Feel Better, Live More with Dr Rangan Chatterjee · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
Mo Gawdat makes a hard case that happiness is a choice, backed by the loss of his son and a striking thought experiment about painful memories.
Tap a chapter to play it from that moment in the show's own player; the transcript opens there too.
“I tend to say that the majority of unhappiness happens in your brain.” Mo Gawdat · at 13:49 — ▶ hear it from here
“Love, compassion, and gratitude. These are the three ingredients, okay?” Mo Gawdat · at 22:48 — ▶ hear it from here
Mo Gawdat argues that happiness is a choice, though not an absolute one: people can shift their baseline through learned skills, reframing and surrounding themselves with what helps. External circumstances do not settle it, since some people in hardship stay content while some with comfort stay miserable. He links his own unhappy years of chasing wealth in his late twenties to expectations he created himself, and contrasts them with the contentment he saw in Kolkata and Egypt among people who valued what little they had.
Gawdat speaks from experience: his son Ali died at 21 after medical errors during a routine operation. He says grief makes people feel targeted by life, yet no amount of misery brings a loved one back, and much of our unhappiness is replayed in the mind rather than caused by the event itself. He suggests that describing a loss as Ali lived, as well as Ali died, is equally true and more empowering. Everyday annoyances, such as a difficult manager or a traffic jam, can be reframed the same way, since most situations are neutral until a perspective gives them weight.
Host Rangan Chatterjee points out that holding a grudge, like checking the forecast for an ex's wedding, hurts only the person carrying it. Gawdat recalls an 'eraser test' he ran with roughly 20,000 students: nearly everyone would erase a painful memory, but 98% changed their minds once told the lessons and people it produced would vanish too. His answer to suffering is love, compassion and gratitude: love as the connecting force, compassion as action to ease others' pain, and gratitude as a way of seeing your own blessings so that life beats expectations.
Mo Gawdat is a best-selling author who spent a 30-year career in tech and now researches happiness. His son Ali died at 21 after medical errors during a routine operation.
Mo Gawdat says he taught a thought experiment he called the eraser test through his Solve for Happy sessions, with as many as about 20,000 students over several years. Participants first recalled their most painful memory, then were asked whether they would erase it.
“I did an experiment, a thought experiment I used to call the eraser test”Mo Gawdat · 18:19
Mo Gawdat says people will say his son Ali died, which is true, but he also says Ali lived, which he calls equally true and more empowering. He points out that Ali lived 21 years and has been gone for more than ten.
“people will say Ali died. That's a true statement, okay? But I also say Ali lived.”Mo Gawdat · 14:46
Mo Gawdat says he was the happiest person as a child growing up in Egypt, where nothing dented his happiness. He credits seeing misery and need all around him with reminding him how blessed he was.
“I mean, growing up in Egypt, happiest person ever.”Mo Gawdat · 7:52
Mo Gawdat argues that happiness is a choice, not a guarantee, and that most unhappiness happens in the mind rather than in the events themselves. He says grief can be held as a life that was lived as well as a life that was lost, using the death of his son Ali at 21.
Mo Gawdat says happiness is a choice, though not an absolute one. He argues people can raise their relative state of happiness through learned skills, reframing thoughts and surrounding themselves with what they need, even when life is hard. He says external circumstances do not decide happiness, because some people with hardship stay happy and some with comfort stay unhappy.
Mo Gawdat's son Ali died at 21 after medical errors during a routine operation, more than ten years before this conversation. Gawdat says grief makes people feel targeted by life, but misery does not bring a loved one back. He says Ali lived 21 years as well as died, and calls the time with him one of his biggest gifts.
Rangan Chatterjee picks up Mo Gawdat's example of being happy if it rains on an ex-girlfriend's wedding and says it shows someone still tied to the past. Gawdat agrees that holding a grudge only hurts the person holding it, and says the person they resent usually does not even know.
Mo Gawdat's eraser test asks people to recall their most painful memory, then imagines a technology that could erase the event from space-time. He says he ran the test with up to about 20,000 students over several years. Nearly everyone raised a hand to erase the memory, but 98% lowered their hands when told that everything that grew from the event would be erased too.
Mo Gawdat says a happy and contented life rests on love, compassion and gratitude. He describes love as the universal language that connects people, compassion as the action side that eases others' suffering, and gratitude as seeing your own blessings so that events beat your expectations.
Mo Gawdat suggests seeing an annoying manager as proof you have a job, a traffic jam as a sign that someone is waiting for you, and the flu as a sign you were healthy until you caught it. He says most situations are neutral at their core, and the perspective you take on them decides their impact.
Mo Gawdat says many millionaires and billionaires are deeply unhappy because the drive to achieve and prove themselves often comes from a sense of lack. He describes his own late twenties, when he chased wealth he did not need and felt frustrated whenever things did not go his way.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp to play the episode from there in the show's own player; the link button on a paragraph copies a link that opens this page there.
0:00Today's Bite Size episode is sponsored by The Way, the only meditation app with a single long-term pathway. Now, if you've tried other meditation apps before, I am certain that The Way will be the one that will finally help you develop a consistent practice. You see, one of the best things about it is that you are not going to get overwhelmed with different options. You simply open the app and do the next meditation, building up your practice step by step. After a few sessions, you will feel as if you've got your own personal meditation teacher, who of course is the wonderful Henry Shookman, who has appeared as a guest on this podcast on two separate occasions. Now, I personally have been using this app for over six months now, and I absolutely love it.
0:53In fact, I love it so much that I have invested in the company to join them in their mission to get more people meditating. For listeners of my podcast, The Way is offering 30 free days to establish your own meditation practice. All you have to do is go to thewayapp.com forward slash live more to get started. Welcome to Feel Better Live More Bite Size, your weekly dose of inspiration, insights, and practical ideas to help you live well and thrive. Each episode brings you some of my favorite moments, useful tools, and inspiring ideas from the many incredible conversations I've had on my podcast. Today's Bite Size is from episode 596 of the podcast with best-selling author Mo Gowdat. After a 30-year career in tech, Mo has made happiness his primary topic of research,
1:55diving deeply into literature and conversing on the topic with some of the wisest people in the world. In this clip, Mo shares some of his thoughts on happiness and how it may be possible to find peace even in difficult times. So you passionately believe that happiness is a choice. 100%. Not everyone shares that perspective. Yeah. Absolute happiness is not anyone's choice suffering is part of life by definition uh but choosing to be happier is 100% within your grasp everyone absolutely has the ability to uh to to learn a skill or to reframe a thought or to surround themselves by what they need to find a little bit of a happier life. That's absolutely no doubt. And so if you can change yourself from say minus one to minus
2:550.5 or from minus one to plus 0.5, then that by definition means you have a choice. And so that choice is not absolute, but it's definitely there when it comes to your relative state of happiness. The idea of absolute happiness versus becoming happier, I find really interesting. So let's go to an extreme scenario. I think you've touched on it already, this idea that let's say someone is living in incredible struggle and there are lots of things going on in their life outside of their control the natural belief that many people take from that is if those external circumstances changed i would be happier correct how does that sit alongside your perspective that happiness is a choice? So that's not always, that belief is not true because, you know, many people who don't have those circumstances are still unhappy.
3:56And many people who have those circumstances are happy. So you see, the idea is there is no inherent value of happiness in anything. You know, the joke I always make is that, you know, rain doesn't make you happy or unhappy. Honestly, rain depends on what you want from life. If it's, you know, if it's your ex's wedding, you'd like rain. Rain is a good idea, right? And so basically, the externalization of my happiness is because of what the world is giving me in an interesting way is a six year old behavior. It's basically giving up on your autonomy, on your agency, in your own happiness by saying, you see, you know, life is giving me lemons again. And the idea here is that, as I said, you know, again, to have the proper empathy,
4:49there are people in the world where it actually is very difficult to be happy. It's, you know, they've lost, you know, they've lost their family or they're in a war zone or they're, you know, going through a very difficult breakup or, you know, there could be reasons, you know, they have chronic pain or some kind of a chronic illness or, you know, there could be reasons, you know, they have chronic pain or some kind of a chronic illness or, you know, you and I have experienced working with people in those states in our work. And yeah, it becomes difficult to find happiness. It even becomes difficult to find happier, you know, states at that time. But truth is, most of the time for those who choose to blame
5:30life for their unhappiness, whatever life would give them, they'll find something to blame. You see, the idea is, as I always try to teach, that is happiness is a difference, the difference between the events of your life and your expectations of how life should be. And so, interestingly, you go to some of the places where the best quality of life exists, you know, where the subjective well-being is very high and you'll still see very high suicide rates. Reason being, you know, when your government gives you health care and gives you unemployment payments and they fair, you know, payments and they'll take care of your every need somehow, somehow in our, um, always ambitious minds, let's call them,
6:14you know, your mind will go like, okay, so if the government can do all of this, why is my girlfriend still annoying? You know, like where's, where's my service level agreement? I signed a service level agreement that the world is always going to give me everything I need to find happiness. And if the world fails, then I'll be unhappy. And the question is, where's that agreement? Show it to me. I mean, I completely agree with your perspective that happiness is a choice. It's a skill that we can cultivate once we know how to do it. And I wonder how much your upbringing in Egypt influences your perspective here. And the reason I ask that is because I was born and brought up in the UK, but my parents were immigrants from India.
7:01And you can see the difference. You can see the difference. And every other summer, we would go for the entire school, British summer holidays, to Kolkata in India. And I often reflect back to those days now and go, wow, I would repeatedly meet and see people in what we would regard here in the West as poverty. But their whole sense of being was light. There was a contentment. There was a happiness. And as you said before, and as I said before, there are so many millionaires, multi-millionaires, billionaires who are deeply unhappy. Miserable. More often than not, actually. Exactly. Because often the drive to go out there and achieve and show the world that you were something that came from a place of lack. Yeah.
7:52That was the story of my life. I mean, growing up in Egypt, happiest person ever. I remember vividly, you know, I would, nothing would dent my happiness. It's, you know, in those societies, you get two very beneficial happiness advantages. One is that you see misery all around you. You see suffering all around you. You see lack and need all around you. So it reminds you of how blessed you are, right? The reality is if your expectations are, I may not be able to eat today. You know, if someone gives you a bowl of rice, you're very, very happy. And that I think is the reality of a place like India. You know, people value what they get. They don't feel disgruntled about what they didn't get because they can easily see, you know,
8:38in my first book, Soul for Happy, I basically call this looking down. And the idea is that, of course, if you look up at, you know, all of the, of the Ferraris in Mayfair, you'd say that you'd think that life is unfair to you. But if you look down to people in war zones, or people who are starving, suddenly you realize, holy, I mean, like, I didn't contribute to that. I would, I could have been born there myself. Yeah. Right. And somehow that reminder really creates a sense of realism in you. Okay? Then I, you know, I became very successful. And I remember in my late 20s when I was so focused on collecting so much wealth that I didn't need. And, you know, feeling frustrated when things didn't go my way.
9:24And, you know, feeling anxious when my daughter interrupted my time, uh, when I was focused on a silly email or a, or a stock chart, you know, these were created by me, not by life. Okay. And the, and the misery was, was my work. It was, you know, life was giving me more and more and more and more. And I was constantly disgruntled with why is it not perfect? Again, the service level agreement. But you see, the other interesting thing is when you deeply, deeply look at life, you need your basic needs and love. Okay. And if you get your basic needs and love, it's not difficult to work on your mind to get into a state of happiness. Okay. If, you know, of course, there are many people that have their basic needs and love, but don't work on their mind.
10:17And so they never find happiness. But I'd ask everyone who has those two in their life to really think deeply about how blessed they are. You know, whether it's feeling loved, which in my view is a state of ego, if you think about it, but most importantly is being able to love, is being able to look at someone and go like, I am my divinity, that part of me is capable of feeling the connection to that other being. And I think that in itself is sufficient, if you ask me. Anthony DiMello writes in Awareness that if you're not feeling happy right now, you're doing something to make yourself unhappy. And I remember the first time I read that, I underlined it and I keep going back to it. And I use it a lot because, you know, we're all human and we can all fall into certain emotional traps
11:16from time to time. And if I'm ever feeling, which is very rare now, this state of discontentment, I ask myself, Rangan, what are you doing that's making you feel this way? What perspective are you taking on life here? You know, what emotions are you ignoring? And what I like about this approach, which I totally agree with, is that it's very empowering. Because then, if happiness is a choice choice that instead of us being a victim to the world and events outside of our control we're suddenly the architects of our lives we're suddenly like oh actually there is something i can do here now why you saying this has particular value for people who've never come across you before your son ali died after significant series of medical errors during a routine operation.
12:07How old was he? 21. He was 21 years old. So I think when someone like you having been through that says happiness is a choice, I think it lands differently. Yeah. And I don't know how to say this, but a lot of people think that when you're a grieving father, you have no choice because it seems that the only, uh, plausible choice is to just, you know, put your head down and, and wait to die. Honestly. I mean, in an interesting way, grief is quite a tricky one because you feel deceived by life. You see, you feel that life targeted you personally. You feel that, you know, uh, life is never going to be the same. You, you lose the point, uh, you know, of like, so what, what now you, so many feel, many feel that
12:58it's a bit of, believe it or not, of, um, of betraying the one they love if they can actually find happiness after them and and there are so many complexities that happen to us in grief uh interestingly though we don't have one choice you know i i could have you know hit my head against the wall in in misery until the day i am on my deathbed or I could choose to be a little happier every day, either way, Ali wouldn't come back. You see, this is what most people don't recognize, is that all of the misery in the world has no impact, zero impact whatsoever on the external world, right? And it really is quite interesting because when you were talking, you know, about unhappiness being our own doing, if you want,
13:49I tend to say that the majority of unhappiness happens in your brain. Okay. That all of the other joyful emotions can happen all over you. They can happen in your body. They can happen in your heart. They can happen in your spirit. They can happen in your brain. But for you to feel unhappy, think about it. Ali left us now more than 10 years ago. The pain of the moment when he was on his operating table, leaving us is probably the biggest pain I ever felt. The moment after they told us that he left was the lowest moment of my life. But think about this Rangan, those moments happened in the past. Okay. When I walked into an inn here and hugged you, an old friend, and we haven't met for a while and we caught up. I didn't think of those moments.
14:46And so interestingly, they didn't exist. So you see the problem, the problem with us humans is that we grant unhappiness the right to exist within our minds. We fuel those thoughts and then we let them torture us. And they wouldn't bring Ali back. Do you understand that? Okay. So where's the wisdom in this? Where's the wisdom in me finding the most painful moment in my life, then bring it up, bringing it up in my head again and saying, okay, let me play that scene again and torture myself. How smart is that, right? The opposite is interestingly true because, you know, people will say Ali died. That's a true statement, okay? But I also say Ali lived. Equally true, as a matter of fact, more true
15:41because Ali lived 21 years and left for 10. Okay. When you really, really think about it, Ali lived is the same fabric of the thought. To die, you have to live and to live, you have to die. But it's interesting because Ali lived is such an empowering thought. Okay. First of all, Ali was not planned. We didn't plan to have Ali, okay? And then we get this gift, an unbelievable blessing that comes into your life, teaches you, shows you love. We laughed so much together. We played so much together. You know, we learned so much together. He, you know, he's one of the biggest gifts. Ali and Aya, by definition, are my biggest gifts in life. My daughter, Aya. And then, you know, the human mind would take all of that and say, no, I'm upset. You know, why did he leave?
16:33And I'm like, he left because he came. Now think of the, you know, of the scenario where God or the universe or whatever you want to believe in, decided to not bring him to your life in the first place. You look at it now and you go like, hmm, you know, if it happened during life and you didn't notice it, you would have never missed him. It would have felt that life has never taken anything away from you, okay? But the truth is also life would have never given you the blessing at the same time. Now, but you look at it now and you go like, oh my God, you know, I would absolutely take the pain a thousand times more to take the blessing of having him in my life for 21 years. Right. And, and if only we start to see those
17:26things, okay. If only we start to see that, you know, I'll use simple examples. So it's not too dramatic. If only we start to see our annoying manager as an indication that I have a job. Okay. If only we start to see being stuck in traffic, that I'm going somewhere and someone's waiting for me. If only we see the flu that you suffer as an indication that you've been healthy until you got the flu. And all of these, you know where they exist. They exist here. The outside event is exactly the same. Yeah. It's such an empowering message because we actually have a huge amount of control over where we put our thoughts, how we frame every single situation. And it's, I would say one of the most important and one of the most beneficial skills in life
18:19is to understand at a deep level that all, you could definitely say most situations are at their core neutral. It's the perspective we take on that situation that really determines its impact on us. I'd go even further, Rangan. I mean, I did an experiment, a thought experiment I used to call the eraser test, where I told people take the most painful memory in your life. Okay. And I used to teach solve for happy to people in person. So I had probably up to maybe 20,000 students or so in, you know, over multiple years. And I would tell them, take that situation, the most painful in your life, you know, bring it up into your mind. Now you feel it again as if you're in it, even though it passed, right? Feel the pain, torture yourself, make yourself feel miserable.
19:10And of course, the minute I said that everyone was like, yeah, celebration, let me torture myself. And someone would think about that bully in school, the other would think about that boyfriend that cheated or whatever. Okay. And some would think about very painful situations. Then I tell them that we've invented a technology that has the ability not to erase it from your memory, but to erase that event from space time. So completely remove it. Okay. And I would ask people, how many of you would choose to erase it? Everyone would raise their hand. Okay. And then I would say, but the only problem is that if we erase it, we will erase everything that happens as a result. That friend that you met, that lesson that you learned, that whatever, anything that happened
19:56as a result of that event will be erased in the process. Okay. Who would still want to go through the experiment? 98% would put their hands down. Okay. And the reason is very interestingly, any suffering that you went through in life is what made you the person that you are. Okay. And unless you really, really dislike the person that you are, okay, then you're grateful for all the pain that you went through. And it's quite interesting because you always look back at those events and you go like, it was very painful then, but it's actually wonderful now, right? And then if you see this and you see it with clarity, you know what, you should ask yourself, so why am I so upset about this event now?
20:42You know, that one that's hurting me now is going to be wonderful then. Yeah. Right. I just have to accept that the only way that we progress to enlightenment in life is to suffer. I have to accept that. And if I can accept that, okay, then suffering doesn't become suffering anymore. Suffering becomes part of the video game yeah life school yeah you know yeah in a work school whatever you want to call it um we did cover this concept of happiness being a choice in detail on our first conversation but let me just tie a loop in something you said right at the start when you were explaining this idea that happiness is a choice you brought up the rain and saying I apologize for Britain but yes it's a relevant example here if it's your ex-girlfriend's wedding
21:34you're happy yeah and I think you were saying that to sort of illustrate the point that the rain is neutral it depends what it signifies and what perspective you're taking on it but if we just go back to that for a minute if you're happy that it's raining on your ex-girlfriend's wedding day... You need to do some work. You need to do some work. You're being tied in your mind to the past. You have no idea how many times I said that example. You're the first one that picks that up. Absolutely. It's, you know, you know what? You're holding on to something. You're being tied to it. You haven't moved on. You haven't let go. And you know who's suffering. You, not her. She doesn't even know that you're suffering.
22:11The fact that you're even checking the weather forecast on her wedding day, that's a problem. Exactly. It's quite interesting that, you know, holding on to a grudge only hurts you. Yeah. Never hurts the other person. I don't remember, was it Nelson Mandela or Gandhi, one of the two, who basically said it's like drinking poison and hoping the other person would die. Yeah. It's not very clever when you really think about it. Just forgive, accept that life comes with stories and benefits and just enjoy that you've moved to another experience. You've got such a wealth of experience and knowledge about the human experience and just enjoy that you've moved to another experience. You've got such a wealth of experience and knowledge
22:48about the human experience and what are the ingredients to live a happy and contented life. For someone who has been listening to us talk and has realized that they're not as happy as they could be, what would you say to them? Love, compassion, and gratitude. These are the three ingredients, okay? Anyone who manages to find those in their life will be fine. So love is clear. Love is the only universal language that we speak to, that we use to speak to each other outside our physical form. Okay. Compassion is the only, so that's the feminine side, believe it or not, the being side of us. The pure feminine is that ability to feel for someone, okay, to be in a state of connecting to someone. Compassion is the action side of it.
23:48It's the masculine side of who we are. Okay. So if we look at the rest of us, of humanity, the only way to deal with humanity, if you ask me, is love on the feminine and compassion on the masculine to make a change to alleviate the pain and the suffering of others. That's compassion. Okay. And gratitude is your way of looking at yourself. It is your way of actually seeing your gifts, of actually seeing your blessings so that your happiness equation is fixed, not just because events are meeting expectations, but that events are beating expectations so much that you're grateful for them. Okay. And you settle in a state of you're grateful for them. Okay. And you settle in a state of it's all okay. Yeah. It's never going to be perfect. It's never going to be
24:32perfect, but it's so cool to be part of this game. I really hope you enjoyed this week's Bite Size. Do spread the love by sharing this episode with your friends and family. And if you want more, why don't you go back and listen to the original full conversation with my guest. I hope you have a wonderful weekend. Make sure you have pressed subscribe. And I'll be back next week with my new conversation on Wednesday and the latest episode of Bite Size next Friday.





