Call Me Back - with Dan Senor · · Transcript & summary by WhipScribe
Summary, chapters and key takeaways for this episode are on their way; the transcript below is complete.
Our own transcript of the public episode, with a timestamp about every 90 seconds. Tap a timestamp or the link button on a paragraph to copy a link that opens this page there.
0:00ARC Media is funded in large part by our ARC Plus members. They allow us to cover Israel and the Jewish world honestly, without compromise. When you join ARC Plus, you support our mission and get access to exclusive content as well as ad-free listening across all ARC Media podcasts. Join us at arcmedia.org. And to our members, thank you. You are listening to an Art Media Podcast. Without an agreement that we need to be sold the things that we need, there could be a real risk to Israel's security in the region. Now, it's not about arms. It's about the signal it sends through the region. And the signal it's going to send through the region. Now, it's not about arms. It's about the signal it sends through the region.
0:46And the signal it's going to send through the region, if these things begin to stop, if the president doesn't veto, if the next president uplifts a veto, is Israel is on its own. The region is going to go, oh, wow, you know, the Americans are not with the Israelis. This changes our peace treaty with Egypt. This changes our relationship with the UAE. Forces in the Middle East like Hezbollah and Hamas and Tehran that are saying, maybe we can actually destroy them now that the Americans are not with them. And this is what the defense establishment in Israel fears. Over the last three weeks, there are so many Democrats I've heard from who were eagerly awaiting the results of the Israeli election. They wanted to understand what was going on,
1:29and they are just hoping and praying for a different government, not because they want a new punching bag, because they want to be able to get back to a more positive spot. And you got to give them something to work with, which is why if these changes don't happen with a new government and with different policies, then yeah, the, the Mehdi Hassan position is going to start becoming more and more mainstream. It's 6.30 p.m. on Sunday, November 14th here in New York City. It's 1.30 a.m. on Monday, November 15th in Israel as Israelis transition to a new day. A quick housekeeping note before we get started. Last year, I participated in a fundraising auction for the Jewish Food Society, a terrific organization
2:25that's close to my heart and to my taste buds. For those of you who aren't familiar with it, the Jewish Food Society uses food as a gateway into Jewish history, identity, and culture. Through our culinary traditions from around the world, they help tell the story of the Jewish people, where we've lived, how we've lived, and what we've carried with us from one generation to the next. So one of Jewish Food Society's auction items is breakfast with yours truly. And another auction item is breakfast with ARK Media contributor Nadav Ayal. Last year, I ended up having a wonderful lunch with the winning bidder, and we covered everything from the origins of Call Me Back to Israeli politics and what's happening in Jewish communities around the world. If this year is anything like last year,
3:10there might be a betting pool going on among the ARC staff over who, me or Nadav, will raise more funds through our respective auctions for the Jewish Food Society. I won't tell you which way the odds are leaning, but let's just say I have a lot riding on this, mostly my dignity. So if you want a chance to sit down with me or Nadav, ask us anything you want and enjoy a great meal while supporting a wonderful cause, please follow the link in the show notes and place your bid. The auction opens today. Now on to today's episode. Twelve days ago, the American electorate delivered a political earthquake for the Democratic Party, really nationally, in which the Democrats won midterm elections by a landslide,
3:52taking back both houses of Congress. The final tally, Democrats have secured at least 256 seats in the House, compared with 169 seats for the Republicans, and 55 seats in the Senate, compared with 169 seats for the Republicans, and 55 seats in the Senate, compared with 44 for the Republicans. They've also flipped six governorships, giving them control of the governorships in 30 states, including some that are very important for the Electoral College in the presidential election. For Israel, this election comes at an extraordinarily difficult moment in its relationship with America. After three years of war, the political consensus that sustained the U.S.-Israel relationship for decades looks at least increasingly fragile. And now,
4:37for the first time in Trump's second term, Democrats have real power in Washington. So what are they going to do with it? How much of what we're hearing from Democrats is campaign rhetoric, not to be actually implemented into policy, and how much will actually translate into real policy? More fundamentally, is Israel facing a temporary backlash or a lasting transformation of the relationship with its most important ally? To understand what the blue wave means for Israel, I'm joined by ARK media contributor Nadav Ayel, who has been doing a lot of reporting on how the Israeli security establishment is interpreting these political developments in Washington, and by Michael Koplow of the Israel Policy Forum. My conversation with Nadav and Michael
5:22right after this short message. This is the moment to send young Jewish adults on a birthright trip to Israel. Not next year, now. Because after three years of misinformation, reality needs to speak for itself. Over the past 25 years, Birthright has sent more than 900,000 young Jews to Israel. They come back more confident, more connected to each other and to Israel. They go on to build Jewish families, lead our communities, and feel part of a 4,000-year Jewish history that belongs to them. Birthright's new goal is to send another 200,000 young adults to Israel by 2029, but it takes people like you to make that happen. To help shape that future, go to OneTripChangesEverything.com. I'm Debra Pardes, the host of ARC News Daily. What's happening in Israel and the Jewish world
6:23right now matters. But it can be hard to keep up, let alone make sense of it all. That's happening in Israel and the Jewish world right now matters, but it can be hard to keep up, let alone make sense of it all. That's why we started ARC News Daily. Every weekday morning, I walk you through the most important news, give you the context you need, and let you know what to look out for next. I don't try to convince you of anything, and I don't waste your time. On most days, I'll be in your ears for about 10 minutes or less. Then you can move on with your day, hopefully a little bit smarter than before. Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts or follow the link in the show notes. I hope to see you tomorrow.
7:01And we're back with Nadav Ayal and Michael Koplow. Gentlemen, thanks for being here. Thanks for having us, Dan. And as to your dignity, I just want to say that I just won last year. Is that true? Yes. The difference was substantial. I did not expect it. And I do not expect it this year. Did you win with a popular vote? I won by a lot of money that goes to charity. So that's what I care about. And Dan, this year, I expect you to do much better. You know, this is your show. You're right. Okay, so please take note to our Call Me Back listeners. You are on notice. Please don't leave me hanging here looking as pathetic as, according to Nadav, I looked last year. And with that, Nadav, I'm not gonna give you the first question.
7:45I was going to, but now I'm not. After that swipe at me, I'll go to Michael, all right? So Michael, jumping into this conversation, the Democratic Party as a whole, as I mentioned, won in a landslide. But I think there's a tendency in a lot of places, especially outside the United States and especially inside Israel, to view the Democratic Party as a monolith. And it really isn't. So if you had to break it down into groups, just in simple terms, based on attitudes towards Israel, how should we understand the different factions and how influential each one of those is in this new, very large caucus that is taking over in the House and the one taking over in the Senate? I agree with you. It's definitely not a monolith. And I think we have three distinct groups. The first group, and this is the smallest group,
8:29but it's also the one that tends to get a lot of attention. And I think arguably in Israel, the one that gets the most attention is the group of DSA or DSA adjacent members of Congress. So if you were in Israel, you would have thought that the election a couple of weeks ago was about Abdul Al-Sayed and nobody else. But that group is a pretty small group and they are loud and they're going to have an impact on the discourse. But in terms of what actually happens with regard to congressional policy, I think they're going to be pretty isolated. You basically, after them, have two groups of, I think, probably relatively equal size, although we'll have to see as things proceed in Congress. One group is a group of progressives. And they, for a variety
9:19of reasons, are very upset with the Israeli government. Some of it has to do with Prime Minister Netanyahu. Much of it has to do with Israeli policy. And I think the distinction between this group and the DSA-aligned group is that for the DSA folks, the problem has nothing to do with Israeli policy. The problem is Israel as a Jewish state. For the progressives, that's not the issue. You have folks who are pretty hardline on this Israeli government in the progressive camp, but they will tell you that they support Israel as a Jewish state, that they support a two-state outcome to the conflict. And that's different from the DSA group. Then you have another large group of moderate mainstream Democrats, and they have
10:07many of the same problems that the progressives do. They certainly have their issues with Prime Minister Netanyahu. They also have their issues with Israeli policy. But I think that group is willing to give a new Israeli government a bit more leeway. And that group is eagerly trying to figure out how the party can get back to a more pro-Israel position. So you definitely have distinctions between these groups. And I think that a lot of what happens next will be determined by the interplay between the mainstreams and the progressives. And to some extent, it will be an argument within the progressive camp itself over how much leeway a new Israeli government might get. And to some extent, it will be an argument within the progressive camp itself
10:45over how much leeway a new Israeli government might get. And I should note that if there isn't a new Israeli government, then frankly, a lot of these distinctions are going to collapse. Because if you have a Netanyahu government that keeps on governing Israel, particularly if it's a coalition that looks like the one that has governed for the past four years. There's going to be a lot of anger on the Democratic side. And talking about different groups and gradations, I think, won't make nearly as much of a difference. OK, before I bring it up and just to get a little granular here this week, when our listeners are listening to this episode, there'll be a lot of news about this showdown in the Senate among Senate Democrats between Senator Chuck Schumer and Senator Chris Van Hollen. So this
11:29really gets to the crux of what you are talking about. So I want to I want to give it very concrete. I want to put it in very concrete terms so people, when they're watching the news, can visualize exactly what you're talking about. So Chuck Schumer is the incumbent leader of the Democrats. He was the Senate minority leader. Now he's expected to be the Senate majority leader because the Democrats are taking over the Senate with such a big majority. And yet he's being challenged by Chris Van Hollen, another Democratic senator who is arguing that he should be the Senate majority leader. And I don't know what the numbers are. You're probably keeping track of this more closely than I am. But he definitely has some support, Van Hollen.
12:06And my understanding is one of the dividing issues between Van Hollen and Schumer in terms of who will determine the leader of the Democrats in the Senate is US policy towards Israel. So A, I guess, what is your reaction to that point? And B, where do you put a guy like Van Hollen in your different, because he's someone people are going to be, you're going to listen to this episode and people are going to see Van Hollen all through the week in the news. So where does Van Hollen fit into your, into your map that you just laid out for us? I think your distinction is great. It does illustrate the difference between these groups. And Van Hollen is somebody who is in that progressive camp. I think that he's probably towards the left side of that progressive camp. But the difference between Van Hollen and someone like Senator-elect al-Sayed is that
12:49Van Hollen would tell you that he unambiguously supports two states. Now, his view of how you get to two states is largely through pressure on Israel through a variety of measures, whether it's recognizing a Palestinian state outside of the context of negotiations, or whether it's enacting sanctions on Israel over settlement policy, or whether it is all sorts of limitations on what arms can be sold to Israel. But Van Hollen is different from the folks in the DSA camp. So Van Hollen is definitely in that progressive camp. And as I said, I think on the left side of it, Schumer is definitely in that mainstream camp. Okay, Nadav, you have been talking both to senior officials, advisors in the Democratic Party and Congress, including moderates.
13:39I think some of the moderates that Michael was just describing who are signaling at least what they think is in store for the U.S.-Israel relationship and the new Congress. I guess my first question without revealing names, what they're telling you off the record. And then you're also talking, as I mentioned, to officials in Israel's security establishment and its political establishment. How prepared are they for what Michael is describing here and also what you're hearing? So what I'm hearing from people who worked for U.S. American Democratic administrations is that any sort of strategic warning in Israel is actually understating the peril to the relationship and to the alliance between the countries.
14:20You know, any wording that I use in my articles, they go, you're still understating what's happening. What they're saying is, to put it plainly, is that this new Congress can actually make the grounds for a possible Democrat in the White House going into office in 2029 to change the relationship in ways that we have not seen before. But what they're mainly saying, Dan, is that the Israelis don't have any time. They need to start mitigating, negotiating, diluting, explaining, getting to some kind of understanding with Democrats right now, because things are going to go down. Things like, you know, a report as to human rights violations in the West Bank, you know, voting in the House as to budgeting and funding issues.
15:14And of course, as long as the president is Donald Trump, this could be vetoed, not signed into law, etc., etc. But what they're saying is that this is exactly the trap. That if Israel goes down the route or the people who support Israel go down that route, saying it's all with the White House right now, trusting the White House on this, Israel has already lost and the alliance is already crumbling down because if a Democrat is going to be elected in 2028, all these vetoes are going to be off the table in a matter of a day. What I'm hearing, and I'm turning now to the Israelis, is a lot of pressure. I don't want to say panic. But before you get to that, Nadav, I just want to be clear so our listeners understand. So what you're basically saying is there could be all sorts of legislative proposals put forward over the next two years.
16:07But A, unless Donald Trump signs them into law, they're not going to be signed into law over the next two years, A. And B, if the Republicans filibuster it, which they likely would if it's very aggressive towards Israel, the Democrats won't have the votes to override the filibuster, which is all a long-winded way of saying it's unlikely even the most worrisome measures that could be advanced, they actually couldn't come into law most likely over the next two years. But you're saying that it doesn't matter because the ground is shifting beneath the feet of policymakers in Israel and they need to wake up as to what's coming. If it's not coming the next two years, it could be coming after. Yeah, I want to be specific about this. I take your point, for instance, on the veto,
16:48but they don't need an embargo to hurt Israel right now. Democrats hold the purse. And cutting Israel off doesn't take a new law. It takes a decision not to fund it. Now, Trump has already said that aid is ending. But when he needs Democratic votes for the defense budget or for Iran war money or anything else, Israel could be the cheapest thing he can trade away. And I'm not saying this because I don't trust President Trump's alliance with Israel. I'm just saying it's going to be another chip in the negotiations with Democrats and it's going to be important for some of them at least. Now, on top of that, a Democratic Senate can, for instance, force a 502B human rights report on Israel with a simple majority, and there's no veto.
17:35West Bank Violence Prevention Act. This was something that I think Nadler, and Michael can correct me if I'm wrong, I think it's a Nadler-Kuhns bill. So it's not a squad bill. And it makes sanctions mandatory on violent settlers and officials who turn a blind eye to that and institutions in Israel. And it can absolutely go to the president. And again, a budget deal. So we can go through these goalposts, but they all are quite dark. And I know that there is a tendency to say, oh, now you have less hardline progressives because it's such a huge majority. So this is the analysis that is being sold to some in Israel. Because they have such a huge majority, they won't need to negotiate and compromise with
18:24their hardliners towards Israel. I accept some of that. But what I'm hearing from Democrats is that people who say that don't understand the music. And the tune is exactly what Michael said. The tune is, if this government doesn't change, if it's the same government, the mainstream Democratic Party is going to be very close to the most hardline rhetoric that we have heard in recent years. And I'm happy to stop here and let Michael react to that because I'm sure he knows better than me as to this. Michael? So I think that what Nadav highlighted is important because there are issues that cut across all of these groups that Democrats are angry about, no matter which of these democratic camps they fall into.
19:12And, you know, one of the ways in which you see this is by looking at the people who are bringing up some of these bills and some of these issues. So Nadav, for instance, highlighted the West Bank Violence Prevention Act, which is targeted at extremist Jewish violence in the West Bank. That's a bill that was championed by Representative Nadler, who's not going to be the next Congress, but I think by any measure is and was a pro-Israel congressman, and Chris Coons, who is also seen as somebody who is a pro-Israel Democrat. An issue like that is something that the Israeli government has to address immediately because that's an issue that unites all Democrats, whether they're moderate, progressive, or
19:55part of the DSA group. Something like not building in E1. That's another bill that was introduced by Chris Coons. Explain what E1 is. E1 is an area that has been a red line for U.S. administrations now dating back 30 years. It's a strip of land in between Jerusalem and Ma'al Adumim. And the theory is that if you build in E1... If you build settlements there. Correct. If you build settlements in E1 because of the geography there, anybody who's driven from Jerusalem down to the Dead Sea knows that it drops basically, right? When you get past Ma'al Adumim, the idea is that if you build that, it bifurcates the West Bank and makes a future Palestinian state far more difficult because you no longer really have
20:42territorial continuity. And so U.S. administrations of both parties have put E1 as a red line for really 30 years. This Israeli government is pretty determined to build there, and they started the process of issuing tenders. It was temporarily stopped by Israel's attorney general, but in an effort to make sure that it really remains stopped, Chris Coons introduced a bill in the Senate that would enact sanctions on any Israeli or any Israeli entity that participates in construction or financing in E1. Something like that is, again, an issue that really unites all Democrats versus a bill that was introduced in the House by Representative Castro, who's definitely in the progressive camp, that would enact mandatory sanctions on Israel if anything is built
21:32anywhere in the West Bank. Now, a bill like that is not going to attract all Democrats. And so that's not the sort of legislation that in this Congress Israel has to worry about. But something like building an E1 or preventing settler violence or improving the humanitarian situation in Gaza, these are things that all Democrats want to see happen and are really gonna demand of an Israeli government that they do happen. So I think that Nadav is right. The Israelis that I speak with, and I was in Israel last week, they don't quite understand the dynamics here in the United States, and they should be paying attention to who is pushing different things, because that will give them a real key as to what they need to address ASAP.
22:17Okay. I guess the most important decision maker here is Hakeem Jeffries, congressman from New York City, from New York State, speaker elect, likely to be the next speaker of the House, the leader of the Democrats. My understanding, and Michael, you would know this better than I do, my understanding is the one bill that is tough on Israel is this bill that he would let advance, that the reality is all these other bills on a range of issues are unlikely to get past Speaker Jeffries. And Speaker Jeffries is the one who ultimately decides for a variety of reasons that we won't get into now, just in terms of how, you know, the sausage making of legislating works and what bills actually get to the floor and
22:54what get voted on the floor. And he can really control the levers. And so the settler violence bill or the building in E1, however you want to, that's the one that you think he's most likely to let advance. Yeah. And we'll have to see because Representative Nadler is no longer in Congress. We'll see who picks up the settler violence bill, but I have no doubt that somebody else will pick it up. I think for Democrats in Congress, in many ways, that is both the lowest hanging fruit and the thing that has them the most upset, because something like settler violence, there's really no argument. And so, you know, I think when a lot of members of Congress see that, pretty much all Democrats and a lot of Republicans too,
23:35and also Ambassador Huckabee, you know, they see this and it's like waving a red flag in front of a bull. And so that's the sort of thing that will have wall-to-wall democratic support, and an Israeli government's going to have to address it. Nadav, to what extent, based on, and I know you were just having a number of these conversations in Israel, to what extent are some saying, at least in the political echelon, look, this new Congress isn't going to come into power until January 3rd. So we've got a couple months. There may be a new Israeli government by then. And this new Israeli government can look a lot different than this government. And this new government could include factions that would have zero tolerance for what we've seen in the West
24:14Bank that this that the Nadler-Kuhn's bill is responding to. Does that give any of the Israeli policymakers and political figures and security types a sense of like, it's going to be okay. We're likely going to get a new government. There's going to be new characters. The likelihood that a Ben-Gvir and Smoltrich are going to be in a new government, certainly the likelihood that Ben-Gvir is going to be running the police and have this national security role is very low. So we're going to be okay. No, I'm not hearing we're going to be okay at all from the Israelis. It's split between those who understand they're mostly on the defense establishment and they see how vital are the next few months to Israel's security and to its place in the region. And the
25:00rest don't understand the severity of the situation at all in the United States. And they definitely don't address it. I can tell you that there was one cabinet meeting that addressed the relationship with the United States post the blue wave in the United States. I don't think that the prime minister, I'm sure he spoke with people about that, but there was no kind of formal approach or strategy of how to deal right now with what has happened in the U.S., which I think we all agree in this conversation is detrimental for the or could be detrimental for the alliance between the countries. Basically, even if you speak with opposition figures, Dan, frankly, they just think that if there's going to be a change of government, this is going to go away, as you basically said.
25:45And from what I know, it's definitely not going to go away. And the bare minimum I'm hearing from people who understand the party right now, the Democratic Party, the bare minimum is very far from what even the Israeli opposition is talking about. And of course, if Netanyahu remains in power, then as Michael said, all bets are off. And there's going to be a unity there between progressives or more radical voices and between mainstream. Now, as to the defense establishment, they are saying that Israel has two main security or strategic assets. The first in terms of security is, of course, the IDF and the entire defense establishment and the Air Force. And the second one is the alliance with the United States. And the alliance
26:29is under risk and without an active and robust relationship, which includes, for instance, the sale of arms, something that many Democrats, including from the sort of middle of the road or very important figures in the party today, like James Tallarico from Texas, who is saying, I'm against selling offensive arms to Israel. And nobody knows exactly what this means, Dan, because our F-35s, F-16Is, you know, they're both offensive, but you really need them in order to defend the country, in order to have deterrence in the region. If this actually sounds a bit, and again, Michael can correct me if I'm wrong, as we're not going to sell arms at all to the Israelis. And again, I don't know if he's serious
27:16about that, but he does seem to be a serious figure now in the party, maybe more than Abdullah al-Sayed from Michigan. Now, the Israelis are hearing that from within the defense establishment, and some of them are in a panic mode. There's no easy way to say that because they're saying, look, you know, without an agreement that we need to be sold the things that we need, there could be a real risk to Israel's security in the region. Now, it's not about arms, Dan, and I think it's a point you made. It's about the signal it sends through the region. And the signal it's going to send through the region, if these things begin to stop, if the president doesn't veto, if the next president uplifts a veto, is Israel is on its own. Even if we have the spare parts we need for these F-35 for the next 10 years,
28:06the region is going to go, oh, wow, you know, the Americans are not with Israelis. This changes our peace treaty with Egypt. This changes our relationship with the UAE. Forces in the Middle East like Hezbollah and Hamas and Tehran that are saying, maybe we can actually destroy them now that the Americans are not with them. And this is what the defense establishment in Israel fears. Not only the spare parts tactically, but the messaging, the signaling that will come, which will lead to instability and maybe a wider war in an attempt to actually eradicate Israel. They are very worried for the fate of the alliance. We'll be right back, right after this short message. Hi, it's Gabe Silverstein from the ARK Media team. You may know me from Research by Gabe
28:55Silverstein. Last summer, I participated in a Birthright trip, so I can tell you exactly what they mean when they say one trip changes everything. Birthright didn't just connect me with my Israeli brothers and sisters in a spiritual and lasting way. Birthright gave me a deeper understanding of what it means to be a Jew and where I fit into the Jewish story. It's incredible to me that this organization exists, and I know that behind every one of these trips are generous people who made it happen, people like you. Birthright Israel's goal is to inspire and empower a new generation of Jewish young adults. To help make that happen and to create more life-changing experiences like mine, please visit onetripchangeseverything.com. Birthright,
29:37one trip changes everything. At Arch Media, we're not sponsored by a government, nor are we an advocacy group. We are only accountable to our listeners. That means we're free to cover Israel and Jewish life honestly and without compromise. When you join ARC+, you support that mission. And you also get access to members-only episodes of Call Me Back, For Heaven's Sake, ARC News Daily, and Chosen People Problems. Each of these shows covers everything from Israel's security and rising antisemitism to American politics and what it means to be Jewish in this moment. If you're able to, consider becoming a member. You can sign up for ARC Plus at arcmedia.org or follow the link in our show notes. And we're back with Nadav Ayal and Michael
30:27Koppelow. Michael, beyond punitive sanctions on Israel, how should we expect relations with the Palestinians to change in this new Congress? Historically, the U.S. relationship with the Palestinians has effectively run through Israel, right? It's been through the prism of the relationship with Israel and the peace process. And for many Democrats, that just doesn't make sense any longer. And part of it is ideological. And part of it is just the way U.S. politics are changing. When Israel had a 70 or 80 percent favorability rating among Americans and including among Democrats and the Palestinians favorability was very low, then politically this made sense. We now live in a world where a majority of Americans have an unfavorable view of Israel. And among Democrats,
31:18there is a big gap now where the Palestinians are seen far more favorably than Israel is. And so this idea that the relationship with the Palestinians should be subservient to the relationship with Israel is just changing. Now, because foreign relations, for the most part, are run by the president, you know, to Nadav's point earlier, if President Trump doesn't want to do stuff, then Democrats can pass whatever bills they like and it won't happen. But I do think what we're going to see from Democrats in this Congress is to lay the groundwork for the next Democratic president and to signal that this relationship with the Palestinians is changing. And I think you're going to see efforts to reestablish
32:03diplomatic relations with the Palestinians. President Trump closed the PLO mission in the United States. He also closed the U.S. consulate in Jerusalem that was seen as the mission on the ground to Palestinians. There will almost certainly be an effort to eliminate some of the legislation dating back decades that prohibits even contact with PLO or PA officials. And there is going to be a real movement to say the next Democratic president should recognize the state of Palestine on day one in office, divorced from a peace process. And so I think in a lot of ways, you know, if we think of Project 2025, right, something that was written ahead of time, sort of lying in wait for the next Republican
32:53president, I think what we're going to see from this Congress in many ways is the equivalent of that. Okay, so this is a very important point. What I hope listeners will understand is there's almost like three phases to think about this, right? One is what can Congress do in the next two years? It sounds like it's pretty limited, I think, but not nothing for all the reasons we're discussing. Then how does it lay the groundwork for the presidential election in 2028? And how much do things escalate on these issues in the context of Democrats competing with one another to win the presidential nomination in 2028? And then if a Democrat wins the presidency in 2028, what do they do after January of 2029 to actually
33:30dramatically change policy? And I want to, Michael, I want you to respond to this. So this is, if you look at the history of the platforms of the language and the platforms of the Democratic Party, the Democratic National Committee at their conventions every four years. They issue like a, think of it for our listeners who aren't from outside the United States, as like policy manifestos. They issue this. Now, obviously they're not, typically the party, whoever's elected, is not held to what's actually in the platform. The platform is a good signals to where the party is generally on these issues. So historically, the Democratic National Convention has issued a platform, platform language on Israel, much like the Republicans
34:11have over the years that have been very strongly pro-Israel, including as recently as 2024. So just think about Biden-Harris. So I'm quoting here from the 92-page document that was released at the Democratic National Convention in 2024. And again, keep in mind, this is, you know, some two years after close to two years of the war. So tensions were already hot. But even against that backdrop, and I'm quoting President Biden and Vice President Harris have unequivocally denounced Hamas's brutal attack on Israel and have made clear that the United States wants to see Hamas defeated. It goes on to say, Israel's security, its qualitative military edge, I'm quoting here, this is the Democratic National Convention in 2024. Israel's security,
34:58its qualitative military edge, its right to defend itself, and the 2016 memorandum of understanding is ironclad. So it it talks in these very strong language that and it's it talks also in the platform about how it's in the U.S. interest. Israel's security is in America's interest and the relationship with Israel is in America's interest. Do you think, Michael, at the 2028 Democratic Convention, the Democrats will produce language, anything comparable to what I just read? I think it depends on two factors that are unknowable today. Factor number one is the nominee, right? Because that is going to make a big difference. You know, a Chris Van Hollen or an AOC as the nominee versus Josh Shapiro or a Pete Buttigieg
35:50as the nominee, I think you can expect to have very different stances and flavors on lots of things, including on Israel. Second, and I think this is actually more important, it's going to depend on what the next Israeli government looks like, and crucially, what policies it adopts. Because you do have a large group of Democrats, it's not the entire party, but it's a large group of Democrats who are eager to get back to a place where the U.S.-Israel relationship is not a political stress point. They define themselves as pro-Israel. They want to see a strong bilateral relationship, and they simply don't feel like it's possible under the current Israeli government, and certainly not in the context of the policies of the last four years.
36:37So a lot is going to depend on that. And it's not just going to be a function of replacing Prime Minister Netanyahu. That's, I think, a necessary step, but it's not just going to be a function of replacing Prime Minister Netanyahu. That's, I think, a necessary step, but it's not sufficient. So if you have a new Israeli government with presumably Prime Minister Gadi Eisenkot, and he does start to address some of these things that Democrats feel are critical and must be addressed immediately, then there is a chance that that language that you just read can make it into the next democratic platform. I want to add something to that, which is an example from this week. So this week, just on Friday, Gadi Eisenkot published a post towards
37:16Shabbat. He received a mandate to our listeners, probably know that, received a mandate from the Israeli president to form a government. He has not succeeded until now, but he has this tendency every week he reports to the public. This was a few things he wanted to say as to the negotiations. I think it was section three in which Arab voters and the Arab members of Knesset. He said, I don't agree with many Arab members of Knesset, but the Arab citizens of Israel are 21 percent. They are an integral part of the Israeli story. And the way that the Netanyahu government has been treating them is racist attack. And I want to stress that the Declaration of Independence of Israel provides for equal rights for all its citizens. I translated parts of this statement of Eisenkot,
38:21and I was amazed by the response of people. And I think this talks to what Michael spoke about, as to the Democrats, mainstream Democrats, looking for this kind of language that they have not heard from Israeli decision makers, even if it was their like formal position, they didn't hear this kind of language. The Arab civilians of Israel are an integral part of the Israeli story. The Declaration of Independence and the Creed of Israel provide for equal rights for all, etc. And I saw the response by the spokesperson of the, I think the president of Pakistan, who was retweeting this. And this is just one example. So response by Democrats and others that were saying, this is what we're looking show. This is what Mark wrote
39:27about the statement by Gadi Eisenkot. It's not for Americans to tell Israelis how to vote or whom to entrust with their government, but it's generally heartening to hear a potential Israeli prime minister speak with such decency and honesty and patriotism and statementship. So this craving for something else coming from Israel, my colleague Amit would say a national unity government. Okay. I would say absolutely, as long as Netanyahu is not leading it. Nobody cares if it's going to be a national unity government. Everybody cares if it's going to be Netanyahu. This craving exists with Israeli allies in Washington, D.C., and they're really looking for it. And again, if Michael thinks differently, or Dan, if you think differently.
40:08Well, here's what I think. I think that everything you're saying sounds perfectly reasonable. However, I think there are forces within the Democratic Party or within the kind of progressive movement that have outsized volume and outsized organizing pressure, and I think will be an outsized volume and outsized organizing pressure. And I think we'll be an outsized force heading into the Democratic presidential primaries. And we tend to be dismissive of these people. Mehdi Hassan, Hassan Paikar, we can go on and on. There's plenty. We tend to be dismissive of them. And actually you don't, Nadav, because you got into a back and forth over the last couple of days with Hassan Piker, which is very good.
40:45It's worth our listeners reading on X. But generally speaking, I think many in the commentariat are dismissive of these kind of like carnival, what we think of as like carnival barkers. But I think we are at our own peril minimizing their ability. I don't want to say to totally shape the debate, but have huge impact in shaping the debate. And I just want to give you one example. In August, when Abdul El-Sayed won the Democratic nomination for the Senate race in Michigan, I got stupidly, foolishly, I got into this sort of like your back and forth with Hassan Piker. I got into a back and forth with Mehdi Hassan. And he basically argued that what El-Sayed's position was reasonable, that there's no difference between Netanyahu and Israel, that Israel has a war crimes, genocide, and apartheid problem, and it's not just a Netanyahu problem, meaning changing the politician doesn't solve the problem.
41:39It's an Israel problem, not a – as Michael said earlier, it's not a which politician is running Israel problem. And so Mehdi Hassan and I got got into this and I asked him point blank. I said Israel is going to have an election in a couple of months. I asked him this on X. I said, assuming there's a new prime minister, a Gadi Eizenkot, does that change your view on Israel? And he he writes me back and I'll read it here. Hi, Dan. Thanks for the serious question. Here is the serious answer. Gadi Eizenkot is opposed to a two state solution and equal rights read it here. Hi, Dan, thanks for the serious question. Here's the serious answer. Gadi Eisenkot is opposed to a two-state solution and equal rights for the Palestinians.
42:10He also helped conceive of the brutal Dahyeh Doctrine, which has killed countless civilians. He was a member of the Netanyahu War Cabinet when the genocide was at its worst in the first few months after October 7th, 2023. And then he goes on to attack Naftali Bennett. He goes on and on and on. He says, they, meaning Eisencott, Bennett, and others, may sound, I'm quoting him here, they may sound less hawkish and racist than Netanyahu and his coalition allies. They might make more conciliatory noises, like the ones, Nadav, that you're citing here. They may make more conciliatory noises and gestures, especially to Western governments. But at a policy level, they just don't differ from Netanyahu that much
42:52on the key issues, Gaza, Lebanon, Iran, equal rights, et cetera. So he says, so look, there's a simple way for Israel to change my perspective, not by swapping one hawkish anti-Arab leader for another, but by not engaging in genocide and apartheid. Actions speak louder than words or personalities. and any number of various political actors who will be very influential in the nominating process for the Democratic Party's presidential race heading into 2028. And so what you just quoted in the Dove by Eisenkot, I think, has to face that reality. I totally agree with you. I think it's a real thing. That's the reason I do address phenomenas like Hassan Taika going on the New York Times, Ezra Klein, getting the, you know, the space that he's getting any sort of denying that
43:54there is a real problem here of the legitimacy, radicalism, legitimacy to violence against Israelis and against Israel. And a real attempt to actually make Israel non-existent is something that we really cannot deny this. It's really part of what's happening today. Unfortunately, not only with some parts of the Democratic Party, but also some parts now of the far right in this country. So I think any way to sort of downplay this would be wrong. Any way to say, oh no, it's just replace Netanyahu and everything is going to be fine. Democrats are going to be the first who are going to tell you, no, it's not going to be fine. But hey, Dejan, get Israel off the news cycle. A, B, change this government.
44:41C, fight Jewish terrorism. Uphold your own laws in the West Bank. fight it the way you fought it a few years ago. And they have some sort of a positive vision for Gaza and for the Middle East of some sort of a political process. You don't need to have immediately a Palestinian state out there. And your condition has improved with moderates. Is it gone? Is the problem gone? I'm asking you guys, you know, you tell me if the problem's gone. You understand this society better than I do. But I think it will probably be improved to some degree or you have better chances there, politically speaking, right? So Michael, I want you to be able to respond to what I read and said and anything that Dav said. And then I have a follow-up question for you guys.
45:23I don't think anybody should dismiss Hassan Taiker or his ilk in the same way that to dismiss Tucker Carlson as irrelevant to the conversation among Republicans would be silly. But also, people like Hassan Piker and Mehdi Hassan are part of that DSA group. And so they're going to drive much of the conversation. You know, frankly, I think that until there's a Democratic nominee, Abdul El-Sayed may end up being the most visible national Democrat. He is a really good communicator. He's a really smart politician. He's going to be on every single Sunday show. People are going to be going to him and giving him a giant megaphone and he's going to drive the conversation. That doesn't mean that he is going
46:05to control the future of the Democratic Party or Democratic Party policy. So these people should be taken very seriously, particularly in the way that they drive the conversation. But with that said, you have to give the Democrats who are not in that camp and who want to see a better and improved bilateral relationship, some sort of ammunition to fight back with. And to Nadav's point, that has to mean policy changes so that they can hold them up and say, listen, Israel is going in a better direction. Over the last three weeks, there are so many Democrats I've heard from who wanted, they were eagerly awaiting the results of the Israeli election. They wanted to understand what was going on and they are just hoping and praying
46:51for a different government, not because they want a new punching bag, because they want to be able to get back to a more positive spot. And again, that's not every Democrat. We should be very clear-eyed about it, but it is a really large group and you got to give them something to work with, which is why if these changes don't happen with a new government and with different policies, then yeah, the, the Mehdi Hassan position is going to start becoming more and more mainstream. The way to make sure that doesn't happen is to provide some actual alternatives, not just different talking points, but actually changes on the ground. Okay, Nadav, you've been hearing murmurs about challenging Israel's
47:33longstanding ambiguity, let's call it, about its nuclear program, that there are some in democratic circles that are arguing that U.S. policy should change on this. Can you explain what nuclear ambiguity means and what were the circumstances which led to that policy? And then we can talk about what it would mean for that to change. I can explain about the Israeli nuclear ambiguity, but I am somewhat restrained as an Israeli citizen in doing so. So back in the late 1960s, there were understandings between the United States and Israel. Israel managed, according to foreign sources, to produce a nuclear military arsenal. And this was not done with the assistance or even with the blind eye of the United States.
48:20According to various researches, research and books that were published, the main element there was French in terms of the assistance for the relevant reactor. And when the U.S. administration learned about that, it tried to somehow control it. At a certain point, these horses left their stables, as we say in Hebrew. And the late 1960s, Golda Meir and the US administrations, first, I think, Lyndon Johnson, but then the Nixon administration, reached allegedly an understanding of don't ask, don't tell. Israel, that is the formula, will not be the first country to introduce, the word is introduce, nuclear weapons to the Middle East. The Israeli interpretation of the word introduce, Dan, was that it will not have a nuclear test of sorts.
49:16It will not declare out in the open that it has nuclear weapons. Therefore, it's not introducing. The U.S. maintained its position that it's about having nuclear weapons. And as a result, and mainly because of the Cold War, because Israel was winning against Soviet armed armies, and because Israel was really important during the Cold War as a U.S. asset strategically, the Americans didn't push Israel. And also Israel never joined the Non-Proliferation Treaty, the NPT, that forces countries not to have nuclear weapons. And Iran is signatory to the NPT and Israel is not. It has never been signatory to the NPT. Now, in May of 2026, and Michael, you can correct me if I'm wrong, about 30 members of Congress suddenly demanded, and it wasn't done suddenly, to actually break that ambiguity.
50:12I think they were led by Joaquin Castro from Texas. And basically, they sent a letter to Secretary of State Marco Rubio, and they demanded to get a report as to Israel's nuclear capability. For Israel, again, according to foreign sources, having a nuclear military arsenal and second strike capability is essential for its deterrence in the region. It's the ultimate guard to say to different countries around the region, if you're thinking about physically annihilating Israel, it's impossible. It's a 10 million country in an area of hundreds of millions of people, and it's constantly threatened. Now, if the US starts playing with this, if there is a new American president, and it will take a president, I want to be absolutely
51:02certain, it's not about Congress, but it will take a president to actually make that shift. This, again, is consequential for the region and for Israel's security. But what Congress can do, it can actually start pressuring the Trump administration as to that. And this has already begun with a Congress that wasn't controlled in both houses by Democrats. And there would be Democrats. And the thing there, Dan, is what you see with the Democratic Party today, is that there is a faction there that actually competes in saying terrible things about Israel. You know, one person says, let's not sell weapons, let's not give aid to Israel. The other guy says, let's not give any offensive weapons to Israel. Another one
51:46comes and says, let's not sell weapons to Israel at all, no matter what. And this competition can lead to the nuclear issue. And this is dealing really with very dangerous topics as far as the Israeli defense apparatus is concerned. Michael? So in many ways, the Iran war has sort of broken things with regard to security policy. And a lot of the votes that have happened since the Iran war started with regard to Israel should be seen as statements about Israel's role in the Iran war. So for instance, when you had 40 Democratic senators a few months ago, vote for a joint resolution of disapproval against transferring certain weapons to Israel, many of them came out and said, this isn't actually about Israeli
52:40policy writ large. It's about the Iran war and Israel's role in it. And since we want to defund the Iran war back here in the United States, why would we vote to send weapons to Israel that they can use against Iran? And I think there is this idea, and by the way, you hear it from Arab states in the region, and it's starting to creep into U.S. discourse that Iran is not the only big destabilizing force in the region. It's Israel as well. And if you believe that, then trying to put some safeguards on Israel's nuclear program, trying to, you know, expose it to the light, trying to get inspectors in, trying to have Israel subjected to the NPT, you know, it makes sense to people if you think that Israel is a regional destabilizer. Now,
53:2730 Democrats on a letter is not a lot. And I'm curious, you know, Nadav, if you have a sense that that group is significantly growing or if at the moment this remains on the fringes. But I don't think anybody should discount the way in which the Iran war is so universally opposed by Democrats and so universally disliked by Democrats that they with regard to nuclear weapons, then you settlement issues and violence in the West Bank. But beyond that, do you think it's realistic that Israel will take steps that will be sufficient to mollify some of the, let's call them reasonable critics, because I agree the extremes are probably hopeless. But what I think you, Michael, would call the reasonable critics.
54:42I absolutely do. The U.S.-Israel relationship, it has changed. I don't think we're going back to the old days, you know, 15 years, 20 years back. But that doesn't mean that this has to be a failed relationship. And there are three pillars on which this relationship has always stood. It's strategic interests, it's shared values, and it's U.S. public opinion. All of these are really under assault for different reasons. And when you look at U.S. public opinion shifting more than 20 points in just two years, we can talk about the ways in which the online discourse and anti-Semitism and all sorts of factors are at play there. But such a dramatic shift, it's because Americans look at what is happening on the ground and they don't like it. And that
55:30shift has happened, by the way, across literally all demographics, all political demographics, all social demographics. So yeah, I think that a different Israeli government that is seen as being a little more restrained on Iran, which is driving this notion of Israel not sharing the same strategic interests as the United States, because this is a war that is very unpopular here too with kind of all sides. I think an Israeli government that gets back on the side of being seen as having shared values with the United States, and that has to do with settler violence. It has to do with improving the humanitarian situation in Gaza. It also has to do with getting just back to basic language, not about two states, because there's no conceivable Israeli
56:14government that's going to talk about two states, but even just trying to say, we'd like to solve this conflict, as opposed to saying, we'd like to transfer all Palestinians out of Gaza and the West Bank. I think those things will start to impact public opinion because public opinion here is responsive to these different pressures and these variables. So are we going back to the days where Bill Clinton and Yitzhak Rabin talk about themselves as, you know, soulmates and political brothers? No, we're not. But can we get back to a point where this relationship is one that's productive for both sides, where it's not constantly being talked about as a political albatross? Yeah, I think we can. Adav, last word.
56:56Yeah, I agree with the optimism, which is surprising, I know, Dan, for you maybe. I think that because this stock is right now trading at 10 cent a stock, it's relatively easy to do just the reasonable things by management, by the board of this company called the State of Israel, in order to get back on track. Now, that doesn't mean that it's going to shoot up in Washington, D.C., as Michael said again, and be in the same place. But it does mean that there are things that could be done. And I can absolutely see a new Israeli prime minister make a big speech and say, Gazans are going to be our neighbors, not only foreseeable for the future, but for eternity. And we want them to have a good life.
57:46And I can see how this rings in the United States in a different way. And I can also see an Israeli prime minister makes an approachment to Democrats, which is something that, you know, Israel has been relatively, and I'm being very diplomatic, extremely partisan. It has abandoned its longstanding position as to bipartisanship. Now, if you ask, I want to represent Amit and the Israeli right wing in that regard, they would say it's not the case. Democrats have abandoned us. And you're blaming us for something that would have happened anyway. That could be true for some Democrats, but it definitely wasn't true for the mainstream until lately. And it all revolves on the sensation of a new leadership in Israel.
58:34And I think it can actually give a good excuse for reasonable people in this country, in the United States, to say and to ask the right questions. And I still believe, looking at the U.S. Congress and decision-making circles, that these are the questions that are interesting for both Republicans and Democrats. All right, gentlemen, thank you for this. This is a topic we will be digging into in the weeks and months ahead, because as I said earlier in the conversation, it does feel like the ground is shifting beneath our feet. You know, to quote Buffalo Springfield, there's something happening here. What it is, ain't exactly clear. So we will try, and call me back, to provide some clarity as we move through
59:14this very confusing time. And you two are great navigators for us as we broaden this conversation. So thank you. Thank you. Thanks, Sam. Here in the U.S., Jewish college students have been carrying their own weight. For years now, they have faced peer pressure and a constant stream of anti-Israel misinformation on campus, online, and everywhere they turn. They can keep arguing about Israel from thousands of miles away, or they can do the one thing that actually works. Go on a birthright trip and experience Israel for themselves. They will come back more grounded, more confident, and more connected to who they are. So if you've been waiting for the right moment to donate, this is it, because Israel needs them, and they need Israel. Go to OneTripChangesEverything.com
1:00:10and make a gift today. Birthright. One Trip Changes Everything.





