US team. I mean, it's a good job they suck those tea ladies now, isn't it? Yeah. All makes sense, actually, when you think about it. Poor old tea ladies. And I think, I mean, I just don't know why he signed well I do he's a clever man he signed a contract extension in August in August yeah he's a clever clever man yeah because let's be honest he knew and a sexy man but he knew a job was going to come in and he knew that a club would pay 7 million pounds and he gets to come back in the Premier League it's a good chunk of million and he gets to come back in the Premier League. It's a good chunk of money for the US to pump back into their system
36:30and we get to see the sexy man back in the Prem. Yeah. Do you think I've seen Thomas Frank topless? I'm going to say yeah. I haven't though. Okay. But I'd love to. Manchester United fans, we'd like to hear from you, obviously. Send us a voice note or a message. The number is 0800 no 08000 269 no 08000 289 369 should be in there now shouldn't it come on Thicko no podcast Thicko you called yourself a Thicko no podcast this Sunday it's the international break but you will be able to catch the commentator's view on Friday and then all the reaction to Spain against England on Sunday night. Don't you point at me. What are you going to do on Sunday without me? Don't you text you? Yeah, fine. That'd be cute, wouldn't it?
37:15Maybe a little FaceTime. Make sure you hit subscribe to the Football Daily wherever you're watching or listening. And turn on those sweet push notifications. This is something I do with my son. His feet on my hands when he's feeling a bit aggy, and you go push, and he pushes as hard as he can. It just takes a bit of energy out. Push. Yes, so I might start saying to him, turn on your push notifications. Does he have a smartphone? Not yet, no. He'll get that when he's 18. Thank you very much for listening or watching. For more than a decade, British boxing has been shaped by two men. Two completely different personalities. Two extraordinary careers. And one fight that just won't go away. There's never been a fight like this in the history of British boxing.
38:17Never. This is the story of how we got here. And how the AJ Fury rivalry redefined boxing forever. This will split the country. Half Fury fans, half AJ fans. Five Live Boxing, Fury v. Joshua. Listen on BBC Sounds. recover faster and feel healthier. Understand and optimize your sleep. Get coaching and insights for every age, stage, and cycle. Track over 140 habits. Get a 360 view of your training and workouts. Never miss a second of that with a wireless and waterproof charger. Expect all new features all the time. Grainger knows if you're a procurement manager at an industrial manufacturing facility, you're balancing inventory and budget while sourcing critical supplies across the operation.
39:17Too much inventory? Cost climb. Too little? Production slows. Grainger's $2 billion in on-hand inventory helps you get what you need when you need it, so you can help keep budgets balanced and lines moving. Call 1-800-GRAINGER, clickgrainger.com, or just stop by. Grainger, for the ones who get it done.



